2025/26 David Moyes

It was until 6 games ago. What's happened since then?

Expectation, that's what and Moyes shat his kicks.

When we truly needed to win games Moyes stuck to his safety first playbook

Even worse for a manager who prides himself on defence and organisation we've conceded 14 goals in the last 6 games .

I genuinely don't know how the Moyes acolytes can defend this , hopefully better than his team.

3 points in 6 games , relegation form.

It also coincided with Branthwaite latest injury too.
 
This is my take on it and why I feel now is the time for change.

We will go on the same run of results next year with Moyes (I think likely pre Christmas) at which point the club will need to make a stick or twist decision. Stick and we have another year of this purgatory. Twist as should be ambitious for the revenue we have and then you’re looking for a manager in the middle of next season which is challenging for all sorts of reasons e.g. availability, instability, likely compensation.

We have two managers (possibly more on the continent from different league available RIGHT NOW). We can get them in, agree squad and first team needs and agree targets. This is the easier most efficient option. It is therefore time to twist.
THIS!
 
The players take responsibility as well mate but, the problem is Moyes is always a reactive manager not a proactive one. We went 1 up today but were gash in that first half, after the first 5/10 mins we were just the same. A proactive manager makes the changes to get us on the front foot looking to get a second and try to put the game to bed, not Moyes though.
At the moment we don’t have the players who can impose themselves on a game. We simply need more quality throughout the team.

That said, O’Brien’s mistake was key and you could argue Moyes should have pulled him off, shifted Garner to the right and tried to stiffen up the midfield. But it’s all marginal stuff. We’re way short of being a top team.
 
12th place and 2 early cup exits should be seen as an unmitigated failure

Any attempts to spin it as success should be totally ignored.

Anyone at the club who thinks it's good enough is part of the problem
It’s being sold as “stability” somehow

Here for the foreseeable future, so get on board, we’re the stability monsters now. Kenwright would be proud.
 
I’ve gotta honest, I can’t even remember the Sunderland manager’s name. All I know is it’s his first crack at the Premier League and he’s practically overhauled the entire squad, bringing in a boatload of players from overseas. But let’s face it, Sunderland looked the better side in all three meetings this season.

Even in that last match, David Moyes still hadn't a clue how to sort things out.

The Leeds boss has done a proper job too, and they've got every chance of pip-pipping us on the final day.

Everyone completely wrote him off at first because of how things went for him at Norwich. But credit where it's due, he’s learned from his mistakes and tweaked the system to a 3-5-2 once Calvert-Lewin got back to full fitness.

Having watched our last six matches, it’s painfully obvious that Everton play at a slower tempo than anyone else in the league. We just can't shift gears.

It looks like we’re trying to set up to hit teams on the counter, but we’re only attacking with the front three. Every other side in this league bursts forward with at least half the team, even if they don't get the final ball, it creates options and lets them win the second balls.

When we do break, you literally see Garner and Tarkowski telling everyone else to hold back—clearly because Moyes is terrified of getting caught on the counter ourselves.

There were so many times where KDH found himself in that exact spot, busting a gut for 30 or 40 yards, only to have to turn back at the final moment because his legs were gone and he had absolutely no support.

And the most comical thing about Moyes' tactics? He tucks O'Brien inside when we’re defending and drops the wide midfielder into a makeshift right-back role, yet he stubbornly sticks to a back four instead of just playing a proper back three with wing-backs. There is no way an out-and-out centre-back is going to storm forward transition from defence to attack—it goes completely against their footballing DNA.

We're nailed on to lose to Spurs, stretching this pathetic winless run to seven games, and we'll probably finish exactly where we did last year. But the real worry is that this rot will carry over into next season if we don’t get rid of the manager.

Oh, I almost forgot—amidst all this absolute misery, there is a silver lining. We’ve managed to retain the "Stability Cup" for the second year running, and honestly, we'll probably keep monopolizing it until David Moyes finally calls it a day and packs his bags.
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top