Howard - 3 - very, very poor for the majority of the season. Needs replacing now for me.
Robles - 6.5 - Started poorly but got better after getting a run. Could have a future as no.1.
Coleman - 6 - Out of form but wasn't horrendous, suffered from lack of cover.
Hibbert - 5 - Didn't play much but did nothing spectacular or terrible when he did.
Jagielka - 6.5 - Started bad, got better, went bad again then got better again. Strange season.
Stones - 8 - One or two moments where his inexperience showed but he's still going to be a fantastic player. POTS for me.
Distin - 2 - Embarrassing, sad that things ended the way they did but his time is well and truly up as PL player.
Alcaraz - 1 - Absolutely appalling, will forever be remembered for his disgusting "performance" in Kiev.
Baines - 6 - Same as Coleman really. Not his best year but was still mostly reliable.
Garbutt - 7 - Another who looks a star in the making, shame he looks to be leaving.
Oviedo - 5 - Did well against Young Boys but it was his only game of note all year.
Barry - 4 - Definitely looked his age this season. Can still be useful but has to play far less games.
McCarthy - 7 - We missed him terribly during that wretched winter run. Is continuing to develop as a player.
Gibson - 5.5 - Showed his quality in a few games that he played in but it's probably best to cash out on him if we can.
Besic - 7 - Another with big potential but he still has bad habits to iron out. Should start more games next season.
Mirallas - 7 - Was unplayable at times but completely anonymous at others. Want him stay but if he doesn't it won't be a disaster if he doesn't.
Pienaar - 4 - He looks finished as well. Legs have gone and all he's doing is picking up a wage.
Atsu - 3 - Very disappointing, was a wild card that definitely didn't pay off. See ya later.
Naismith - 5 - Not as a good last year though he was played out of position a lot of time. Hopefully better next year.
Barkley - 4 - Confidence looks to have been destroyed and he's clearly unsure of his role. Needs lots of patience.
McGeady - 4 - Not good enough for me, he's had his chance but hasn't been good enough. Sell him if we can.
Lennon - 7 - Apart from 1 or 2 games he was very impressive, offered something different. Should definitely try to sign him.
Lukaku - 7 - Another who had good and bad periods but ultimately his overall season performance was just about to a satisfactory level.
Kone - 2 - Utterly crap, offers very little and everyone has rightfully given up hope on him. Needs to go.
Robles - 6.5 - Started poorly but got better after getting a run. Could have a future as no.1.
Coleman - 6 - Out of form but wasn't horrendous, suffered from lack of cover.
Hibbert - 5 - Didn't play much but did nothing spectacular or terrible when he did.
Jagielka - 6.5 - Started bad, got better, went bad again then got better again. Strange season.
Stones - 8 - One or two moments where his inexperience showed but he's still going to be a fantastic player. POTS for me.
Distin - 2 - Embarrassing, sad that things ended the way they did but his time is well and truly up as PL player.
Alcaraz - 1 - Absolutely appalling, will forever be remembered for his disgusting "performance" in Kiev.
Baines - 6 - Same as Coleman really. Not his best year but was still mostly reliable.
Garbutt - 7 - Another who looks a star in the making, shame he looks to be leaving.
Oviedo - 5 - Did well against Young Boys but it was his only game of note all year.
Barry - 4 - Definitely looked his age this season. Can still be useful but has to play far less games.
McCarthy - 7 - We missed him terribly during that wretched winter run. Is continuing to develop as a player.
Gibson - 5.5 - Showed his quality in a few games that he played in but it's probably best to cash out on him if we can.
Besic - 7 - Another with big potential but he still has bad habits to iron out. Should start more games next season.
Mirallas - 7 - Was unplayable at times but completely anonymous at others. Want him stay but if he doesn't it won't be a disaster if he doesn't.
Pienaar - 4 - He looks finished as well. Legs have gone and all he's doing is picking up a wage.
Atsu - 3 - Very disappointing, was a wild card that definitely didn't pay off. See ya later.
Naismith - 5 - Not as a good last year though he was played out of position a lot of time. Hopefully better next year.
Barkley - 4 - Confidence looks to have been destroyed and he's clearly unsure of his role. Needs lots of patience.
McGeady - 4 - Not good enough for me, he's had his chance but hasn't been good enough. Sell him if we can.
Lennon - 7 - Apart from 1 or 2 games he was very impressive, offered something different. Should definitely try to sign him.
Lukaku - 7 - Another who had good and bad periods but ultimately his overall season performance was just about to a satisfactory level.
Kone - 2 - Utterly crap, offers very little and everyone has rightfully given up hope on him. Needs to go.
Last edited:
