Seamus Coleman

[Eggs]

Does the club get anything by way of compensation?

..not that I'm aware of. Somebody posted the ruling when I raised the subject some days ago but I think it only relates to salary. I dare say individuals and clubs could seek compensation (Anichebe got £1m settlement for the dreadful tackle on him some seasons ago against Newcastle).

 

[ToffeeTim]

I was told today at work by one of the far too many resident kopites, that he "will be no big loss" and that "sure oviedo is better than him anyway."

I have no words.

 

[The Rhino]

What annoys me is Taylor will get a 4 game at most ban. Absolute joke when Colemans out for 8-9 months. Should be 10-20 game ban for those sort of tackles.

 

[Bungle]

Yeah, that's still in place. It's called the FIFA Club Protection Programme, see here
http://resources.fifa.com/mm/docume...01/64/76/90/technicalbulletinmitcirculare.pdf

I think thats quite Remarkable that FIFA will pay his wages. Thats good thing ofcourse...is it somekind of assurance or something. Has this happened before cause I havent heard about cases like this?

Does the club get anything by way of compensation?

..not that I'm aware of. Somebody posted the ruling when I raised the subject some days ago but I think it only relates to salary. I dare say individuals and clubs could seek compensation (Anichebe got £1m settlement for the dreadful tackle on him some seasons ago against Newcastle).

The link is in that top quote from the other day, gives a fairly good explanation as to what Fifa pay.

 

[TheFinnFan]

What annoys me is Taylor will get a 4 game at most ban. Absolute joke when Colemans out for 8-9 months. Should be 10-20 game ban for those sort of tackles.

Exactly.

 

[roydo]

What annoys me is Taylor will get a 4 game at most ban. Absolute joke when Colemans out for 8-9 months. Should be 10-20 game ban for those sort of tackles.

Whilst I understand your annoyance, it doesnt work like that does it? Any high tempo, competitive sport carries a risk.

Some of the posts in here should take a peek at the way we laughed at the way West Ham carried on when Jimmy Mac put Payet out for a few months. It happens.

 

[streeky]

I was told today at work by one of the far too many resident kopites, that he "will be no big loss" and that "sure oviedo is better than him anyway."

I have no words.

shows how deluded they are.

 

[The Rhino]

Whilst I understand your annoyance, it doesnt work like that does it? Any high tempo, competitive sport carries a risk.

Some of the posts in here should take a peek at the way we laughed at the way West Ham carried on when Jimmy Mac put Payet out for a few months. It happens.

If the tackle doesn't result in injury then fair enough 3-4 game ban is sufficient but surely the punishment should reflect the damage done?

2 people could drink drive, but should the prison sentence be the same if one knocks down and kills a person? As thats effectively what the current rule is in football which is a joke.

 

[scratchnsurf]

The link is in that top quote from the other day, gives a fairly good explanation as to what Fifa pay.

***SOUND THE SENSIBLE ON TOPIC REPLY FROM BUNGLE CLAXON***




Hang on - is it an animals bumming link?

 

[roydo]

If the tackle doesn't result in injury then fair enough 3-4 game ban is sufficient but surely the punishment should reflect the damage done?

2 people could drink drive, but should the prison sentence be the same if one knocks down and kills a person? As thats effectively what the current rule is in football which is a joke.

Just dont think a punishment, for anything, should be demanded by the victims of the offence. The rules are there. 2, 4, 5 match ban, whatever, but to say that a player should be banned for a similar time as the player who was crocked is nonsense, in my opinion.

Was a bad tackle, obvs, got a red. Dems the rules.

He would have got a red if Seamus came out of it unhurt. The offence is punished, not the unfortunate out come.

Unpopular maybe, but its the way sport is.

 

[Bungle]

***SOUND THE SENSIBLE ON TOPIC REPLY FROM BUNGLE CLAXON***




Hang on - is it an animals bumming link?

Missed my window of opportunity to edit the link ffs

 

[dublinbluenose]

Still absolutely gutted for him. And us.

 

[Jay_EFC93]

Still absolutely gutted for him. And us.

can't get over it still. Nicest lad in the premier league ffs

 

[Nymzee]

If FIFA pay the wages when players are injured on international duty does this mean we've never had to pay McCarthy before.

 

[Bob Elstone]

Should have been Everton captain last year and this year.