Seamus Coleman isn't up to it.

[TX Bill]

He made an amazing last gasp tackle to deny Le Fondre when the terrible Heitinga was caught out for about the tenth time that game.

He didn't have a bad game at all. He made one lapse for the penalty but other than that there were far more notable poor players in the Everton side - Heitinga and Pienaar spring to mind instantly.

Yeah, one good play doesn't make up for an overall poor match as Evertonians note on a regular basis.

Ever? Ever again? Really?

Yes, as right back, ever again. Right mid, I'm perfectly fine with. Off the bench, yes, absolutely.

 

[TX Bill]

Everton and Irealnd #1 RB.

Phil Neville, starting DM for Everton.

 

[Tubey]

Yeah, one good play doesn't make up for an overall poor match as Evertonians note on a regular basis

I personally don't think he was bad at all... It's weird, people see games differently I guess.

 

[davek]

Yeah, he was bad today. And I haven't even brought up the penalty. That was obvious. He just doesn't defend. That's his job. Bring back Hibbert asap.

Baines, Everton's best player by a country mile also doesn't defend so well at times...and he's got a settled partnership with Pienaar.

Bill, you're popcorning.

 

[Joao Moutinho]

 

[Connor]

Best right back we have IMO. Lads gotta learn, playing will help him.

Don't see why Seamus, Ok he gave away the pen, but why is he the scapegoat ?
Why not blame Heitinga who didn't have a much better game himself.

 

[harry]

Baines, Everton's best player by a country nmile also doesn't defend so well at times...and he's got a settled partnership with Pienaar.

Bill, you're popcorning.

This, surley its a wind up.

 

[Joey66]

SPOT ON - Shamus was covering two attacking players the whole match - motm in his international game in midweek too - JH can be dropped sold for me get him off the wage bill a total liability!

 

[Tubey]

Best right back we have IMO. Lads gotta learn, playing will help him.

Don't see why Seamus, Ok he gave away the pen, but why is he the scapegoat ?
Why not blame Heitinga who didn't have a much better game himself.

I agree with you Macca. Any sign of a loan yet mate?

 

[Brennan]

Knees jerking all over the show. Can't defend ? I must have imagined those two goal stopping tackles he made.

The lad has played about 6 games at right back after being played at right mid for two years.

Take a breath.

 

[Connor]

I agree with you Macca. Any sign of a loan yet mate?

Ffs. #NotMcAleny

 

[davek]

This, surley its a wind up.

It has to be. Bill's never seemed like a knee jerker before. It'll be some Texan mind game play.

 

[ijjysmith]

There's defo a Coleman thread already.

*legs it

 

[Azzurri]

It's threads like these that make it really tough to support Everton sometimes.

..........

 

[formerly manx toffee]

I think generally we are paper thin throughout really.

We have no better RB long term but made a couple of bloopers in the last couple of games that have cost us goals.

We are going to ask too much of him