You don't need a mechanic to tell if you if you have a flat tyre equally the Shakun material is so obviously flawed you don't need a peer review paper to point out the failings. Here's a sample for bedtime reading and remember to attack the messenger rather than the detail you're letting the side down otherwise
Guest Post by Willis Eschenbach The quote above is from Lord of the Rings, an exchange between Gollum and Smeagol, and it encapsulates my latest results from looking into the Shakun 2012 paper, …
wattsupwiththat.com
Glad to see you concede despite the Shakun bluster it is the orbit that controls glacial events not co2
The moon landings were based on computer models devised by empirical observation - animals sent into space - climate models have no such grasp of the variables hence their failures but thanks for directing the reader to their inherent problems.
"
The climate system is a coupled non-
linear chaotic system, and therefore the long-term prediction of future
climate states is not possible." IPCC