Current Affairs Israel is an apartheid state

Status
Not open for further replies.
All that money and then firework rockets are the best they can come up with
 
Sorry, are you talking about indigenous land rights?

Surely these apply most of all to the people who actually lived there, whose families have lived there for hundreds / thousands of years prior to 1947 and whose descendants were in many cases Jews who converted to Christianity and then Islam?

Yes that's my point, it seems you think I am referring to Judaism when I refer to Jews. If it wasn't clear I am referring to the ethnic group which originated as a culture in the Levant and beyond and have been continually displaced over millennia.

While some people in the thread have been pushing a race angle the issue here is almost 100% cultural, yes after the Turkish occupation ended it would have been ideal if there could have been one state where peoples individual rights and freedoms were protected and they held hands and sang Kum ba Yah, but it was clear between 1918 and 1947 that was unlikely to happen, which led to the partition plan and the current clusterf**k.

I have always been pro-Palestinian, my kids are half Arabic and my mother in law is currently a refugee living in Jordan, so I do think I am looking at this through an objective lens in wanting a solution that will be effective rather than 'righteous'. I would be lying if I said I wasn't surprised and that my sympathy didn't wane when they voted in a Islamist terror group in the 2005 elections, any clear thinking westerner who tries to justify that, clearly thinks that Palestinians are less than, and not capable of anything better,

There has to be a two-state solution if the never ending cycle of misery is going to end, and the borders are going to be something along the lines of the 1967 borders with land swaps, any conversations outside of that are noise in the signal that will lead to more death and trauma.
 
I believe that bombing over 30,000 men, women and children to smithereens is not right

No one apart from psychopaths takes any comfort in the death of innocent people, I agree with you.
Apart from the people who were Hamas militants, everyone one of those deaths is a tragedy, for the people killed and the family who mourn them.

That is a no-brainer, but what's the counter narrative?

How does a government respond to this?

In any disagreement we have two options, conversations or violence. If we expect non-violent responses from Israel why can we not expect them from Hamas?
 
Also, more than half of the occupiers have zero Palestinian/israel dna - they are European only. Laughable they try and claim the lands that the Palestinians have occupied for millennia

Mate, the hole you keep digging for yourself and now descending into flat out biological essentialism.

Ashkenazi Jews who migrated to Europe still descend from the same group of Jews that never left the middle east, even if you deny their initial right to a homeland surely you believe that the people who do have a right, can establish a society where they welcome whoever they want as most countries do today.

Follow your reasoning to the end, how many people living in the UK now have what would be considered *European DNA? Don't go down that road, it goes to a bad place.

*for the record I am a Darwinian, we all originated in Africa and can all trace our roots back to a handful of women that lived there about 200k years ago. All differences are cultural and easily overcome with an acceptance of our common humanity and a tolerance of our differences.
 
A truly insane statement and dangerous rhetoric being used to whip people up by a guy who has downplayed Islamaphobia throughout his career. Let's just ignore the many Jews who join these apparently deadly protests. Perfectly suits the Tory Party line of "antisemitism bad, Islamaphobia fine".

Excellent point.

The members of the Jewish community that took exception to the protests at a ladies' match at Arsenal ascribe anti-Semitism to a protest against war criminal actions carried out by a political regime.

This is simply wrong.

Many faithful Jewish people are also protesting under the title 'Not in my Name'.

Protests against Putin's regime are not racist against the Russian people.

Protests against US foreign policy from Vietnam to the Middle East are not racist against Americans.

Terrible deeds have been done in the name of Islam but they do not warrant genocide against innocent people, men women or children.
 
Mate, the hole you keep digging for yourself and now descending into flat out biological essentialism.

Ashkenazi Jews who migrated to Europe still descend from the same group of Jews that never left the middle east, even if you deny their initial right to a homeland surely you believe that the people who do have a right, can establish a society where they welcome whoever they want as most countries do today.

Follow your reasoning to the end, how many people living in the UK now have what would be considered *European DNA? Don't go down that road, it goes to a bad place.

*for the record I am a Darwinian, we all originated in Africa and can all trace our roots back to a handful of women that lived there about 200k years ago. All differences are cultural and easily overcome with an acceptance of our common humanity and a tolerance of our differences.
But you’re conveniently missing the vital point…. There are people already living there. Forcibly taking their homes and land is illegal but you totally ignore it

Once again , twisting the narrative to suit your agenda
 
Last edited:
Weapons grade irony in a conversation where the only group who have a murderous agenda are Hamas and who say the quiet parts out loud.




I can share countless vids of Israelis talking about the desired deaths of Palestinians.
You really do pick and chose the most basic issues and then fabricate some bizarre reason for justifying the murderous occupation
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top