2025/26 David Moyes

I'm curious about the specific points of progress you think we've made compared to last season?

I could play devil's advocate, and say, we've spent a lot of money to fail to improve key positions we've been short in for years, in fact we've got worse at centre forward, worse at right back, and worse at centre half, our brightest centre half looks no longer to have fitness levels to keep with the demands of games, and have virtually the same points total as the past two seasons.

I'm all ears to positive points you might make, but in my opinion, the above is not progress, that's going backwards - especially given the age of many players in the squad and how much all other teams seem to be able to improve.
We spend some money to replace half a squad. It wasn’t some spree, it was just adding the necessary numbers for a league season.
 
It’s never been good enough. The league is a marathon and we weren’t able to cope with losing key players at key moments in the season. But we’ve still made progress on last season which gives us something to build on.

You can be as negative as you like, but it’s still the early stages of a rebuilding process.
What progress? We’ll likely finish in the exact same position as last season, the football is absolutely dreadful and we’ve not developed any of our young players whatsoever.
 
When we had our first eleven available we were pushing for Europe. If we strengthen in the summer I think we get Europe next season.

At the end of the day, it’s the first European chase we’ve had in a long time, but we aren’t good enough at the moment.

Now, if Moyes thinks staying at the current level is acceptable then I would say he does deserve the sack. If he wants to make the team better next season then he deserves another season.
I see your point, the only counter to that for me would be 1) we have better midfield / attacking options than last season (Grealish - injured in Feb and KDH, with an option albeit not very good with Barry) which offsets 2) we’ve lost JB for 90% of the season. I think if we super reliant on one person we have not done our job in recruitment (£60m of it we’ve barely seen this season)

I genuinely don’t see the progress on balance (and certainly not in the stats).I also think that most managers want to improve their results and performances. That’s what they’re in the game for. That’s not a good enough reason to keep them on when they under perform.

Even if he does not go this summer (and that’s unlikely based on Kinnear’s statement yesterday), he’s placed himself under pressure to start next season well, which equally puts pressure on the board to make a decision if the season is not started well.
 
I see your point, the only counter to that for me would be 1) we have better midfield / attacking options than last season (Grealish - injured in Feb and KDH, with an option albeit not very good with Barry) which offsets 2) we’ve lost JB for 90% of the season. I think if we super reliant on one person we have not done our job in recruitment (£60m of it we’ve barely seen this season)

I genuinely don’t see the progress on balance (and certainly not in the stats).I also think that most managers want to improve their results and performances. That’s what they’re in the game for. That’s not a good enough reason to keep them on when they under perform.

Even if he does not go this summer (and that’s unlikely based on Kinnear’s statement yesterday), he’s placed himself under pressure to start next season well, which equally puts pressure on the board to make a decision if the season is not started well.
Which is fair enough. It’s the nature of the sport. At the end of the day, we should have gathered more than enough data this season to have identified what we need to do to improve.

What I don’t agree with is that ripping up any strategy we had drawn up to bring in a new coaching staff after what was essentially a somewhat decent season with some highs and lows. Bringing someone new in at this time would cause chaos behind the scenes.
 
1779040215741.webp
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top