Match Thread Manchester City(1) Vs Everton(2) - Capital One Cup - Semi Final 2nd Leg - Weds 27th Jan - 19:45 KO

Status
Not open for further replies.
In Rocky III, Sylvester Stallone rides his motorbike up to the statue of himself in Philly and, with a classic Rocky grunt, launches his helmet at his likeness. He knows he’s lost the Eye of the Tiger. How many of our players have too?

We are, as Jose Mourinho might say, specialists in failure.

Okay, an unlucky deflection or a linesman who must have been desperate for City to score didn’t help us, but everything except Barkley’s goal reeked of negativity, fear and half-heartedness.

The midfield combination of Barry and Cleverley was so insipid and weak all night that it would have been better starting two kids who would have given everything. Barry has been exceptional this season, but his lack of awareness for the De Bruyne goal was, as Roberto would say, ‘sensational’- for all the wrong reasons.

John Stones continues to believe his own hype as the world’s greatest defender while simultaneously forgetting how to defend. Watching the replays of Aguero’s header this morning made for embarrassing viewing. He must have been thinking about how good he’ll look next to Gary Cahill or Gerard Pique because he certainly wasn’t thinking about defending the ball into the box. Martinez has created his own Frankenstein: a beautiful player, but a weak defender.

But it wasn’t just the men on the pitch displaying weakness. The substitutions made by the manager bordered on insane. We’d gone one down in a cup-tie with not long left on the clock and he put on a right back. Maybe several seasons ago Coleman would have been the right option, but a half-fit, rusty player who isn’t as offensive as he used to be made no sense. If I were Aaron Lennon I would have had strong words with Martinez after the game.

And Deulofeu should also be aggrieved. Not one player on the pitch looked like they were going to create anything substantial apart from Gerry. Barkley had faded and he was our one chance at carving something out, and I don’t think I can forgive Roberto for substituting him. This was an ‘incredible’- to quote the manager again- chance for silverware this season, and once again we’ve bottled it.

One journalist claims Martinez was ‘powerless’ to stop the defeat and maybe we were. As soon as De Bruyne scored everybody inside the stadium knew we were heading out. Others want to see the manager sacked. For me, the manager’s fate is no longer a concern of mine. This season turned into a relegation battle on Sunday and bar a miraculous run in the FA Cup there’s no excitement left. The spectre that looms largest over Goodison is that of the big clubs who will undoubtedly break this talented squad apart.

Back to Rocky III, and Mickey says to Sly: ‘The worst thing that could happen to a fighter happened to you: you got civilized’. It’s happened to us too. We’ve gotten too civilized. And all the Clubber Lang’s of the league have got hungrier and hungrier while we sat here and believed our own hype. To paraphrase Apollo Creed, we need to get mad again.
 
Just saying on talksport, some beaut has got a pic of the ball crossing the line, and they have done something with it that shows the ball never went out because 'the ball was still over hanging the line'

Haha! strange that, I've had the 3rd goal up on photoshop & added a line blatantly showing Aguero is both head & shoulders offside.

Oh and the ball was out.
 
City had 19 attempts to 4 and hit the post twice. Yes they were awarded a goal that definitely should have been disallowed but they have a case in saying that Barkleys goal should have been disallowed also.

We weren't robbed by the officials we were never going to withstand their assault the way we set up, as in the same way we set up every match and with (it hurts to say this) Leon Osman as a passenger, cleverly on the pitch and our first choice RB warming the bench so stones could be shoe horned into the team.

Everton played close to perfectly in the first half. And Osman was at the heart of everything they did.

It would have been an enormous risk to start Coleman for the first time against City. He cannot be match fit.

McCarthy wasn't match fit either, and Besic was injured, so there was little choice but to play Cleverley.

Mori was fantastic - it would certainly have been a mistake to play Stones instead of him.

The game was a great exhibition of football skills.
 
Phil Jagielka has branded Martin Atkinson 'arrogant' as Everton's fury towards the referee mounted following their controversial exit from the Capital One Cup.

Everton's captain – like his manager Roberto Martinez – was furious that Kevin De Bruyne's goal, which gave Manchester City a 2-1 lead and levelled the semi-final on aggregate, was allowed to stand after Raheem Sterling ran the ball out of play before crossing.

Jagielka tried to speak with Atkinson – who has history with Everton – immediately but the England international claims the match official gave him a sarcastic reply and said he 'just told me that our defending was brilliant'.
 
Calm down, you have your opinions I have mine. Your opinions aren't divinely fact.

Coleman looked fit when he came on. Do you have inside info? Martinez said both he an McCarthy were fit. I have to take his word over yours. Sorry

Stones got away with a penalty in the league game. Got caught out by Sterling because he's not a rb. The officials gave us a clean sheet that day.

Didn't think Osman did well. A couple of good passes i grant you. Class is permanent. Unfortunately he's too slow these days. Navas was brought on to exploit that.

At least we agree about Kone

No, they're not. Neither are yours - yet you have been stating them as fact...

Coleman obviously wasn't deemed fit enough to start the game, or he'd have started. He said that McCarthy was medically fit, but didn't know what role he would play (during the presser). He said Coleman was potentially fit to start - he decided to go with the defence that kept the first clean sheet against City since January 2015....

Osman is too slow. Navas was brought on. We then took Osman off. Navas' threat was negated. During the time when Navas and Osman were on the pitch together, did City scroe? No.

Well yeh, Kone is the whipping boy like, cos he's turd... but, saying that, I saw the logic in the change at the time in that he wanted to try and get support to Rom. Retrospectively, it should have been Lennon.
 
But it wasn’t just the men on the pitch displaying weakness. The substitutions made by the manager bordered on insane. We’d gone one down in a cup-tie with not long left on the clock and he put on a right back. Maybe several seasons ago Coleman would have been the right option, but a half-fit, rusty player who isn’t as offensive as he used to be made no sense. If I were Aaron Lennon I would have had strong words with Martinez after the game.

Yet others are criticising Roberto because he selected Stones to play at right back in place of Coleman.

Roberto just can't win. It's another stick to hit him with.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top