2017/18 Idrissa Gueye

Status
Not open for further replies.
He is a stats driven hipster favourite, who adds nothing and let's teams attack us directly down the middle, offering our already weakened defence no protection whatsoever. And because of his reputation, his performances and mistakes are dismissed because we are "Lucky to have him". Same with Pickford. Absolutely bullet proof. While other players get bombed out for the slightest error.

Noticed quite a few people have started to say this recently whereas i'd argue that the people who don't rate him constantly come out with the daft "people claim he's a good player because he runs round a bit" line. Just like they did with McCarthy who also has a role in the team (when he's actually fit) that requires him to 'run round a lot', make tackles and play 5-10 yard balls to players with more ability on the ball. Just because the team is playing poorly and the fans want the players to show more won't make Gana and Schneiderlin become something they're not. E.g a Ross Barkley type whose going to run with it for 20-30 yards and have a shot. There is no argument that they're not performing to their level but to call him bang average is wrong in my opinion.

He's not performing well enough but it's a team problem. I'd say even Pickford's performance suffered on Thursday for one of the first times this season and that's because the whole set up is an absolute mess.

Gana is a quality player and if he was in a better team he'd show it. Kante would be poor in this current team but i'm sure i'll get a comeback about how he's won the league twice which he has, except it was for 2 teams full of confidence with every player playing pretty much to their maximum level of ability and with a manager who has the team playing effectively. The complete opposite to this current Everton side.
 
No one was saying he was crap last season. No one.
Player of the year for a reason.

As I said I do like the guy, but like Schneiderlin he just hasn't taken enough responsibility this season. Between them their poor form has been a big contributing factor to our issues on the pitch.
 
Evertonians are great, we slate our best players then wonder why some want to leave or not sign contracts. Anyone with a knowledge on football can see this guy is a really good player, when the whole team is playing awful there really is no point trying to judge individual players....well apat from Williams :)
 
I can't articulate how unbelievably poor this guy was today, appalling, utter coward in every challenge.
 
Wow, the state of a few of you. He has a job in the team and does it. Others on the team.....not so much. Place your anger elsewhere.
 
Wow, the state of a few of you. He has a job in the team and does it. Others on the team.....not so much. Place your anger elsewhere.

Usually yes.

But not today mate ...actually played like Klaassen today.

We don't have room for passengers, we're already carrying Rooney.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top