when were we last down to 9 players?
Unless there’s an angle I’ve not seen I don’t see why Keane was stupid. From the one angle I saw it didn’t look like he’d deliberately grabbed his hair and yanked it, just that he’d gone to get a handful of his shirt as every defender does in those situations and ended up with his hair instead. If I’m wrong fair enough but that’s all I’ve seen.
BullensRoad
Player Valuation: £35m
pfim
Player Valuation: £50m
It wasn’t deliberate, you are correct. Sometimes it’s tough to judge intent, but no one in the world would ever think to do that mid air, let alone be able to pull it off.
One club gets allowances made for getting offside goals given and nothing for sarcastically clapping the referee
The other club receives red cards for hair pulling and sarcastically clapping the referee
Hmmm
The other club receives red cards for hair pulling and sarcastically clapping the referee
Hmmm
Ring master
Player Valuation: £90m
For us
Brantwaite & Rondon v Brentford May 2022.
Neville & Hibbert v Liverpool Oct 2007
Arteta & Neville v Liverpool December 2005
Naismith & Weir v Liverpool April 2003
Against Us
Scholes & Neville in April 2005 is last time in league we had 2 players sent off v us, Otherwise its sep 2007 v Kharkiv in Euro Game
BigDunc'sFod
Player Valuation: £35m
Every time McNeil and Mykolenko play
evertondotcom
Player Valuation: £20m
I’m honestly lost for words at both decisions.
Who do referees think they are? They are not immune to questioning or criticism - what type of arrogance allows you to send a player off for a sarcastic clap?
I’m absolutely done with these clowns. Utter head loss over here
Who do referees think they are? They are not immune to questioning or criticism - what type of arrogance allows you to send a player off for a sarcastic clap?
I’m absolutely done with these clowns. Utter head loss over here
mccole
Player Valuation: £35m
I meant it's stupid not from Keane because I don't think he purposely meant to do so but he pulls his hair.
He does it but I don't know if it's intentional or accidental, the rules are "violent" conduct but VAR should show it however the ref has to take into account the "violence" attached.
He's a new ref who got bullied into a decision by VAR. Clubs should demand audio of all decisions and if incorrect, FA should be banning and fining officials
I am fed up of VAR reffing games and not getting it correct. It's every week and most clubs.
TraffordBlue
Player Valuation: £30m
Still want to know how pulling someone's hair in an aerial challenge is violent conduct
Can't believe there are Evertonians justifying that decision.
Can't believe there are Evertonians justifying that decision.
I thought “violent conduct” was for things when not challenging for the ball? That’s how the rules are written, anyway.
Charles Hawtrey
Player Valuation: £50m
Once I got sent off (the only time) in a youth game in Liverpool. The ref had been awful all game and given nothing to us. Finally I got chopped down and he gave the free kick. I picked myself up and announced "And, your comedians tonight - are the referee".
For those of a certain age......
For those of a certain age......
JobForTheMoyes
Player Valuation: £50m
West Ham had a player sent off a few years ago when he cleared the ball cleanly and the opposition player ran onto his foot and made a meal of it. The standard of officiating is awful in the Premier League.
