Rate our players last season out of 10

Status
Not open for further replies.
Based purely on how they played, rather than how much they earn, what they cost or any expectations


Howard : 6 - inconsistent.

Robles : 6 - poor start, looked nervous, finished well

Coleman : 6 - out of form a lot but showed glimpses now and then

Hibbert -: 6 - did nothing wrong when called on

Jagielka : 8 - shaky start, but excellent for most of the season

Stones : 7 - bags of talent, will be mega boss but still got a bit to learn

Distin : 4 - poor

Alcaraz : 5 - poor. Some decent performances, but never looked comfortable at this level

Baines : 7 - much better than people give him credit for. People are judging him against other better seasons. Would have given him 8 if he could regularly knock a decent corner in

Garbutt : 6 - decent showing for someone without much experience at this level

Oviedo : 5 - rusty when he came back, not really played much

Barry : 6 - some poor games, but he's been better than most people credit him for

McCarthy : 7 - steady performances with occassional bossness

Besic : 6 - OK rather than outstanding

Mirallas : 6 - the odd brilliant moment, but lots of meh ones too.

Osman : 7 - if he could defend and tackle I'd have given him an 8. Sadly he can't.

Naismith : 6 - without his great start to the season he'd have been a 5

Barkley : 5 - ineffective for most of the season

McGeady : 5 - ditto

Lennon : 7 - had many more good games than poor

Lukaku : 7 - His weaknesses are there for all to see, but you can't argue with his goals scored and his obvious strengths

Kone : 4 - Sad to see someone in an Everton shirt stuggling so much

Browning and Galloway - done OK in their little cameos, but not played often enough to get a rating

Pienaar : 6 - showed glimpses of what we've missed
 

Howard - 4
Robles - 8
Coleman - 5
Hibbert - 6
Jagielka - 6
Stones - 7
Distin - 2
Alcaraz - 3
Baines - 7
Garbutt - 6
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 4
McCarthy - 7
Besic - 7
Mirallas - 6
Naismith - 8
Barkley - 4
McGeady - 6
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 5

My ratings are weighted relative to their own ability or expectations rather than against each other.
 
Woolly Blue said:
Based purely on how they played, rather than how much they earn, what they cost or any expectations


Howard : 6 - inconsistent.

Robles : 6 - poor start, looked nervous, finished well

Coleman : 6 - out of form a lot but showed glimpses now and then

Hibbert -: 6 - did nothing wrong when called on

Jagielka : 8 - shaky start, but excellent for most of the season

Stones : 7 - bags of talent, will be mega boss but still got a bit to learn

Distin : 4 - poor

Alcaraz : 5 - poor. Some decent performances, but never looked comfortable at this level

Baines : 7 - much better than people give him credit for. People are judging him against other better seasons. Would have given him 8 if he could regularly knock a decent corner in

Garbutt : 6 - decent showing for someone without much experience at this level

Oviedo : 5 - rusty when he came back, not really played much

Barry : 6 - some poor games, but he's been better than most people credit him for

McCarthy : 7 - steady performances with occassional bossness

Besic : 6 - OK rather than outstanding

Mirallas : 6 - the odd brilliant moment, but lots of meh ones too.

Osman : 7 - if he could defend and tackle I'd have given him an 8. Sadly he can't.

Naismith : 6 - without his great start to the season he'd have been a 5

Barkley : 5 - ineffective for most of the season

McGeady : 5 - ditto

Lennon : 7 - had many more good games than poor

Lukaku : 7 - His weaknesses are there for all to see, but you can't argue with his goals scored and his obvious strengths

Kone : 4 - Sad to see someone in an Everton shirt stuggling so much

Browning and Galloway - done OK in their little cameos, but not played often enough to get a rating

Pienaar : 6 - showed glimpses of what we've missed
Click to expand...

Pretty fair assessment that.
 
Howard : 2

Robles : 6

Coleman : 5

Hibbert -: 6

Jagielka : 7

Stones : 8

Distin : 3

Alcaraz : 4

Baines : 6

Garbutt : 6

Oviedo : 4

Barry : 5

McCarthy : 6

Besic : 6

Mirallas : 7

Osman : 7

Naismith : 6

Barkley : 3

McGeady : 3

Lennon : 7

Lukaku : 7

Kone : 3

Pienaar : 5
 
Howard - 2
Robles - 7
Coleman - 5
Hibbert - 3
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 3
Alcaraz - 3
Baines - 7
Garbutt - 4
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 6
McCarthy - 7
Besic - 7
Mirallas - 7
Naismith - 6
Barkley - 5
McGeady - 2
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 2
 

Howard - 4
Robles - 5
Coleman - 5
Hibbert - 5
Jagielka - 6
Stones - 7
Distin - 4
Alcaraz - 4
Baines - 6
Garbutt - 5
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 4
McCarthy - 7
Besic - 6
Mirallas - 6
Naismith - 5
Barkley - 4
McGeady - 4
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 6
Kone - 4
 
Surprised at the low ratings Oviedo's been getting. When he filled in for Baines around January he didn't put a foot wrong.
 

Really concerned about the people who gave Besic a higher mark than John Stones? I'm a fan of Besic but don't believe he (or anyone else) has come near to Stonesey's standards?
 
Howard - 4
Been awful this year. Responsible for many dropped points and a real weak link.
Robles - 7
Took his opportunity well. Very unlucky to get dropped.
Coleman - 7
Solid defender, also chipped in with a handful of goals. Never reached the heights of last season though.
Hibbert - 5
Didn't play badly, didn't play well.
Jagielka - 8
Solid consistent performer. What a goal.
Stones - 8
This guy has it all. Could be one of the world's best in years to come, we really missed him through the Christmas period.
Distin - 4
Played badly in the few games he had. Shouldn't taint an otherwise fantastic Everton career.
Alcaraz - 5
Played well in some games and badly in others. Would have been 6 had it not been for Kiev.
Baines - 6
Solid but very rarely fantastic any more. Doesn't stick out in an average team.
Garbutt - 6
Decent debut season for the youngster. Could make it, but we will see.
Oviedo - 6
Played very little. Unlucky not to score at Old Trafford. We need him fit and ready for next season.
Barry - 6
Had a very poor spell around the new year, however found some form towards the end. Scapegoated sometimes.
McCarthy - 8
Fantastic player. The future of Everton. Thrives when he is allowed to venture forward.
Besic - 7
Had some fantastic games. Had some fairly average ones. Should get more game time next season.
Gibson - 7
Made a real impact in the games he did play. THAT through ball in the Young Boys games. Injured too often.
Mirallas - 7
Had a superb spell where he seemed to carry the team, then he dropped off. Blows hot and cold, but when hot, he can be awesome.
Naismith - 5
Scored a few at the start, but cannot string 2 passes together. Liability.
Barkley - 5
Had an awful second season. Should improve next year as we know he can. The injury on the eve of the season was terrible timing.
Osman - 7
Not the answer to our problems, but adds a bit of guile to our attacking options. Can be useful in cameos.
McGeady - 6
Don't care what anyone says, he is boss at times. At others, less so.
Pienaar - 5
Did he play?
Lennon - 7
Came in and gave us the injection of pace and runs in between the defence we needed. Had a handful of superb performances, winning us the game.
Lukaku - 7
Scored 20 but always seemed like he could do more.
Kone - 6
Can hold the ball up, is strong and is not slow. Not awful, but not enough to scare a defence. Worthy of a place on the bench.
 
Howard - 0.12
Robles - 9
Coleman - 6
Hibbert - 5
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 5
Alcaraz - 5
Baines - 5
Garbutt - 5
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 3
McCarthy - 7
Besic - 7.5
Mirallas - 6
Naismith - 6
Barkley - 4
McGeady - 4
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 6
Kone - who?
 
Woolly Blue said:
Based purely on how they played, rather than how much they earn, what they cost or any expectations


Howard : 6 - inconsistent.

Robles : 6 - poor start, looked nervous, finished well

Coleman : 6 - out of form a lot but showed glimpses now and then

Hibbert -: 6 - did nothing wrong when called on

Jagielka : 8 - shaky start, but excellent for most of the season

Stones : 7 - bags of talent, will be mega boss but still got a bit to learn

Distin : 4 - poor

Alcaraz : 5 - poor. Some decent performances, but never looked comfortable at this level

Baines : 7 - much better than people give him credit for. People are judging him against other better seasons. Would have given him 8 if he could regularly knock a decent corner in

Garbutt : 6 - decent showing for someone without much experience at this level

Oviedo : 5 - rusty when he came back, not really played much

Barry : 6 - some poor games, but he's been better than most people credit him for

McCarthy : 7 - steady performances with occassional bossness

Besic : 6 - OK rather than outstanding

Mirallas : 6 - the odd brilliant moment, but lots of meh ones too.

Osman : 7 - if he could defend and tackle I'd have given him an 8. Sadly he can't.

Naismith : 6 - without his great start to the season he'd have been a 5

Barkley : 5 - ineffective for most of the season

McGeady : 5 - ditto

Lennon : 7 - had many more good games than poor

Lukaku : 7 - His weaknesses are there for all to see, but you can't argue with his goals scored and his obvious strengths

Kone : 4 - Sad to see someone in an Everton shirt stuggling so much

Browning and Galloway - done OK in their little cameos, but not played often enough to get a rating

Pienaar : 6 - showed glimpses of what we've missed
Click to expand...
Finally some one spot on
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top