Don’t get me wrong, finishing fourth that season was an incredible feat. It’s something I personally look back on as being one of the major heights of my time supporting the club, and it was the catalyst for the club to go from relegation-battlers to top four challengers.
But it was a fluke.
If you look at the squad during that season, there are a couple telling issues which needed to be addressed the following season. Firstly, our back four.
We usually started with a flat four at the back consisting of a limited Tony Hibbert, the ever reliable Alan Stubbs, the ageing David Weir, and Gary Naysmith. We played the vast majority of our games on the backfoot that season, which suited our defence as pace at the back was never a strong point. Naysmith and Hibbert were told to stay back, and on the rare occasion we did push them forward we’d have the athletic cover of Lee Carsley there to provide cover and form a make-shift back three.
A perfect example of how limited we was was the 2-0 loss to Fulham. A game that, at the time, was seen to be the game in which we needed to win to finish in the top four meant that Moyes shifted into a more attacking formation. This saw Yobo come in for Alan Stubbs to provide pace and athleticism, and Steve Watson preferred to Tony Hibbert for his ability to get down the wing and support Arteta. We also played two up front, with Ferguson and Bent leading the line.
As we pushed up, Radzinksi and Collins John moved to get in behind the centre back pairing - notably targeting Alan Stubbs’ comprehensive lack of pace. Within 40 minutes we were 2-0 down, reverted to our defensive game and never really looked a threat as Fulham were contempt sitting with their lead intact.
Whether it be by miracle, or Liverpool’s inability to capitalise on our drop of form, we finished 4th and secured Champions League football the following season.
Moyes understood full well that, if we were to crack on, we’d have to change our gamestyle from 1-0 chancers to becoming an outfit that was capable of holding the ball and pinning back the opposition into their own half.
Following the end of his contract, Alan Stubbs was released to join recently promoted Sunderland. His replacement would come in the form of a £5m Danish centre back who had just played a major part in Udinese’s 4th place finish in Serie A - Per Kroldrup.
Champions League winner and Portuguese international, Nuno Valente was signed from Porto to replace Alessandro Pistone.
Mikel Arteta, who impressed the Goodison Park faithful with his creativity, signed on a permanent basis from Real Sociedad for a measly £2m. Matteo Ferrari, a highly-rated pacey centre back from the Italian league, was loaned in to provide cover for Joseph Yobo. Manchester United’s Phil Neville, known for his versatility and work-rate, was then made our club’s highest paid player when he was brought in for £3.5m. Simon Davies also signed from Spurs, but I can't remember the fee.
And on the final day of the season, the enigmatic but undoubtedly highly talented, Andy van der Meyde was signed from Inter Milan for £1.8m on the final day of the transfer window.
On the face of it, it looked as if Moyes had addressed all of the squads shortcomings. The pace issue at the back looked to be addressed in its entirety, with Per Kroldrup and Matteo Ferrari providing far more athleticism than Alan Stubbs and David Weir.
Nuno Valente and Phil Neville provided the sort of technical ability we needed if we were to push our fullbacks forward. Andy van der Meyde promised to provide the crosses needed to get the best of out of James Beattie. Simon Davies looked to offer more than Leon Osman.
It just so happened that almost all of those signings (other than Valente, Arteta, and Neville) turned out to be complete flops. Moreover, the dependable Nigel Martyn was forced into early retirement after being dealt a nasty break in his ankle, leaving us with the eclectic Dickie Wright in goals.
We bought well from then on, but early being knocked-out so early on in the Champions League and that horrible 5-1 defeat to a Romanian side I can't even remember the name of took the wind right out of the club. The hangover was immense, and we did well to finish were we did.
I wouldn't blame anyone in particular for this. We spent £15-18m that season on a number of players, who on the face of it, looked to address all of our shortcomings - but it didn't work out.