Mason Holgate

Status
Not open for further replies.

Just seems strange that we sign this touted young lad, who seems to be getting good reviews in the youth set up, yet we spend most of January going after another young Right Back (In Byram) and we're pulling players like Pennington back early from loans to try and paper over the cracks for Saturday, when we've got this lad just sitting there and not being used

Again, strange
 

Mikey_Fitzgerald said:
Just seems strange that we sign this touted young lad, who seems to be getting good reviews in the youth set up, yet we spend most of January going after another young Right Back (In Byram) and we're pulling players like Pennington back early from loans to try and paper over the cracks for Saturday, when we've got this lad just sitting there and not being used

Again, strange
Click to expand...
Pennington is 2 years older, has been at the club a lot longer, and has played more than double the amount of games in the football league. He also did well when given some minutes in the cups earlier this season.
 
Mikey_Fitzgerald said:
Just seems strange that we sign this touted young lad, who seems to be getting good reviews in the youth set up, yet we spend most of January going after another young Right Back (In Byram) and we're pulling players like Pennington back early from loans to try and paper over the cracks for Saturday, when we've got this lad just sitting there and not being used

Again, strange
Click to expand...

Oh here we go.
 
Mikey_Fitzgerald said:
Just seems strange that we sign this touted young lad, who seems to be getting good reviews in the youth set up, yet we spend most of January going after another young Right Back (In Byram) and we're pulling players like Pennington back early from loans to try and paper over the cracks for Saturday, when we've got this lad just sitting there and not being used

Again, strange
Click to expand...

Holgate will be a centre half so it doesnt escape the fact the we NEEDED a backup senior right back.
 
Scolari said:
Pennington is 2 years older, has been at the club a lot longer, and has played more than double the amount of games in the football league. He also did well when given some minutes in the cups earlier this season.
Click to expand...

To be fair though, Pennington's a centre-back isn't he? He looks about as natural at right back as Stones does.
 
Mikey_Fitzgerald said:
Just seems strange that we sign this touted young lad, who seems to be getting good reviews in the youth set up, yet we spend most of January going after another young Right Back (In Byram) and we're pulling players like Pennington back early from loans to try and paper over the cracks for Saturday, when we've got this lad just sitting there and not being used

Again, strange
Click to expand...

....perhaps the coaches don't feel he's good enough.
 

kithnou said:
Playing in the youth team recently. We have been watching him there. Don't think he is injured.
Click to expand...
Just to be clear its u21 he's playing at, usually we'll talk about u 18 as Youth.
He played alongside Conolly at Centre back two matches ago , against Chelsea, and they both got good reviews. Holgate may have been the third youngster in contention last Saturday, although more likely to have been Dowell. Anyway, it would seem Connoly has nudged ahead of him as Holgate remained with the U 21s last Monday.
Although he's got some good reviews ,he's made some highly visible mistakes at u 21 level , the most recent being a poorly hit back pass against Middlesborough which gifted them a goal. Youngsters will make mistakes, so shrug and move on but it can affect perception on when they are ready to be exposed to the first team. He's played his first games for England u 20s this season, appeared on the bench for the first team at least once but didn't get on , and has generally made good progress . There is a danger of him being compared with Stones and Galloway re our expectations of him but he's still only 19, plenty of time for him to be developed further.
 
Bruce Wayne said:
To be fair though, Pennington's a centre-back isn't he? He looks about as natural at right back as Stones does.
Click to expand...
That is the position he has played on loan and the position he has been recalled to cover. My point was that this makes sense and shouldn't be viewed as Holgate not being good enough, just rightly behind Pennington in the pecking order.
 
blueloon said:
Just to be clear its u21 he's playing at, usually we'll talk about u 18 as Youth.
He played alongside Conolly at Centre back two matches ago , against Chelsea, and they both got good reviews. Holgate may have been the third youngster in contention last Saturday, although more likely to have been Dowell. Anyway, it would seem Connoly has nudged ahead of him as Holgate remained with the U 21s last Monday.
Although he's got some good reviews ,he's made some highly visible mistakes at u 21 level , the most recent being a poorly hit back pass against Middlesborough which gifted them a goal. Youngsters will make mistakes, so shrug and move on but it can affect perception on when they are ready to be exposed to the first team. He's played his first games for England u 20s this season, appeared on the bench for the first team at least once but didn't get on , and has generally made good progress . There is a danger of him being compared with Stones and Galloway re our expectations of him but he's still only 19, plenty of time for him to be developed further.
Click to expand...
Great stuff mate. You are the man!
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top