Would Siggurdsson walk into the Top 4?

[Steve0]

Sorry Steve mate, i can’t see these three names in a peer group with Siggurdson. May as well chuck Messi in there too such is the absurdity.

History will be my judge. And my friend I fancy.

Balloon door is a possibility in the coming years.

 

[JL94]

Better than Barkley.
Better than Erikssen.
Better than Sanchez
Better than ozil.
Better than Liverpool.

Might struggle at city.

Barkley you have a point on, but past that your arguing form over quality.

 

[Eggs]

...i’m sure he’d get game time in any Premier League team but the extent of that would depend on the team model deployed.

 

[Nyhus]

he wouldn't on face value, but if he played they would probably find it hard to drop him (based on current form)

This. Dont like the discussion tho, he’s an Everton player and I want it to stay that way.

 

[Brendan Janus]

Not a chance !!

 

[Prevenger17]

Better than Barkley.
Better than Erikssen.
Better than Sanchez
Better than ozil.
Better than Liverpool.

No mate

 

[carolinablue232]

Sorry Steve mate, i can’t see these three names in a peer group with Siggurdson. May as well chuck Messi in there too such is the absurdity.

Sanchez and Ozil been crap for some time now. If people complain about Sig drifting in and out of games from time to time, Ozil would be maddening. Sanchez isn’t even close to what he was 2 years ago. Erikson is pure class though.

 

[sageyefc]

@RickyRyder

 

[Bruce Wayne]

De Bruyne/Silva/Mahrez = no
Hazard = no
Ozil = no
Erikssen/Ali = no
Firminio = we will see, but not on the basis of last season
Mata = quite possibly, certainly on current form

 

[Steve0]

This thread is perfect for the siggy haters, they can still damn him and look objective doing so.

 

[MickA]

Someone please just settle an argument for me

Not a chance.

 

[kenada_blue]

@RickyRyder

He's got proof he's on par with Messi

 

[carolinablue232]

De Bruyne/Silva/Mahrez = no
Hazard = no
Ozil = no
Erikssen/Ali = no
Firminio = we will see, but not on the basis of last season
Mata = quite possibly, certainly on current form

He wouldn't be competing with Hazard though would he? It'd be Kovacic or Barkley. Same with Firmino. He'd be competing more with Wjinaldum or Lallana.

 

[Bruce Wayne]

He wouldn't be competing with Hazard though would he? It'd be Kovacic or Barkley. Same with Firmino. He'd be competing more with Wjinaldum or Lallana.

He's more of a #10 than a #8 though isn't he?

 

[ijjysmith]

Definitely in the top 4 Icelandic Everton players ever.

Easily in fact.

Stupid question this.