VAR

[Bedfordblue]

For posterity, Wolves V Eve goal disallowed for Skilliman offside, however ball hits the hand of wolves defender on way through, reviewed and not given. Similar to KDH previous week that was given.

 

[BullensRoad]

Checking VAR for a Pickford handball which wasn't even close.

 

[Igrok]

Give manu some wins…

 

[judge]

….maybe ex-players doing VAR.

Most ex-players (at least the pundits on TV) are stupider than mud and think with their emotions 'that pull on the shirt wasn't enough to give a foul for' - since when did pulling someone's shirt become acceptable? If that's happened during my Sunday League days, someone would have got chinned....probably me.
VARshould be run by people independent of the game/refs/players, not by refs covering their mates' backs.
Anyway, these footballers are all millionaires - they should give their arms up, couldn't handball it then!

 

[Timbucktoo]

….maybe ex-players doing VAR.

Players are worse than referees for knowing the rules. Every game you can see a player blatantly foul another and yet claim innocence, and players throwing themselves on the ground and being completely amazed they don`t get a free.
I think the rules have so many grey areas it allows for different decisions to be made every week for the same sort of incident. Fix the rules so that there are no grey areas and then VAR will work to help the officials enforce the rules.

 

[Timbucktoo]

Give manu some wins…

That`s been happening for some time already.

 

[irishtony1878]

For posterity, Wolves V Eve goal disallowed for Skilliman offside, however ball hits the hand of wolves defender on way through, reviewed and not given. Similar to KDH previous week that was given.

Wouldn't know, I don't think we got to see a review.

 

[Tipp blue]

Something has to give with VAR soon, Decisions like the ones given so far this season have to be questioned legally as match fixing..

 

[Marcus Kendall]

handball should be any part of th arm below the shoulder joint, and its handball if its is either deliberate or accidental but you gain an advantage (ie if it drops at your feet)

Shoulder joint is way too high

 

[Marcus Kendall]

Neither is your elbow.

You could argue wrist and below though obviously that's as drastic as the shoulder limit

 

[pfim]

For posterity, Wolves V Eve goal disallowed for Skilliman offside, however ball hits the hand of wolves defender on way through, reviewed and not given. Similar to KDH previous week that was given.

Arm was down at his side, KDH was up and out from his body. I don’t think either are handball, but for different reasons

 

[Marcus Kendall]

Give manu some wins…

Every game they don't lose seems to be aided by a shocking VAR decision in their favour along the way. Its mind boggling that even with having a 12th man every game they are still nearer the bottom than top

 

[Bedfordblue]

Arm was down at his side, KDH was up and out from his body. I don’t think either are handball, but for different reasons

Can safely say ‘we’ve seen them given’ though…..

 

[Bedfordblue]

Shoulder joint is way too high

Wasn’t it below the sleeves of a short sleeved top the other season? (Another bizarrely difficult / objective rule)

 

[mmmmsnouts]

If it makes you feel any better, Real Madrid just had a goal ruled out because VAR decided the edge of Mbappe’s head was about a centimeter offside when he was 45 yards from goal