Saint Domingo
Player Valuation: £90m
I suppose we got lucky with Tony Hibbert coming from the academy, which feels very weird to say. And I'd say that collectively, we probably only started appreciating the value of attacking fullbacks once Baines was a regular from 2009 onward. Following that you had one of the best fullback pairings in the league for a solid 4/5 years from 2012. So that's the context for the first 15 or so years when you say "this millennium".
Your point is still spot on though. The Patterson and Mykolenko double announcement is horrifying when you look back at it now. That was our chance to reset and we signed a pair of bums.
Even a Hibbert though, as much as I liked him, we didn’t look to replace him at all, ever. We got lucky, let’s be honest, that a 60K kid from Ireland turned into a brilliant fullback but it wasn’t like we’d bought loads of right backs every few seasons until we found the right one. We made no attempt to replace Coleman either even though he needed competition from about 2018 until we bought Patterson.