Current Affairs EU In or Out

In or Out

  • In

    Votes: 688 67.9%
  • Out

    Votes: 325 32.1%

  • Total voters
    1,013
Status
Not open for further replies.
Seriously though, there seems an implication in what you are saying that either Brexit is a less intelligent option or that voting for it is somehow a harking back to bygone times rather than a looking forward.

Well it is possible that some people voted for it for those reasons and obviously the whole issue is a matter of opinion but I would refute it is about either of those things.

At its base it is a simple constitutional decision that will have us back in line with our history (Britain has spent longer as a separate country or union of the British countries than as part of a European federation, and , as empires build they surely die away again and that is IMO what is likely to happen with the EU over the next 10-15 years).

I think once the initial effects are over we will be better off and better admired out than in.

Bruce has already answered this. However, I'll try my best to add to it, from my perspective.
I obviously do think it's a 'less intelligent option', otherwise why are we debating it?
Without being too provocative, I'd also question the reasoning of 'some of' the people who voted for it e.g. an interviewee stating immigration as a reason for voting 'leave' but, then listing the 'European' countries that he didn't mind immigrants coming from!

"Back in line with our history", one of the issues you refuted.

I hope you're right.


Nice thoughtful post Bruce and I agree with you about the EU helping keep peace between it's countries (even though I am concerned about its likelihood of it - or the US if Hilary had been elected - starting wars with Russia or others).

I agree with your idea of us being citizens of the world and that's one reason I am not pro EU - I identify with being a citizen of the world rather than just being European.I believe the EU just focusses on Europe and that Britains will best be able to identify as citizens out of the world rather than in it.

On whether the EU will fail or not, I could be wrong (the US union of states jas survived) but I think that it has grown so large with increasingly disparate members that holding it together will be increasingly difficult.

EU big wigs (I use that term as I am not sure who they are or how they were appointed) talk about not giving Britain too good a deal in case other countries want to leave. Well, if the EU was so good surely countries wouldn't want to leave - if they had confidence in what the EU offered then they wouldn't have to try and did used people from leaving.

I'm not sure how Clinton being elected would've increased the chance of war with Russia?
Guessing you were typing on a mobile? Hard to decipher what you meant.
Probably, the same civil servant types, that write the answers for ministers in parliamentary questions. Also the same types that advise and write the legislation?


Fair point but.....if trade barriers are such a bad thing then why does the EU insist that all its members put up compulsory trade barriers (via the customs union) with all the non-EU countries in the world?

Is the EU a benevolent organisation or one that actually harms the rest of the world in order to preserve its own self interests (or as even that seems to he working less and less now, the self interests of Germany)?

I thought leaving the EU was to preserve Britain's self interests?
So, we can do it and the EU can't?
 
1. I obviously do think it's a 'less intelligent option', otherwise why are we debating it?

2. Without being too provocative, I'd also question the reasoning of 'some of' the people who voted for it e.g. an interviewee stating immigration as a reason for voting 'leave' but, then listing the 'European' countries that he didn't mind immigrants coming from!

1. First part of your sentence is an opinion, and a denigrating one at that. Tell me how I'm less intelligent than you, for starters... The second part, after the comma, is surely self-evident. There is a slur, implied or otherwise, on those who voted a certain way in the tenor of the whole sentence.

2. One might turn this point on its head, and question why some of the people who voted Remain did so. Scared of the unknown? Happy in the comfort of the status quo? A 'leave things be and don't ruffle any feathers' attitude. A resistance to change - ergo a Luddite attitude. Equally as valid as the other side of the argument...
 
tadao said:
1. I obviously do think it's a 'less intelligent option', otherwise why are we debating it?

2. Without being too provocative, I'd also question the reasoning of 'some of' the people who voted for it e.g. an interviewee stating immigration as a reason for voting 'leave' but, then listing the 'European' countries that he didn't mind immigrants coming from!

1. First part of your sentence is an opinion, and a denigrating one at that. Tell me how I'm less intelligent than you, for starters... The second part, after the comma, is surely self-evident. There is a slur, implied or otherwise, on those who voted a certain way in the tenor of the whole sentence.

2. One might turn this point on its head, and question why some of the people who voted Remain did so. Scared of the unknown? Happy in the comfort of the status quo? A 'leave things be and don't ruffle any feathers' attitude. A resistance to change - ergo a Luddite attitude. Equally as valid as the other side of the argument...

So, I've used your selected (numbered) points of mine -

1. It's not meant to be denigrating but, of the 2 options available, it is my opinion that the 'less intelligent' one was to leave. I am not saying I'm more intelligent than you. The second part, after the comma, is not a slur and only confirms a difference of opinion.

2. I'm not sure how any of that correlates to what I said?
 
So the EU is allowing employers to stop staff wearing religious clothing including burkas.

Much as I find the tendency of current Islam to cloak their women and children in head to toe black ridiculous and cult-like, even I wouldn't go that far.

Someone earlier in the thread asked Brexit voters for an example of a stupid EU law - well here is one...
 
So, I've used your selected (numbered) points of mine -

1. It's not meant to be denigrating but, of the 2 options available, it is my opinion that the 'less intelligent' one was to leave. I am not saying I'm more intelligent than you. The second part, after the comma, is not a slur and only confirms a difference of opinion.

2. I'm not sure how any of that correlates to what I said?


1 But it is...

2. If you can't see how the converse argument/point applies, then there's nothing further I can do to explain it...
 
I think E.U is in theory a good idea but as it has grown and developed over the decades it has become more and more ineffective and far too restrictive of individual nations. The E.U countries have become German colonies. Germany is far too powerful. The way our brothers and sisters in Ireland, Greece and other countries have been treated is disgraceful, in my opinion.

If the witch Le Pen gets elected in France, it's goodnight E.U. Even if she is not elected president, I think it is still only time until it collapses.

Too many nations in the E.U have fought for their freedom and sovereignty, only for it to be stealthily taken away again.
 
So the EU is allowing employers to stop staff wearing religious clothing including burkas.

Much as I find the tendency of current Islam to cloak their women and children in head to toe black ridiculous and cult-like, even I wouldn't go that far.

Someone earlier in the thread asked Brexit voters for an example of a stupid EU law - well here is one...

To clarify my post (because I seem to be getting my Islamic headgear types mixed up) Id have no problem full Islamic veils being banned in certain jobs but don't agree that employers should be able to ban any or all religious clothing which would include sikh turbans or Muslim hijabs.

People should be free to wear what they want except where it has a negative effect on others or is obviously incompatible with a job role
 
I think E.U is in theory a good idea but as it has grown and developed over the decades it has become more and more ineffective and far too restrictive of individual nations. The E.U countries have become German colonies. Germany is far too powerful. The way our brothers and sisters in Ireland, Greece and other countries have been treated is disgraceful, in my opinion.

If the witch Le Pen gets elected in France, it's goodnight E.U. Even if she is not elected president, I think it is still only time until it collapses.

Too many nations in the E.U have fought for their freedom and sovereignty, only for it to be stealthily taken away again.

Well to be precise, too many nations within the EU let the UK/USA fight for their freedom and sovereignty, only for it to be stealthily taken away from them.....
 
You weren't making the converse point though, what you replied to him with, was absolutely nothing to do with the point he made about immigration.

And you are always argumentative with any post I put up. It really has become tiresome from you...

Go and read the exchange of posts, and if you can't understand it then...
 
Don't forget the World Cup Pete.

Yeah, but you would have to agree that the UK/USA did bring peace and freedom to the continent, and that a great many of our servicemen and merchant seamen gave their lives for the freedoms now enjoyed by many in Europe....to ignore this is really an insult to their memories.....even the Russians acknowledge this fact......
 
Yeah, but you would have to agree that the UK/USA did bring peace and freedom to the continent, and that a great many of our servicemen and merchant seamen gave their lives for the freedoms now enjoyed by many in Europe....to ignore this is really an insult to their memories.....even the Russians acknowledge this fact......

I'm not sure anyone does ignore that do they?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top