2025/26 David Moyes

I am going to violently vomit in the opening week of next season when Iraola has Newcastle playing like world beaters and Moyes is still persisting with O'Brien at right back.
Newcastle are another club that is more attractive at the moment. Why would he chose to come here vs. Newcastle? They won the League Cup and have been playing in the Champions League.
 
Sorry mate.

Going to have to completely fact check this.

Did absolutely fantastic to build the best Everton side he had on a shoestring. Arteta £2m. Pienaar £2.5m. Lescott £5m. Jagielka £4.5m. Howard £5m. Baines £6m.

But that spell aside, he spent significant amounts at United & at West Ham.

19/20: £30m in Jan
20/21: £55m (£10m Net)
21/22: £75m (£72m Net)
22/23: £190m (£170m net)
23/24: £170m (-£25m net loss)
Total spend: £520m, with net £227m

Man Utd:
13/14: £75m (£74m Net)


Sunderland
16/17: £40m (£16m net)

Everton
25/26: £125m (£115m Net)

This myth he works on a budget is utter nonsense. Riding on a former glory.

If you want steady, that's absolutely fine and respect your decision. But he's not a miracle worker for me. Very negative, and and safe, but happy to let narrative run that he never has a budget.
Sunderland is unique as he had little input on transfers. They would sign an inferior player in a purportedly higher cost as they had very low wages and the payment terms were more favorable. Martin Short had pulled the plug and was selling the team.

The other teams are fairer criticism. But West Ham should also be contextualised for fairness. He spent several seasons with a low net spend and then they had their big spend season where they got Paqueta, etc, but the signings were not really that successful overall. At the end of the day though, they build a good squad that achieved high finishes and won a trophy. That’s pretty much as good as they can expect.

How well he did there is underlined by their subsequent underperformance despite actually spending more money.
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top