Everton v Chelsea. 30th August at 17.30.

[DanEFC92]

Howard - 4
Coleman - 7
Jagielka - 2
Distin - 3
Baines - 6
McGeady - 6
McCarthy - 6
Barry - 6
Mirallas - 8
Naismith - 6
Lukaku - 5

Eto'o - 6

You had an issue with me giving Naismith a 7, but you score him one point less? Ok....

And how did Barry warrant a 6?

 

[Boss_Blue]

Naismith wasn't kept quiet all game that's nonsense he was ace, as were Miralles, Coleman, and Eto'o when he came on.

Everyone else varied across a scale of average to okay except Jags who had a shocker and Besic who I hope can pick himself up from that debut.

 

[davek]

Haven't seen the game and don't want to after seeing the score, but were they really that bad? Again?

As bad as you're ever likely to see. To call it clown shoes is an insult to clowns.

 

[BlueToff]

Very harsh those mate, even considering how bad the defence was.

Howard - 4
Coleman - 6
Jags - 2
Distin - 2
Baines - 4
McGeady - 6
McCarthy - 6
Barry - 4
Mirallas - 7
Naismith - 7
Lukaku - 5

Eto'o - 7

I meant to say on Coleman and McGeady mate

 

[Big Fat Sam]

Howard - 6 - Couldn't do much about the goals imo
Coleman - 7 - Great in the first half, decent in the second, roasted for one of the goals we conceded, I think
Jagielka - 0 - Pathetic
Distin - 1 - Nearly as pathetic as his clown colleague ainand supposed capt
Baines - 6 - Looked decent, but somehow a little lost without his mate Stevie P
McGeady - 5 - Toothless really, with a few moments of good place
McCarthy - 5 - He's a good player but SEVERELY lacks creativity, do we need two defensive midfielders in front of defence?
Barry - 5 - See McCarthy
Mirallas - 8 - Our best player, great goal, started and finished the move
Naismith - 7 - Took his goal well and looked decent in the air, as usual
Lukaku - 3 - Thought he was rubbish but clearly isn't fit

Eto'o - 7 - Looked up for it and scored a super goal

 

[kithnou]

As bad as you're ever likely to see. To call it clown shoes is an insult to clowns.

Damn..I would rather see Stones get a game and learn from such a score line. Surely must come in. I would say the same for Robles...but I can't

 

[davek]

You had an issue with me giving Naismith a 7, but you score him one point less? Ok....

And how did Barry warrant a 6?

No, I placed him amongst a number if players who had just better than average games as au saw it. Mirallas and Coleman were a clear best performers for us though.

 

[kithnou]

Howard - 6 - Couldn't do much about the goals imo
Coleman - 7 - Great in the first half, decent in the second, roasted for one of the goals we conceded, I think
Jagielka - 0 - Pathetic
Distin - 1 - Nearly as pathetic as his clown colleague ainand supposed capt
Baines - 6 - Looked decent, but somehow a little lost without his mate Stevie P
McGeady - 5 - Toothless really, with a few moments of good place
McCarthy - 5 - He's a good player but SEVERELY lacks creativity, do we need two defensive midfielders in front of defence?
Barry - 5 - See McCarthy
Mirallas - 8 - Our best player, great goal, started and finished the move
Naismith - 7 - Took his goal well and looked decent in the air, as usual
Lukaku - 3 - Thought he was rubbish but clearly isn't fit

Eto'o - 7 - Looked up for it and scored a super goal

 

[davek]

Howard - 6 - Couldn't do much about the goals imo
Coleman - 7 - Great in the first half, decent in the second, roasted for one of the goals we conceded, I think
Jagielka - 0 - Pathetic
Distin - 1 - Nearly as pathetic as his clown colleague ainand supposed capt
Baines - 6 - Looked decent, but somehow a little lost without his mate Stevie P
McGeady - 5 - Toothless really, with a few moments of good place
McCarthy - 5 - He's a good player but SEVERELY lacks creativity, do we need two defensive midfielders in front of defence?
Barry - 5 - See McCarthy
Mirallas - 8 - Our best player, great goal, started and finished the move
Naismith - 7 - Took his goal well and looked decent in the air, as usual
Lukaku - 3 - Thought he was rubbish but clearly isn't fit

Eto'o - 7 - Looked up for it and scored a super goal

Harsh but fair!

 

[Big Fat Sam]

Harsh but fair!

The fella should be ashamed of himself, being the anchor of our team, wearing the armband and doing little to stop us shipping 10 goals in three games. He's past it.

 

[sageyefc]

Howard - 6 - Couldn't do much about the goals imo
Coleman - 7 - Great in the first half, decent in the second, roasted for one of the goals we conceded, I think
Jagielka - 0 - Pathetic
Distin - 1 - Nearly as pathetic as his clown colleague ainand supposed capt
Baines - 6 - Looked decent, but somehow a little lost without his mate Stevie P
McGeady - 5 - Toothless really, with a few moments of good place
McCarthy - 5 - He's a good player but SEVERELY lacks creativity, do we need two defensive midfielders in front of defence?
Barry - 5 - See McCarthy
Mirallas - 8 - Our best player, great goal, started and finished the move
Naismith - 7 - Took his goal well and looked decent in the air, as usual
Lukaku - 3 - Thought he was rubbish but clearly isn't fit

Eto'o - 7 - Looked up for it and scored a super goal

About right, although mcgeady needs higher score though, played some lovely passes through to teamates

 

[davek]

Damn..I would rather see Stones get a game and learn from such a score line. Surely must come in. I would say the same for Robles...but I can't

He's a bit if a nervous Nerys though too.

 

[davek]

The fella should be ashamed of himself, being the anchor of our team, wearing the armband and doing little to stop us shipping 10 goals in three games. He's past it.

I agree mate. The feller's hopeless.

 

[kithnou]

He's a bit if a nervous Nerys though too.

At least we get game time into him..and surely is a step or two faster in movement

 

[DanEFC92]

No, I placed him amongst a number if players who had just better than average games as au saw it. Mirallas and Coleman were a clear best performers for us though.

Ranked him slightly higher than you did and get the 'ha ha ha' treatment.

Didn't answer my Barry question, who was shocking throughout.