Would you like to see Fellaini return?

[Death]

As I close my eyes

I FEELING IT ALL SLIPIN AWAY

 

[sageyefc]

Nah

 

[tadao]

No.

 

[Agent Blue]

He will be 31 in November so no probably not.

 

[ExpatinBangkok]

I could see Man U wanting Pickford in the next year or two and our club management negotiating to get cash and Fellaini in return and the club thinking it is a massive win and boost to Everton.

 

[ilikecheese]

Sam's dream target man up top.

It's a no for me.

 

[Walken]

Turning down felli on a free is absolutely mental

 

[larbert toffee]

he had the awful pairing of osman and neville behind him and was doing the work of three people, no wonder he got cheesed off, and in terms of how he left, even if you choose to be cynical, by modern era standards, acrimonious is a little harsh no?

It's all about opinions and debate, in my opinion it was an acrimonious departure and despite your best efforts the vote as to whether he should return has slipped into negativity.
As to whether a free transfer would be a ''' no brainer ' it would still involve a big signing on fee, massive wages etc too much of a risk at his age IMO as we appear to have enough problems at the moment and an aging squad.
That said I do appreciate where you're coming from, I enjoyed the bulk of his stay first time around.

 

[tonyhorne]

Been there, done that...

 

[Boba Fret]

A definitive no from me.

 

[Walken]

It's all about opinions and debate, in my opinion it was an acrimonious departure and despite your best efforts the vote as to whether he should return has slipped into negativity.
As to whether a free transfer would be a ''' no brainer ' it would still involve a big signing on fee, massive wages etc too much of a risk at his age IMO as we appear to have enough problems at the moment and an aging squad.
That said I do appreciate where you're coming from, I enjoyed the bulk of his stay first time around.

My love for certain players is definitely bordering on the blind, and felli fits into that category, I'm not to worried about the vote though, we voted for kirkby, and as I said I think he will have better options in the summer. If he was to come I genuinely think he would be a success, he hasn't started any obvious form of decline like Rooney had, though as you say there isn't really any such thing as a free anymore, except you negotiate directly with the player

 

[Eggs]

...the Fellaini situation is the same as with any other player in that any acquisitions have to fit a team model and strategy that the DoF and Manager want to play.

A large part of the problem we have is that players have been bought in isolation, with no view to how they will fit into a team and no view how they will blend with others.

 

[DanB90]

Possibly better than any of our current central midfielders, but it’s a no from me.

Can’t be arsed with any more players past their best or United cast offs just coming for a payday.

 

[NCLBlue]

No.

Man Utd cast off winding down the end of their career.

 

[Walken]

...the Fellaini situation is the same as with any other player in that any acquisitions have to fit a team model and strategy that the DoF and Manager want to play.

A large part of the problem we have is that players have been bought in isolation, with no view to how they will fit into a team and no view how they will blend with others.

I've never seen a less balanced squad