Fellaini > McCarthy

  • Thread starter Thread starter tsdoddy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.

Mccarthy is ace. Is he better than Fellaini? Was Fellaini actually any good?

I'm turning this into a two part documentary.
 


McCarthy done good

Still think the people who retrospectively are now saying Felli wasn't any good are doing him a disservice though

He's had one bad season at United, where he was never played to his strengths, so it's not like he's finished or anything.

He showed enough at the World Cup for me to think he can bounce back

I certainly have no ill will towards him

I'm glad McCarthy has done so well though. He's had a great first season.
 
It should be pointed out as well that McCarthy and Fellaini are pretty much tied at one good season each with us in the past 2 years. This season will be the "rubber match", if you will

Fellaini was great at times for us during the 12/13 season and McCarthy was good for us during 13/14

Those writing Fellaini off may be jumping the gun. He's had one bad season after having a run of decent ones. There's still time for him to pull this around. McCarthy had an excellent debut season with us, but Felli had lot's of great matches and moments with us prior to his arrival.

If Fellaini had been used at United as he should have been used, he likely would have had a good season too
 

Fellaini is history as far we are concerned, we now have McCarthy who IMO is better. Time to move on and forget about Fellaini - he is not our concern anymore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top