Reyes for Pienaar?

[TyphooToffee]

I don't mind having Reyes but not at the expense of Stevie P

 

[Dutch Toffee]

I don't mind having Reyes but not at the expense of Stevie P

Don't think anyone on here does.

 

[Dom1878]

Id love to have Reyes, but Pienaar is very under-rated in the team, and would be a massive loss

 

[NickD]

na keep peanuts, defo wudn't wanna lose him! not sure on reyes, he did ok for arsenal thou

 

[TyphooToffee]

na keep peanuts, defo wudn't wanna lose him! not sure on reyes, he did ok for arsenal thou

If he could repeat that form, the reported £4m would be a steal. But the SP is SP stays

 

[Blue Wiz]

Wouldn't do that trade. We have a good LM that cooperated well with our LB. Why trade it for a player that have a history here for not being able to settle down? I'm for a purchase, a gamble, or Reyes for £4M, but not for a swap with Pienaar.

 

[tonyefc1878]

reyes is good ,but not at the expense of peanuts ,hope this not a sign to come we want a player but have give up one of ours (jo for lesscot)

 

[Blue Wiz]

reyes is good ,but not at the expense of peanuts ,hope this not a sign to come we want a player but have give up one of ours (jo for lesscot)

Would never trade Jo for Lescott. We have 3 CD's and need 2 each game. We have 4 strikers and mostly just plays with 1 each game.. why swich a CD for another striker?

 

[Goat]

What a random thread.

I can do that also.

Moutinho for Cahill?
Defour for Arteta?
Mbia for Neville?

I dont get the point of this thread. Very strange.

 

[Dutch Toffee]

What a random thread.

I can do that also.

Moutinho for Cahill?
Defour for Arteta?
Mbia for Neville?

I dont get the point of this thread. Very strange.

What would be your thoughts on this one though, MG? I know it's only hypothetical, but what would you choose? Very interesting post really.

 

[Stegoroth]

What a random thread.

I can do that also.

Moutinho for Cahill?
Defour for Arteta?
Mbia for Neville?

I dont get the point of this thread. Very strange.

Everton to offer Pienaar for Madrid's Reyes | Premiership News | tribalfootball.com

It's being reported for some reason. Next you'll hear "Everton are stepping up their pursuit..." Makes me laugh when the say "Stepping up" I always picture DM & BK doing a goose step.

 

[Goat]

What would be your thoughts on this one though, MG? I know it's only hypothetical, but what would you choose? Very interesting post really.

It would depend, too many factors, but if you gave me the choice, I would pick Moutinho. Only due to age.

Everton to offer Pienaar for Madrid's Reyes | Premiership News | tribalfootball.com

It's being reported for some reason. Next you'll hear "Everton are stepping up their pursuit..." Makes me laugh when the say "Stepping up" I always picture DM & BK doing a goose step.

Right, so this thread is based on a tribalfootball link, that says:

"The Toffees could even be willing to offer Steven Pienaar as part of the deal." "£3m move for Atletico Madrid’s Jose Antonio Reyes"

??????????? Really.

 

[Neiler]

Ha ha following a tribal football link ive just read something that suggests we should sign the Mout and Defour.

Ah living the dream!

 

[Welton Toffee]

Why would we want to swap one of our best players for someone who's been largely crap for years??? Utter rubbish.

 

[teppic]

pienaar will be a star next season. we have to keep him this summer.