Moyes is all i've known

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't agree with the bold mate. This season he had every opportunity to crack on. We sat in the top 4 for 4 months. He has arguably the best squad available that he's ever had. Yet he's relied on tight bit games in 4-5-1 situations. He can't go above and beyond. His caution keeps games at 1-1, 0-0, 2-1 and that where we have suffered.

He's mismanaged players for me this season:

John Heitinga - Player of the season last year and dropped without any real reason other than he favour Jagielka and a left sided centr half.

Naismith - played out of position and turned into the devil. Hated amongst fans, whilst never being given an opportunity in the role that suits him.

Jelavic - played infront of a static Fellaini who offers him no movement or creativity so has to run the channels to find the ball.

Barkley - thrown into the oblivion when really he should have been used as a direct replacement for a tyring Osman at latter stages of games and now towards the end of the season.

For me he has been the downfall this season. Some of his decisions have left us the way we are. A massive one was the inclusion of Neville in the QF last weekend.

For me he will never change. He will never know how to go above and beyond, even with the likes of Mirallas and Jelavic in the team he reverts to 4-5-1. Let's all be honest the time we finished 4th was due mainly to abit of luck. Ability to nick a goal and defende staunchly. It wasn't great to watch and since then it hasn't changed much except we've gained better calibre players.

I don't blame Moyes though, the Blue Union should be out speaking to coaches in Europe and coming up with new tactics for Moyes to employ.

Damn that Blue Union.
 
Moyes has done a decent job but I think that we shouldn't be afraid to embrace change. Lets face it, if nothing changes in the boardroom then why would there be any point in Moyes staying? He will want to try and further his career at some stage (although I don't see him managing a top English team) and We should be looking to the future instead of fretting. My mate, a Leeds fan, said we'd be like Charlton without DM! Personally I think that's the view from outsiders but in reality we still have one of the better squads in the Prem. A lot of decent managers would be happy to have our first 11.

I think DM has run his course, but for that i mainly blame the board. Would Fergie have stayed so long at Utd if the board were as useless as our lot? I think we need a new man who is up for the challenge, not a good servant who has seen his ambitions ground into the dust by a lack of funding.

Agreed. The message gets old and Moyes habbit of screaming at them, telling where and when to run etc must really piss a few off. Time for a fresh approach. Of the current squad the only players I would not want are Naismith, Neville and Heitinga. New broom please.
 
It's not. You said the downfall was to Moyes decisions. I'm agreeing with you on that, but seen as you think the Blue Union should be finding investors for Everton, I thought they could also help out with tactical decisions as well.

Do you get my point?

No, stop going off topic. If you want to discuss the BU do it in the right thread. I will wipe the floor with you in there. ;)
 
Great post by the OP.

The problem is in my opinion is people are now just fed up and i think in some quarters it makes people hate when really they are just frustrated and want change.

Moyes has been great for Everton but as time goes on his limitations become more and more annoying and leads to us all wanting change.

His role as manager has become stale and we all just need to move on. He needs to leave and go somewhere else and we need fresh ideas.

I don't hate the guy and i wish him all of the success when he leaves but 12 years is a long time without significant growth.

Not all of the lack of spending can be blamed on the board either. Let me digress. If in the games where Moyes got his tactics wrong and maybe just maybe we were more consistent and lifted a trophy or two when it was there for the begging we might have generated more revenue for being in Europe and the gradual growth might have been sped up thus us being able to afford more players and entice them with European football.

For those who just hate the guy and say he just isn't a good manager i tend to ignore as that is simply not true. He is a good manager as the work he has done at the club which we all know as fact has been fantastic there is no denying that.

The problem is he will probably never be a great manager because he cannot see past his own limitations and failures and grow on them.

I really hope he leaves and the board really consider their options and not just appoint the cheapest option as that is what i fear the most. Bringing in someone who they can afford who won't do a good job or even some flashy foreign manager who will be great short term but won't understand the English game.

Again in my opinion.
 
Couldnt agree more with the OP.

Also those figures mean nothing. Quality ahead of quanity.. Most teams spend millions on plyers who turn out to be bit part squad players. We dont do that.
 
was thinking about it before the spurs semi final, they were the team of the moment and we hammerd them, fast forward to now spurs team of the moment now ,do you think we could beat spurs in a semi under moyes? not to sure myself

We managed it in the league but that was before our collapse in January.

It is a cop out answer but I really think that if we had an even slightly stonger squad out of the top 11-14 players, we'd be much higher up the table now

That performance against Man United in the semi's in 09 was a real clutch performance, so Moyes teams are capable of it
 
We managed it in the league but that was before our collapse in January.

It is a cop out answer but I really think that if we had an even slightly stonger squad out of the top 11-14 players, we'd be much higher up the table now

That performance against Man United in the semi's in 09 was a real clutch performance, so Moyes teams are capable of it


Was it bollocks we held on to nil nil against a united third team, they also had a clear panalty not given. i think we had about 3 shots in the second half. Nothing like big joe's Everton in 95 against spurs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top