Dyche picks the team he thinks is best. Sometimes his opinion is different to yours. All of your other arguments are trying to suggest something else. Sometimes my opinion is different to Dyche's too. He makes mistakes. I would make more.
The comparison here is with a player brought in for nearly £20M, not a player from the 21s. He was mom in his first game (according to GOT). O'Brien has been nowhere near
No need to panic yet. Just need to make sure we get three more points than Leeds do until May 12th and we're in with a decent chance. 5 points not inconceivable in those 3 games and we could be out of the relegation zone with a game in hand.
But signing only under 24's (or something approximating to this strategy) is no longer a football hipster view but the prevailing strategy at the majority of successful European clubs.
Lewis Dobbin recently (http://www.secretscout.co.uk/academy-life-lewis-dobbin/) mentioned how hard he found the jump from 18s to 23s. It might be harder than some imagine, or it might just be down to the player.
Would be good to see Dobbin and Simms working well together. Simms needs to learn...
This seems very unlikely. Might be possible they go with these 5 and Gibson covering left back (especially if they flip last season's 442/352 hybrid around, with a new rb and maybe Iwobi on the left). Loans and incomings seem like the plan though.
Keane will get minutes from the bench at least.