John Stones' Value

What price would you consider 'acceptable' to sell John Stones?

  • £15-£20m

  • £20-£25m

  • £25-£30m

  • £30-£35m

  • £35-£40m

  • £45-£50m

  • £50m+

  • £40-£45m


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
If this saga has done nothing else it has probably put about 15million on the value of John Stones.

I think Chelsea may have miscalculated in deciding their strategy.
I think that Chelsea looked at age, experience, CL experience, international caps when deciding on a value. They knew there would be a premium because he is English but that Everton would be keen to sell because of constant money shortages.

Let the opening bid be 20m. It will be rejected but sets the price range in which the transfer would occur...25M if Chelsea get lucky but 30m tops and Everton have a new British record for a defender...everybody wins.

They simply did not realise how highly valued he is at Everton and how upset Everton would become by the tactics used to unsettle the player, maybe even didn't realise how highly rated Stones is in football generally.
The tactics have changed dramatically but the damage has been done as the reference by RM last about money not being able to buy everything proves.

Chelsea then relied on John Stones pushing for a transfer and this is the last hope for Chelsea and again after last night that doesn't appear too promising.

They have a couple of options remaining imo.
1. Look at the purchase of Stones as a longer term project and accept that it may have to wait at least twelve months.
2. Make an offer that even Everton fans are saying we should accept. 40m plus Remy for instance would make us all think twice..it certainly would make me think twice. But, don't try offering us loans or players they simply want off their books.
 
Can't believe all the abuse Stones got last night. Really a way to get him to want to stay. Or try his best on the the pitch. Not like he hasn't been doing his best on the pitch.
 
Not for sale now we need a stopper along side Stones great in the air a Derek Mountfield, Subbs , Gough style player like centre back and rest Jags as he is as shaky as last season early on!
I think we are all ignoring Browning.
I think he would have played last night if RM didn't want to send a message to Chelsea by playing Stones and he didn't come on because the manager was forced to ake two substitutions at half time and the game was never totally secured.
 
I think we are all ignoring Browning.
I think he would have played last night if RM didn't want to send a message to Chelsea by playing Stones and he didn't come on because the manager was forced to ake two substitutions at half time and the game was never totally secured.
I thought Browning would play last night, I would like to see if he can win the ball in the air from a set piece as the pair we have can not
 
Just changed my vote to £50m+

But only because there is no "£60m plus Zouma, plus cancellation of remaining outstanding Lukaku fee, plus Eva Carneiro, plus cheese on crying Portuguese on toast" option. Any chance you can fix that?

Especially the Eva Carneiro bit!
 
If we got 30m-35m we could get an adequate replacement however with the likes of Johnny Evans going for 12m and then assuming 3m for for Barnsley we would be left with 15m and when you consider fees etc less than that even. We would also have swapped a 21 year old with a 27 year old who would need replaced in 4 years. Most young CBs would be too risky to consider and in fact we have a couple already.

Ultimately really good players are hard to find and for a club like ours even harder to attract to want to come. We either "grow" them ourselves by buying potential young or we over-pay for those that aren't quite good enough for the top teams. We've recently since Martinez took over been operating this strategy and I don't think it's to sell them on.

We have Barkley, Stones, Besic, Lukaku and Deulofeu. All 22 and under and others in our youth teams. I want to see how good they become. Selling Stones might lead to a slippery slope.

Of course they will most likely go at some point but 21 is too soon. So I went for the highest figure 50m+.
 
Last edited:
Can't believe all the abuse Stones got last night. Really a way to get him to want to stay. Or try his best on the the pitch. Not like he hasn't been doing his best on the pitch.
He got very little abuse mate. Lukewarm reception at first, literally a couple of isolated boos in the first few minutes which prompted warm applause from a lot of fans for his next few touches. Rest of the match went back to very little noticeable comment either way. Whole teamed booed v loudly at half time and one fan on film calling him a rat. Went off to warm applause which he returned nearly all the way to the tunnel although personally I thought at the end that he was looking a bit stressed as he went off not like someone who had just enjoyed a good cup win.
 
If it wasn't for this nob head stadium project that Kenwright wants to waste money on, then we would already have said that he ain't for sale at any price. Unfortunately, there are still plenty of Evertonians who think a nob head stadium project would be in Everton's best interests, when in reality it won't benefit anyone because it won't actually happen, an even if it did, the main beneficiaries will be Kenwright and Earle, the people who have been playing you like a fiddle for years.
It is also the best chance to get rid of them and be bought over by a sugar daddy.
 
At this time right now john stones is priceless, considering the time we have left to find a replacement and our boards reputation for being rubbish at buying players.

His value will once again change 1st jan 2016
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top