Fellaini > McCarthy

royalblue66 · August 23, 2013

Quim said:
Lets be honest Fellaini is a much better then McCarthy, however for those slating the lad. McCarthy never gave Fellaini a kick on three occasions last season

Don't see no queue forming for McCarthy, Bet Dave the limp will come out In the next few day's reminding everyone that he is available.

Quim · August 23, 2013

uncle bill's moggie said:
Don't see no queue forming for McCarthy, Bet Dave the limp will come out In the next few day's reminding everyone that he is available.

Not saying he is mate but people on here are makin out he's ****e. The lad is very good at what he does, we used to rave about Joe Parkinson for doing the same job. If you wanted someone to let Gibson use it and Barkley play you could do a lot worse then this lad.

royalblue66 · August 23, 2013

Quim said:
Not saying he is mate but people on here are makin out he's ****e. The lad is very good at what he does, we used to rave about Joe Parkinson for doing the same job. If you wanted someone to let Gibson use it and Barkley play you could do a lot worse then this lad.

Not at 12/13 m, like I say no one else seems interested, IMO like

davek · August 23, 2013

uncle bill's moggie said:
Don't see no queue forming for McCarthy, Bet Dave the limp will come out In the next few day's reminding everyone that he is available.

...probably because his card is already marked and everyone else knows it.

TheFinnFan · August 23, 2013

uncle bill's moggie said:
Don't see no queue forming for McCarthy, Bet Dave the limp will come out In the next few day's reminding everyone that he is available.

you dont see it cause he's earmarked. wouldnt be suprised if martinez has said to him something like "be patient and wait, im coming back for you"

royalblue66 · August 23, 2013

davek said:
...probably because his card is already marked and everyone else knows it.

Maybe, guess we will have to wait and see like.

jeffers4england · August 23, 2013

That's why you don't manage everton

If McCarthy is valued at 15m in the championship then we should all give up. If this guy was that good why has no one else gone for him? Why are united after fellaini and not mcarthy? ****ing hell lads

tsdoddy · August 27, 2013

jeffers4england said:
That's why you don't manage everton

If McCarthy is valued at 15m in the championship then we should all give up. If this guy was that good why has no one else gone for him? Why are united after fellaini and not mcarthy? ****ing hell lads

Very good point exactly why ain't anyone else linked with him then?

Eggs · August 27, 2013

....Fellaini - McCarthy thread, McCarthy to replace Fellaini thread, same discussion on the transfer thread....its all so confusing.

steken1 · August 27, 2013

tsdoddy said:
No if, buts or maybes, Fellaini in the DM position is a better player than McCarthy and I think McCarthys price tag of £15 is a bit too steep especially from a relegated side.

[video=youtube;dCxji7TyAQU]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCxji7TyAQU[/video]

Look below for Fellaini vid

Why did anyone bother to do a youtube compilation of a lad getting a few tackles in with a lot of mediocre passing thrown in. That video makes him look shiite.

ijjysmith · August 27, 2013

steken1 said:
Why did anyone bother to do a youtube compilation of a lad getting a few tackles in with a lot of mediocre passing thrown in. That video makes him look shiite.

Funny that.

Brennan · August 27, 2013

tsdoddy said:
Very good point exactly why ain't anyone else linked with him then?

'If Baines is so good why did nobody else get him from Wigan ?'

bourneblue · August 27, 2013

jeffers4england said:
That's why you don't manage everton

If McCarthy is valued at 15m in the championship then we should all give up. If this guy was that good why has no one else gone for him? Why are united after fellaini and not mcarthy? ****ing hell lads

How did we sign Fellaini then, was there a massive queue of CL clubs vying for his signature ?
No, there wasn't, McCarthy is young and he will get better, just as Fellaini did.Yet at the time of his signing there was a massive outcry on here and other forums at the £15 million we spent on him,just as there is now over McCarthy.
'Panic buy' was the buzz phrase being bandied about.

steken1 · August 27, 2013

ijjysmith said:
Funny that.

I don't know if he is or not. I've only seen him against us a few times.

JOE ALLEN was the impression I got from that though and I've only ever noticed him the time they done us with Neville and Osman in CM.

royalblue66 · August 27, 2013

Idon't think we would be talking about McCarthy if he had never played for Bobby, and Dave the limp said he wanted something like £13.5m for him, 6/7m max IMO.