Current Affairs EU In or Out

In or Out

  • In

    Votes: 688 67.9%
  • Out

    Votes: 325 32.1%

  • Total voters
    1,013
Status
Not open for further replies.
I hope so Bruce. We need the remain people to get behind the vote. To continue denying it is what will cause unrest and division. It is causing uncertainty and becoming a self fulfilling prophecy.......Either we believe in democracy or we don't, there can be no shades of grey......

The Leavers have not helped matters by the vacuum that has emerged since the vote. With Boris (undoubtedly the figurehead of the campaign) jumping ship and Farage and Hannan admitting that a number of key campaign pledges were dishonest, there has been a huge amount of uncertainty created around just what is going to happen.

The Bank of England clearly thought about what might happen in the event of a leave vote as Carney was right on the spot attempting to stabilize markets, but no one else seems to have a bloody clue, which is frankly shocking given how long the campaign went on for. I mean did leave have no plan on which to base their campaign? It sadly seems they did not.

Until that comes to pass I'm not sure what it is people are supposed to get behind? Give people something to get behind and you might have a chance.
 
You don't think this vote has legitimized racist thoughts and actions in any way? I'll say again, that was predicted prior to the referendum and dismissed as scaremongering, yet not only have those on the political extremes lauded the result, but there has also been a rise in racist incidences across the country. So those fears have been very much vindicated.

Regarding the skilled workers, you might be but surely you can see that the general climate in the country is more anti-foreigner now than it was a year ago. Whether someone is technically allowed to remain in the country, if there's a perception that someone isn't wanted then no amount of technicalities will persuade them to stay.

There has been much written about how commerce dislikes uncertainty, but the same is true at an individual level, as there has been absolutely no meat on the bones from leave campaigners about just what will happen once we leave in regards to EU citizens living and working in Britain now. You have people with mortgages and businesses that may have to leave the country, you have researchers that are being shut out of bids due to the uncertainty involved.

Regarding your final point, of course the end of western civilization is hyperbole, unquestionably. What I do think however is that the probability of unrest has increased significantly, and I said as much several times on this forum before the vote. Ireland has an increased probability of unrest. Scotland and the breakup of the Union seems to have increased in likelihood. The rise of extremist political parties has grown in probability since the election, as has the prospect of an extremist entering the White House. Whilst it's unlikely that these things will signal the end of western civilization, none of them are positive in regards to the way of life we cherish so dearly.

As for war, well history is littered with examples of wars emerging when countries have reason to hate on one another, so it seems reasonable to me that if the EU falls apart that this raises the possibility of war blighting Europe again. That's not fear mongering, that's just observing history. The whole idea of the likes of the EU and NATO was to ensure that the world is so inter-connected in terms of the flow of trade, people and information that war would be nonsensical, and it has worked in that we haven't had conflict in western-Europe since then.

You may regard this as unlikely, but we've seen in this country the rise in hate-crime against those who the nutters feel legitimized in blaming for whatever woes have befallen them. Now place yourself in a scenario whereby those nutters are actually in government, as we might have soon in places like Austria or maybe even France and America. Is that a nice picture to you? Is that a picture you see coming out well?
No I don't think a vote to leave has legitimized racist thoughts or actions in any way shape or form. The scumbags doing harm to their fellow human being's based on where they were born are beneath contempt and would of committed their vile acts at some point anyway so it's unfair to use a perfectly legitimate vote in the referendum to give them their excuse. The referendum isn't why these knuckle draggers are doing what they've done just the excuse they use and I'm sorry but I refuse to forfeit my democratic right to vote for what I believe to be right because a gang of animals abuse the result.

I don't agree the atmosphere in the country is anti foreign, just anti unskilled foreign cheep labour which is as much an abuse to the foreign unskilled worker (who is far less likely to mobilizeand fight for fair rights and pay) as it is for British workers who subsequently have more competition who are prepared to work longer, harder hours for unacceptable levels of low pay. We need to look into individual cases of people and decided on merit of they have contributed to society, I'm sure large numbers will qualify but your fooling yourself if you think all of them do. We dont actually know if anyone will have to leave the country do we?

I'm honestly sorry if anyone feels unwelcome here, that was not my intention when I voted and I believe most of the leave camp feel the same way. It's funny how you talk about being made to feel unwelcome because quite a few remainers have made it perfectly clear what they think of leavers and I can from first hand experience lots of unjust things have been thrown around and threats have been made against 'you horrible racists'. The point is I would never accuse most remainers of being like that, because I know that would be unfair to label perfectly good people as something bad because a small group of idiots have behaved in an abhorrent way.

The reason for all the uncertainty about what happens to everyone now is the Government's fault. It was their job to plan ahead for the possibility of Brexit and if they've made no plans when your anger should be directed at them. It's not the leave voters job to decide and lots of people voted for very different reasons anyway so you would find it hard to find one overriding voice. The best solution to this imo would be a second referendum not on if we are to leave (as this has been decided and to change it would be anti democratica) but on how and when we leave. That would clear a lot of things up and ease people's minds from the instability if nothing else. Also much of the instability has been caused by disgusting scaremongering by the media and embittered Bremainers.

Regarding your point on Ireland, the possibility of unrest is always bubbling under the surface there and was always going to rise again. I refuse to let the threat of more trouble in Ireland stop me voting my way. The Scots? They can whistle into the wind because they won't get into the EU, it's funny how you talk about racism but ignore the disgraceful attitude the SNP shown towards the English. If anyone has legitimized racism it's the SNP.

The political landscape hasn't changed at all, don't be fooled by 2020, the Blairite's will have reclaimed the Labour party and will no doubt win vs a Teresa May lead Tory party. The political elite will continue to rule the roost. This referendum is the exception not the rule.

I see you have fallen into the trap of thinking it was the EU that prevented war since the end of WW2. It had nothing to do with British and American troops being based in Germany for many years? Furthermore the EU only came into being in 92 so to give them credit for stopping wars is a bit farfetched. The reason we will never again see wars on the scale of WW2 is the threat of nuclear weapons. Nothing whatsoever to do with the EU. The other real reason it's unlikely we'll ever see and Western Europe war again is because of the non-stop 24/7 news coverage and the internet. People aren't the poor helpless saps they were 70 years ago. Do you honestly think ANY western government would be able to convince their population to agree with conscription?

The rise In hate crime can easily be delt with by giving proper punishment's to those who commit crimes of this nature. In fact I'd like to see proper jail terms for people committing such crimes. If the rise in far right governments is coming then it's all the more reason to do something now before it gets to bad. Just shouting down people who are crying out for something to be done is not the answer. People have legitimate concerns over immigration that nobody will answer without using the word racist. This is why the uneducated look to somebody prepared to do something about it, like Trump. If you want to prevent this then the solution is simple: listen to people's concerns, acknowledge that they have a point (and most of the time they do) and help them fix the problem. It doesn't look nice to me at all but I blame the fools who have shut down debates they find uncomfortable and only engage with like minded thinkers who look on with contempt at those who they disagree with.

Your insinuating that everyone voted to leave because of the right wing. Well that's nonsense. I know several members of TUSC who all voted to leave because of the EU's pro austerity stance and their contempt of workers unions. This idea that everyone who voted to leave is a part of some big right wing conspiracy is madness. You talk about being afraid of how things will go with the right wing? Well let me tell you, to just disregard democracy is the most sure fire way to guarantee an extremist government I can think of. Just remember this, it might of been fools and democracy that made Hitler the Chancellor of Germany but it was this same wilful disregard of democracy that made the the fuhrer of the Reich.
 
Last edited:
No I don't think a vote to leave has legitimized racist thoughts or actions in any way shape or form. The scumbags doing harm to their fellow human being's based on where they were born are beneath contempt and would of committed their vile acts at some point anyway so it's unfair to use a perfectly legitimate vote in the referendum to give them their excuse. The referendum isn't why these knuckle draggers are doing what they've done just the excuse they use and I'm sorry but I refuse to forfeit my democratic right to vote for what I believe to be right because a gang of animals abuse the result.

I don't agree the atmosphere in the country is anti foreign, just anti unskilled foreign cheep labour which is as much an abuse to the foreign unskilled worker (who is far less likely to mobilizeand fight for fair rights and pay) as it is for British workers who subsequently have more competition who are prepared to work longer, harder hours for unacceptable levels of low pay. We need to look into individual cases of people and decided on merit of they have contributed to society, I'm sure large numbers will qualify but your fooling yourself if you think all of them do. We dont actually know if anyone will have to leave the country do we?

I'm honestly sorry if anyone feels unwelcome here, that was not my intention when I voted and I believe most of the leave camp feel the same way. It's funny how you talk about being made to feel unwelcome because quite a few remainers have made it perfectly clear what they think of leavers and I can from first hand experience lots of unjust things have been thrown around and threats have been made against 'you horrible racists'. The point is I would never accuse most remainers of being like that, because I know that would be unfair to label perfectly good people as something bad because a small group of idiots have behaved in an abhorrent way.

The reason for all the uncertainty about what happens to everyone now is the Government's fault. It was their job to plan ahead for the possibility of Brexit and if they've made no plans when your anger should be directed at them. It's not the leave voters job to decide and lots of people voted for very different reasons anyway so you would find it hard to find one overriding voice. The best solution to this imo would be a second referendum not on if we are to leave (as this has been decided and to change it would be anti democratica) but on how and when we leave. That would clear a lot of things up and ease people's minds from the instability if nothing else. Also much of the instability has been caused by disgusting scaremongering by the media and embittered Bremainers.

Regarding your point on Ireland, the possibility of unrest is always bubbling under the surface there and was always going to rise again. I refuse to let the threat of more trouble in Ireland stop me voting my way. The Scots? They can whistle into the wind because they won't get into the EU, it's funny how you talk about racism but ignore the disgraceful attitude the SNP shown towards the English. If anyone has legitimized racism it's the SNP.

The political landscape hasn't changed at all, don't be fooled by 2020, the Blairite's will have reclaimed the Labour party and will no doubt win vs a Teresa May lead Tory party. The political elite will continue to rule the roost. This referendum not the rule.

I see you have fallen into the trap of thinking it was the EU that prevented war since the end of WW2. It had nothing to do with British and American troops being based in Germany for many years? Furthermore the EU only came into being in 92 so to give them credit for stopping wars is a bit farfetched. The reason we will never again see wars on the scale of WW2 is the threat of nuclear weapons. Nothing whatsoever to do with the EU. The other real reason it's unlikely we'll ever see and Western Europe war again is because of the non-stop 24/7 news coverage and the internet. People aren't the poor helpless saps they were 70 years ago. Do you honestly think ANY western government would be able to convince their population to agree with conscription?

The rise In hate crime can easily be delt with by giving proper punishment's to those who commit crimes of this nature. In fact I'd like to see proper jail terms for people committing such crimes. If the rise in far right governments is coming then it's all the more reason to do something now before it gets to bad. Just shouting down people who are crying out for something to be done is not the answer. People have legitimate concerns over immigration that nobody will answer without using the word racist. This is why the uneducated look to somebody prepared to do something about it, like Trump. If you want to prevent this then the solution is simple: listen to people's concerns, acknowledge that they have a point (and most of the time they do) and help them fix the problem. It doesn't look nice to me at all but I blame the fools who have shut down debates they find uncomfortable and only engage with like minded thinkers who look on with contempt at those who they disagree with.

Your insinuating that everyone voted to leave because of the right wing. Well that's nonsense. I know several members of TUSC who all voted to leave because of the EU's pro austerity stancep and their contempt of workers unions. This idea that everyone who voted to leave is a part of some big right wing conspiracy is madness. You talk about being afraid of how things will go with the right wing? Well let me tell you, to just disregard democracy is the most sure fire way to guarantee an extremist government I can think of. Just remember this, it might of been fools and democracy that made Hitler the Chancellor of Germany but it was this same wilful disregard of democracy that made the the fuhrer of the Reich.
THE best post ever on GoT. Thank you for saying pretty much what/how I feel.
 
The Leavers have not helped matters by the vacuum that has emerged since the vote. With Boris (undoubtedly the figurehead of the campaign) jumping ship and Farage and Hannan admitting that a number of key campaign pledges were dishonest, there has been a huge amount of uncertainty created around just what is going to happen.

The Bank of England clearly thought about what might happen in the event of a leave vote as Carney was right on the spot attempting to stabilize markets, but no one else seems to have a bloody clue, which is frankly shocking given how long the campaign went on for. I mean did leave have no plan on which to base their campaign? It sadly seems they did not.

Until that comes to pass I'm not sure what it is people are supposed to get behind? Give people something to get behind and you might have a chance.

I think it's unfair to say that Boris 'jumped ship' when he was patently stabbed in the back. Anyway, as May, a remainer, will become PM we will have a chance of bringing people back together.

In respect of a plan, I expect that level 1&2 plans are in existence and levels 3&4 are in production, but just like with the military these type of plans rarely deliver past the first conflict and will be written and rewritten many times in the months ahead.....the Leavers also now have the full support of the Civil Service, which they were denied before the vote, to develop the strategies, scenario planning, risk analysis, negotiating plans, etc etc......
 
I'm a touch ignorant on Marine le Pen and her plans for the French National Front. Its just guess work but if she gained more support in France wouldn't that destabilise Europe?
 
This whole business shows the latent fascism just under the surface of left wing "progressives". Demanding a second referendum and calling for an end to universal suffrage because some people are too old or not educated enough to be trusted with a vote wouldn't look out of place in 1930's Germany.
If you call the working class vote fascism? Really 17.5 million people?
 
No I don't think a vote to leave has legitimized racist thoughts or actions in any way shape or form. The scumbags doing harm to their fellow human being's based on where they were born are beneath contempt and would of committed their vile acts at some point anyway so it's unfair to use a perfectly legitimate vote in the referendum to give them their excuse. The referendum isn't why these knuckle draggers are doing what they've done just the excuse they use and I'm sorry but I refuse to forfeit my democratic right to vote for what I believe to be right because a gang of animals abuse the result.

I don't agree the atmosphere in the country is anti foreign, just anti unskilled foreign cheep labour which is as much an abuse to the foreign unskilled worker (who is far less likely to mobilizeand fight for fair rights and pay) as it is for British workers who subsequently have more competition who are prepared to work longer, harder hours for unacceptable levels of low pay. We need to look into individual cases of people and decided on merit of they have contributed to society, I'm sure large numbers will qualify but your fooling yourself if you think all of them do. We dont actually know if anyone will have to leave the country do we?

I'm honestly sorry if anyone feels unwelcome here, that was not my intention when I voted and I believe most of the leave camp feel the same way. It's funny how you talk about being made to feel unwelcome because quite a few remainers have made it perfectly clear what they think of leavers and I can from first hand experience lots of unjust things have been thrown around and threats have been made against 'you horrible racists'. The point is I would never accuse most remainers of being like that, because I know that would be unfair to label perfectly good people as something bad because a small group of idiots have behaved in an abhorrent way.

The reason for all the uncertainty about what happens to everyone now is the Government's fault. It was their job to plan ahead for the possibility of Brexit and if they've made no plans when your anger should be directed at them. It's not the leave voters job to decide and lots of people voted for very different reasons anyway so you would find it hard to find one overriding voice. The best solution to this imo would be a second referendum not on if we are to leave (as this has been decided and to change it would be anti democratica) but on how and when we leave. That would clear a lot of things up and ease people's minds from the instability if nothing else. Also much of the instability has been caused by disgusting scaremongering by the media and embittered Bremainers.

Regarding your point on Ireland, the possibility of unrest is always bubbling under the surface there and was always going to rise again. I refuse to let the threat of more trouble in Ireland stop me voting my way. The Scots? They can whistle into the wind because they won't get into the EU, it's funny how you talk about racism but ignore the disgraceful attitude the SNP shown towards the English. If anyone has legitimized racism it's the SNP.

The political landscape hasn't changed at all, don't be fooled by 2020, the Blairite's will have reclaimed the Labour party and will no doubt win vs a Teresa May lead Tory party. The political elite will continue to rule the roost. This referendum is the exception not the rule.

I see you have fallen into the trap of thinking it was the EU that prevented war since the end of WW2. It had nothing to do with British and American troops being based in Germany for many years? Furthermore the EU only came into being in 92 so to give them credit for stopping wars is a bit farfetched. The reason we will never again see wars on the scale of WW2 is the threat of nuclear weapons. Nothing whatsoever to do with the EU. The other real reason it's unlikely we'll ever see and Western Europe war again is because of the non-stop 24/7 news coverage and the internet. People aren't the poor helpless saps they were 70 years ago. Do you honestly think ANY western government would be able to convince their population to agree with conscription?

The rise In hate crime can easily be delt with by giving proper punishment's to those who commit crimes of this nature. In fact I'd like to see proper jail terms for people committing such crimes. If the rise in far right governments is coming then it's all the more reason to do something now before it gets to bad. Just shouting down people who are crying out for something to be done is not the answer. People have legitimate concerns over immigration that nobody will answer without using the word racist. This is why the uneducated look to somebody prepared to do something about it, like Trump. If you want to prevent this then the solution is simple: listen to people's concerns, acknowledge that they have a point (and most of the time they do) and help them fix the problem. It doesn't look nice to me at all but I blame the fools who have shut down debates they find uncomfortable and only engage with like minded thinkers who look on with contempt at those who they disagree with.

Your insinuating that everyone voted to leave because of the right wing. Well that's nonsense. I know several members of TUSC who all voted to leave because of the EU's pro austerity stance and their contempt of workers unions. This idea that everyone who voted to leave is a part of some big right wing conspiracy is madness. You talk about being afraid of how things will go with the right wing? Well let me tell you, to just disregard democracy is the most sure fire way to guarantee an extremist government I can think of. Just remember this, it might of been fools and democracy that made Hitler the Chancellor of Germany but it was this same wilful disregard of democracy that made the the fuhrer of the Reich.

Given the debacle the country is now in due to the lack of forward planning done by the Government in regard to a "leave vote" do you not think some of our problems may be a result of poor governance and not just the EU.
 
No I don't think a vote to leave has legitimized racist thoughts or actions in any way shape or form. The scumbags doing harm to their fellow human being's based on where they were born are beneath contempt and would of committed their vile acts at some point anyway so it's unfair to use a perfectly legitimate vote in the referendum to give them their excuse. The referendum isn't why these knuckle draggers are doing what they've done just the excuse they use and I'm sorry but I refuse to forfeit my democratic right to vote for what I believe to be right because a gang of animals abuse the result.

I don't agree the atmosphere in the country is anti foreign, just anti unskilled foreign cheep labour which is as much an abuse to the foreign unskilled worker (who is far less likely to mobilizeand fight for fair rights and pay) as it is for British workers who subsequently have more competition who are prepared to work longer, harder hours for unacceptable levels of low pay. We need to look into individual cases of people and decided on merit of they have contributed to society, I'm sure large numbers will qualify but your fooling yourself if you think all of them do. We dont actually know if anyone will have to leave the country do we?

I'm honestly sorry if anyone feels unwelcome here, that was not my intention when I voted and I believe most of the leave camp feel the same way. It's funny how you talk about being made to feel unwelcome because quite a few remainers have made it perfectly clear what they think of leavers and I can from first hand experience lots of unjust things have been thrown around and threats have been made against 'you horrible racists'. The point is I would never accuse most remainers of being like that, because I know that would be unfair to label perfectly good people as something bad because a small group of idiots have behaved in an abhorrent way.

The reason for all the uncertainty about what happens to everyone now is the Government's fault. It was their job to plan ahead for the possibility of Brexit and if they've made no plans when your anger should be directed at them. It's not the leave voters job to decide and lots of people voted for very different reasons anyway so you would find it hard to find one overriding voice. The best solution to this imo would be a second referendum not on if we are to leave (as this has been decided and to change it would be anti democratica) but on how and when we leave. That would clear a lot of things up and ease people's minds from the instability if nothing else. Also much of the instability has been caused by disgusting scaremongering by the media and embittered Bremainers.

Regarding your point on Ireland, the possibility of unrest is always bubbling under the surface there and was always going to rise again. I refuse to let the threat of more trouble in Ireland stop me voting my way. The Scots? They can whistle into the wind because they won't get into the EU, it's funny how you talk about racism but ignore the disgraceful attitude the SNP shown towards the English. If anyone has legitimized racism it's the SNP.

The political landscape hasn't changed at all, don't be fooled by 2020, the Blairite's will have reclaimed the Labour party and will no doubt win vs a Teresa May lead Tory party. The political elite will continue to rule the roost. This referendum is the exception not the rule.

I see you have fallen into the trap of thinking it was the EU that prevented war since the end of WW2. It had nothing to do with British and American troops being based in Germany for many years? Furthermore the EU only came into being in 92 so to give them credit for stopping wars is a bit farfetched. The reason we will never again see wars on the scale of WW2 is the threat of nuclear weapons. Nothing whatsoever to do with the EU. The other real reason it's unlikely we'll ever see and Western Europe war again is because of the non-stop 24/7 news coverage and the internet. People aren't the poor helpless saps they were 70 years ago. Do you honestly think ANY western government would be able to convince their population to agree with conscription?

The rise In hate crime can easily be delt with by giving proper punishment's to those who commit crimes of this nature. In fact I'd like to see proper jail terms for people committing such crimes. If the rise in far right governments is coming then it's all the more reason to do something now before it gets to bad. Just shouting down people who are crying out for something to be done is not the answer. People have legitimate concerns over immigration that nobody will answer without using the word racist. This is why the uneducated look to somebody prepared to do something about it, like Trump. If you want to prevent this then the solution is simple: listen to people's concerns, acknowledge that they have a point (and most of the time they do) and help them fix the problem. It doesn't look nice to me at all but I blame the fools who have shut down debates they find uncomfortable and only engage with like minded thinkers who look on with contempt at those who they disagree with.

Your insinuating that everyone voted to leave because of the right wing. Well that's nonsense. I know several members of TUSC who all voted to leave because of the EU's pro austerity stance and their contempt of workers unions. This idea that everyone who voted to leave is a part of some big right wing conspiracy is madness. You talk about being afraid of how things will go with the right wing? Well let me tell you, to just disregard democracy is the most sure fire way to guarantee an extremist government I can think of. Just remember this, it might of been fools and democracy that made Hitler the Chancellor of Germany but it was this same wilful disregard of democracy that made the the fuhrer of the Reich.

A very long post and I don't want to disrespect what was clearly thought through by providing a glib response, but I am just popping out and will endeavour to respond more fully when I get back. But, I would like to say before I go that Hitler was voted democratically by the Germans, with the Nazi's becoming the largest party in the government by 1933. It wasn't as though he stole power, he was given it by the German people using a sadly all too familiar dose of rhetoric about in groups and out groups. I also wasn't confining this to extreme right-wing groups, as there are similarly extreme groups on the left-wing that also blame 'out groups' for the woes of the 'in-group', they just do so on different things (usually economic rather than social). Note how Syreza blamed the woes of Greece on the Troika rather than on past Greek governments.
 
Given the debacle the country is now in due to the lack of forward planning done by the Government in regard to a "leave vote" do you not think some of our problems may be a result of poor governance and not just the EU.

Of course, no one can blame one group of politicians and civil servants over another. But now at least we will know where the problem lies and can vote them in or out......
 
Bruse,
Re your post #5010

1. You can make any number of projections into the future, and come up with a whole shoal of 'probabilities', but the fact remains (and this IS a fact) that none of that guesswork can be accepted as 100% certain, or for that matter, any kind of %age certain.

2. The reactions HAVE been childish. A petition to Parliament. Rallies in London. All because their preference came second in a two horse race.

3. Lies were perpetrated on BOTH sides. Where is Osborne's swingeing budget? Why was Cameron allowed to spend £9.5 million of taxpayers money on a 'HM Government' booklet canvassing for a 'Remain' vote? That booklet says 'A vote to leave could mean a decade or more of uncertainty'. That is overlaid on the photo that they had no permission to use in the first place (hilarious - the Govt. doesn't even understand the copyright laws of the land!). I won't go on - it's riddled with crap from start to finish.

4. This is what you said, Bruce. You, not me: "...The rise of extremist political parties has grown in probability since the election,..." I would venture to suggest that you are th eone being silly about this...

5. You also say this: "...As I said several times on this forum way before the referendum, there is a growing populist movement throughout Europe on both left and right..." So, a simple consideration of this remark shows that the Referendum result had no bearing on WHAT WAS ALREADY GOING ON throughout Europe. And given that for many centuries politics has had right and left parties holding certain views, are we to now set any credence to your point that all of a sudden political left and right views are suddenly surfacing? Karl Marx may have something to say about that...

6. Certain political leaders in other countries (whether you like those leaders or not is not germaine) have looked at the UK Referendum, and now believe that their own country should go down the road of a referendum regarding their own country's continuing membership of the EU. It just might be (and here I state this with no certainty whatsoever) that their country might be better off without the shackles of the EU. That's all.
 
Of course, no one can blame one group of politicians and civil servants over another. But now at least we will know where the problem lies and can vote them in or out......

You can only vote them out if you have a radically different opposition, I think the past 20 years have shown us the professional political class we now have on both sides of the house doesn't really offer us an alternative.
 
The Leavers have not helped matters by the vacuum that has emerged since the vote. With Boris (undoubtedly the figurehead of the campaign) jumping ship and Farage and Hannan admitting that a number of key campaign pledges were dishonest, there has been a huge amount of uncertainty created around just what is going to happen.

The Bank of England clearly thought about what might happen in the event of a leave vote as Carney was right on the spot attempting to stabilize markets, but no one else seems to have a bloody clue, which is frankly shocking given how long the campaign went on for. I mean did leave have no plan on which to base their campaign? It sadly seems they did not.

Until that comes to pass I'm not sure what it is people are supposed to get behind? Give people something to get behind and you might have a chance.


The 'Leave' campaign is NOT a political movement. If anyone thinks it is, or was, then they are misguided. The Leave campaign came about through Cameron calling a referendum. They put the opposite case to the Remain campaign. Both campaigns ceased to exist as of 10 p.m., 23rd June. The reult, whichever way, then rests with the Governemt of the day - can you not see that?

After the result, personalities on both sides then put their views on a range of topics, but the two campaigns were not political movements. That is self-evident by the fact that MPs of different parties were in the Leave camp; the PM and Leader of the Opposition were in the Remain camp.

The Bank of England is there to manage the economy. Is it any surprise that Carney actually did the job he is being paid for? He, and his predecessors have been doing that for a long time - did not the Head of the Bank of England do that when the money speculators got it wrong in the mid-2000s and countries worldwide fell into recession as a result? Of course they did? Your point here is a cock that will not fight!
 
Bruse,
Re your post #5010

1. You can make any number of projections into the future, and come up with a whole shoal of 'probabilities', but the fact remains (and this IS a fact) that none of that guesswork can be accepted as 100% certain, or for that matter, any kind of %age certain.

2. The reactions HAVE been childish. A petition to Parliament. Rallies in London. All because their preference came second in a two horse race.

3. Lies were perpetrated on BOTH sides. Where is Osborne's swingeing budget? Why was Cameron allowed to spend £9.5 million of taxpayers money on a 'HM Government' booklet canvassing for a 'Remain' vote? That booklet says 'A vote to leave could mean a decade or more of uncertainty'. That is overlaid on the photo that they had no permission to use in the first place (hilarious - the Govt. doesn't even understand the copyright laws of the land!). I won't go on - it's riddled with crap from start to finish.

4. This is what you said, Bruce. You, not me: "...The rise of extremist political parties has grown in probability since the election,..." I would venture to suggest that you are th eone being silly about this...

5. You also say this: "...As I said several times on this forum way before the referendum, there is a growing populist movement throughout Europe on both left and right..." So, a simple consideration of this remark shows that the Referendum result had no bearing on WHAT WAS ALREADY GOING ON throughout Europe. And given that for many centuries politics has had right and left parties holding certain views, are we to now set any credence to your point that all of a sudden political left and right views are suddenly surfacing? Karl Marx may have something to say about that...

6. Certain political leaders in other countries (whether you like those leaders or not is not germaine) have looked at the UK Referendum, and now believe that their own country should go down the road of a referendum regarding their own country's continuing membership of the EU. It just might be (and here I state this with no certainty whatsoever) that their country might be better off without the shackles of the EU. That's all.
You forgot about world war 3 and the skies were to fall in on us toolol
 
The 'Leave' campaign is NOT a political movement. If anyone thinks it is, or was, then they are misguided. The Leave campaign came about through Cameron calling a referendum. They put the opposite case to the Remain campaign. Both campaigns ceased to exist as of 10 p.m., 23rd June. The reult, whichever way, then rests with the Governemt of the day - can you not see that?

After the result, personalities on both sides then put their views on a range of topics, but the two campaigns were not political movements. That is self-evident by the fact that MPs of different parties were in the Leave camp; the PM and Leader of the Opposition were in the Remain camp.

The Bank of England is there to manage the economy. Is it any surprise that Carney actually did the job he is being paid for? He, and his predecessors have been doing that for a long time - did not the Head of the Bank of England do that when the money speculators got it wrong in the mid-2000s and countries worldwide fell into recession as a result? Of course they did? Your point here is a cock that will not fight!
It was very UKIP orientated though a massive turn out 72 % more than a general election can we run that again oh I forgot the opposition Labour is in tatters!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top