The Johnny 'Colossus' Heitinga Appreciation Thread

Keep or get rid?

  • Keep

    Votes: 24 19.8%
  • Get rid

    Votes: 97 80.2%

  • Total voters
    121
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is a bit though, they aren't great as a partnership. Seperately, boss players, together they don't have a great understanding.

I disagree. I think they have a very good partnership. I think our problems in conceding last year were more down to individual error and being stung on the counterattack after poor offensive play. I thought we were still quite well drilled, and Distin and Jags compliment each other well.

I also don't think Jags and Heit would make a good pair as Heit lacks pace and they both lack height when compared to Distin. Plus they're both right footed, and Moyes likes left footed LCBs.
 
I like Heitinga but he is not as important as the people playing beside him. I wouldn't be too sad if we sold him what we bought him for. Made up he's still here like.
 
I disagree. I think they have a very good partnership. I think our problems in conceding last year were more down to individual error and being stung on the counterattack after poor offensive play. I thought we were still quite well drilled, and Distin and Jags compliment each other well.

I also don't think Jags and Heit would make a good pair as Heit lacks pace and they both lack height when compared to Distin. Plus they're both right footed, and Moyes likes left footed LCBs.

Not sure. I think Heitinga Distin is better than Heitinga Jags as a partnership certainly. Not certain about their understanding though. They cover for each other well enough but I reckon all too often they end up digging each other out of each others mistakes rather than acting as a unit. I think the fact they are both talented defenders covers a lot for the fact they don't have a great understanding.
 
Not sure. I think Heitinga Distin is better than Heitinga Jags as a partnership certainly. Not certain about their understanding though. They cover for each other well enough but I reckon all too often they end up digging each other out of each others mistakes rather than acting as a unit. I think the fact they are both talented defenders covers a lot for the fact they don't have a great understanding.

I'd argue that digging your partner out of his mistake is part of being a unit. Because all CBs make mistakes, but if your partner's on the same wavelength and alert to you, he can cover you and so on.

But I think you're quite right that their individual talent goes some way to compensating for any lack of understanding. I just don't think there's much of a lack. I've seen interviews with them and they say they have a strong understanding, and from what I've seen of them (and I watch almost every game in full, now that streams are always available!) they've backed that up on the pitch.

However interpreting an understanding between two players is obviously not a simple thing to do, so one or both of us could be wrong.
 
I'd argue that digging your partner out of his mistake is part of being a unit. Because all CBs make mistakes, but if your partner's on the same wavelength and alert to you, he can cover you and so on.

But I think you're quite right that their individual talent goes some way to compensating for any lack of understanding. I just don't think there's much of a lack. I've seen interviews with them and they say they have a strong understanding, and from what I've seen of them (and I watch almost every game in full, now that streams are always available!) they've backed that up on the pitch.

However interpreting an understanding between two players is obviously not a simple thing to do, so one or both of us could be wrong.

Indeed, I vote for both of us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top