tsubaki
Player Valuation: £90m
This, emphatically.
- Status
This, emphatically.
evilwebby
Player Valuation: £50m
He's never been anything other than a top pro, but Christ, have you actually seen him play this season? He's being carried by the rest of the team and oppositions have long since sussed him out as a weakness they can attack. He gets selected because we know Moyes is loyal to his favourites.
Maybe he could still look good in the Championship, but the pace of a PL game badly exposes him.
Maybe he could still look good in the Championship, but the pace of a PL game badly exposes him.
EFCNIK
Banned
I'd have him in there somewhere yes. Again, we play better with him. He's never gonna do silky dribbles or play killer balls, but in centre mid he breaks play up and plays simple passes (admittedly he's not the best but he's not dire- most of the time) and at right back he's very accomplished defensivly. Offers **** all going forward but I'd be more confident of him against Bale, Young and all the other quick little ****s from a defensive point of view than Coleman.
Half the time he just gets stick because he's Neville. Can't remember who it was against, maybe Liverpool at home this season (could be wrong), but he was our best player and people were giving him reluctant 7's all over the show.
A decent solid utility player, and a fantastic captain. Yes we will need to move on from him at some point, and improve on him to push for the top places, but for now I like him. He does the simple things well. Sometimes its not the obvious black and white of a ridiculous 50 yard pass or several million maradona turns to beat a man. Some of you 'football fans' need to look past the obvious stuff and realise what a player can bring to the table off the ball, and the simple stuff on the ball. Football isn't always a ronaldo\messi fap fest.
Mrk
Player Valuation: £40m
Neville hasn't done too badly in central midfield this season when he's been asked to cover for Gibson - he'd adept at winning the ball and he's got the best pass completion in our squad.
I do feel somewhat sorry for him though because his performances are distorted by fans depending on the result of the game, if we win he goes largely unnoticed and if we lose he immediately becomes the problem, regardless of how he performed.
I do feel somewhat sorry for him though because his performances are distorted by fans depending on the result of the game, if we win he goes largely unnoticed and if we lose he immediately becomes the problem, regardless of how he performed.
Christiffa25
Player Valuation: £35m
The stats don't lie... And Neville's role is cover for Gibson. Have we lost games because of Neville? I would say No. Do we need someone better who can have more influence on games? I would say Yes.
Until we get someone else in, when Gibson is injured then Neville is still the best option.
Other than that he's been a great signing IMO. No not the most gifted but he's done a job, he's represented the club like a true pro, and hardly missed any games through injury. Personaly unless we make Europe think this should be his last season. If we're still relying on him next season that would be a worry. Would have no problem taking him on some European nights tho when were resting players.
Until we get someone else in, when Gibson is injured then Neville is still the best option.
Other than that he's been a great signing IMO. No not the most gifted but he's done a job, he's represented the club like a true pro, and hardly missed any games through injury. Personaly unless we make Europe think this should be his last season. If we're still relying on him next season that would be a worry. Would have no problem taking him on some European nights tho when were resting players.
PN in midfield pass rate may be high but I am afraid his passing is mainly sidewards or backwords he can break the play up etc but very limited & his age is catching up on him see how he does at Rightback V UNT today - I wish Coleman could play today!
Mrk
Player Valuation: £40m
That's the job of a defensive midfielder - win the ball and pass it to players who are better distributors.
formerly manx toffee
Player Valuation: £70m
Reverse ?
Sideliner
Player Valuation: £5m
Phil Neville WAS a descent player -
He MIGHT still be a good leader -
but he IS the most overrated PL player (nevermind playing captain ) -
his basic defensive mistakes cost us the the game today -
he is a passenger in a good side and carrying him gets harder every game -
he should do the honourable thing and just hang up his boots because he is so way past his sell by date that no PL side would take him on a free transfer -
he is unfortunately overstaying his welcome - that is my honest opinion despite his glorious past acheivements
He MIGHT still be a good leader -
but he IS the most overrated PL player (nevermind playing captain ) -
his basic defensive mistakes cost us the the game today -
he is a passenger in a good side and carrying him gets harder every game -
he should do the honourable thing and just hang up his boots because he is so way past his sell by date that no PL side would take him on a free transfer -
he is unfortunately overstaying his welcome - that is my honest opinion despite his glorious past acheivements
toffeejack
Player Valuation: £100m
50k a week i think, could be wrong
- Status
