As I said, I don't want to go too far off topic so won't carry on after this but yeah I don't think one individual being ahead of their time etc really means a lot with this type of thing. A lot of serious track and field fans would tell you that high jumpers like Barshim and Bondarenko jumped higher than Sotomayor's world record numerous times, but never did it with the bar set at the WR height so it obviously isn't recorded, but even if you ignore that it's hard to argue against records in general being broken as time passes and the exception just proves the rule really.
In many ways it's a pointless discussion because there's no way of ever proving it either way. For me the argument you're making sounds very similar to the old tropes that the 'best' World Cup is always the one that takes place closest to your 10th birthday and the clubs you perceive as being 'big' are the ones which were successful when you first became interested in football, but maybe you're right and football peaked when Alan Wright, Steve Stone and Rob Lee made the PFA team of the year, we'll never know.