I’ve had both jabs mate.Not sure. But if you decide to use that as opposed to getting vaccinated, you’re definitely a bit of a neighsayer.
The whole thread I took this from is worth a read but particularly like this visual representation of what you are describing aboveI’m going to put this here as I think it’s important show. It’s not a direct response to you btw but it’s to show the importance of vaccinations.
I’ve made a couple of fairly conservative assumptions that I’ll happily adjust for people. They are as follows:
R0 is 6 for both vaccinated and unvaccinated people (assuming it is highly infectious and the same for both cohorts). So for every 1 person that gets it, they’ll spread it to 6 people all things being equal.
The efficacy of the vaccine is 50%. That is, if you are vaccinated it is 50/50 you’ll contract covid. The efficacy after two vaccines is much higher.
So I’m assuming that the vaccine efficacy is lower than what has been shown so far and I’ve assumed that once it’s been contracted you are equally likely to pass it on if you are vaccinated or not.
So using conditional probabilities of A) contracting the virus and B) spreading it onto others, the formula would be as follows:
For one vaccinated person the expected outcome based on the conditional probability of getting the virus and then passing it on would be :
(Efficacy x number of people) x (infectious factor x r0)
or
(0.5 x 1) x (1 x 6) = 3.
The same formula for an unvaccinated person would be: (1 x 1) x (1 x 6) = 6
The infectious factor is 1 for both assuming you are equally infectious.
These are all relative to each other. That 50% chance of getting it relative to and unvaccinated person reduces the probability of spreading it by half relative to unvaccinated. Assuming you can’t spread it if you don’t contract it.
If I used an efficacy figure closer to the actual figure (80%), the vaccinated figure would be 1.2.
To say that vaccinations don’t make a difference to the spread is insane, basically.
Any ideas what driving this increase?
Especially as things seem to be improving in England
Any ideas what driving this increase?
Especially as things seem to be improving in England
I’m going to put this here as I think it’s important show. It’s not a direct response to you btw but it’s to show the importance of vaccinations.
I’ve made a couple of fairly conservative assumptions that I’ll happily adjust for people. They are as follows:
R0 is 6 for both vaccinated and unvaccinated people (assuming it is highly infectious and the same for both cohorts). So for every 1 person that gets it, they’ll spread it to 6 people all things being equal.
The efficacy of the vaccine is 50%. That is, if you are vaccinated it is 50/50 you’ll contract covid. The efficacy after two vaccines is much higher.
So I’m assuming that the vaccine efficacy is lower than what has been shown so far and I’ve assumed that once it’s been contracted you are equally likely to pass it on if you are vaccinated or not.
So using conditional probabilities of A) contracting the virus and B) spreading it onto others, the formula would be as follows:
For one vaccinated person the expected outcome based on the conditional probability of getting the virus and then passing it on would be :
(Efficacy x number of people) x (infectious factor x r0)
or
(0.5 x 1) x (1 x 6) = 3.
The same formula for an unvaccinated person would be: (1 x 1) x (1 x 6) = 6
The infectious factor is 1 for both assuming you are equally infectious.
These are all relative to each other. That 50% chance of getting it relative to and unvaccinated person reduces the probability of spreading it by half relative to unvaccinated. Assuming you can’t spread it if you don’t contract it.
If I used an efficacy figure closer to the actual figure (80%), the vaccinated figure would be 1.2.
To say that vaccinations don’t make a difference to the spread is insane, basically.

Joe here will not post for a bit hoping this goes away, then return to this same opinion once I'm gone...and I am off after today for the rest of the year, you'll all be happy to know.
Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.