Rate our players last season out of 10

[Eric Djemba-Djemba]

Pretty self explanatory really.

Howard - 0
Robles - 10
Coleman - 5
Hibbert - 4
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 2
Alcaraz - 3
Baines - 6
Garbutt - 5
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 4
McCarthy - 7
Besic - 9
Mirallas - 7
Naismith - 4
Barkley - 4
McGeady - 4
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 1

We really do have a lot of dross in our squad.

 

[windymiller]

Howard - 3
Robles - 6
Coleman - 6
Hibbert - 4
Jagielka - 7
Stones - 8
Distin - 4
Alcaraz - 3
Baines - 6
Garbutt - 6
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 5
McCarthy - 8
Besic - 6
Osman - 6
Mirallas - 6
Naismith - 5
Barkley - 5
McGeady - 3
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 3

 

[Jozzy]

Howard - 4
Robles - 5
Coleman - 6
Hibbert - 5
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 4
Alcaraz - 5
Baines - 6
Garbutt - 6
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 6
McCarthy - 7
Besic - 7
Mirallas - 7
Naismith - 6
Barkley - 6
McGeady - 5
Atsu - 5
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 4

 

[Eggs]

.....not sure about the 'dross' reference. I presume the scores are based on what was expected, let's not forget many players were part of a squad that accumulated a lot of points and came close to a Champions League spot the season before. Disappointing season with disappointing individual performance yes, but there is a fair bit of quality there in my opinion.

 

[Prevenger17]

Howard - 0
Robles - 10

lol

 

[Deleted member 28206]

Are they all a minus?

 

[ArtetaMoney]

Howard - 4
Robles - 7
Coleman - 7
Hibbert - 7
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 4
Alcaraz - 4
Baines - 7
Garbutt - 6
Oviedo - 6
Barry - 6
McCarthy - 8
Besic - 5
Mirallas - 6
Naismith - 5
Barkley - 4
McGeady - 4
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 4

 

[tommye]

Howard - 8
Robles - 0
Coleman - 0​

Hibbert - 0​

Jagielka - 0
Stones - 0
Distin - 0
Alcaraz - 0
Baines - 0
Garbutt - 0
Oviedo - 0
Barry - 0
McCarthy - 0
Besic - 0
Mirallas - 0
Naismith - 0
Barkley - 0
McGeady - 0
Lennon - 0
Lukaku - 0
Kone - 0​

 

[blue61]

Are they all a minus?

If so @Eric Djemba-Djemba thinks Howard was our best player.

 

[Eric Djemba-Djemba]

If so @Eric Djemba-Djemba thinks Howard was our best player.

Now that is just sick mate.

 

[Goat]

Howard - 0
Robles - 8
Coleman - 6
Hibbert - 5
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 3
Alcaraz - 3
Baines - 7
Garbutt - 2
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 6
McCarthy - 7
Besic - 10
Mirallas - 7
Naismith - 4
Barkley - 5
McGeady - 2
Lennon - 8
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 0

 

[toffeemax]

Howard - 5
Robles - 7
Coleman - 7
Hibbert - 6
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 6
Alcaraz - 3
Baines - 7
Garbutt - 7
Oviedo - 6
Barry - 4
McCarthy - 8
Besic - 6
Mirallas - 7
Naismith - 7
Barkley - 6
McGeady - 6
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 6

6 is an average rating. Distin and hibbo didnt play enough to give any higher or lower.

 

[Ihaters]

Howard - 5
Coleman - 6
Hibbert - 0
Jagielka - 6
Stones - 8
Distin - 4
Alcaraz - 4
Baines - 6
Garbutt - 5
Oviedo - 5
Barry - 6
McCarthy - 6
Besic - 6
Mirallas - 6
Naismith -5
Barkley - 5
McGeady - 2
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 0

 

[Goat]

Howard - 8
Robles - 0
Coleman - 0​

Hibbert - 0​

Jagielka - 0
Stones - 0
Distin - 0
Alcaraz - 0
Baines - 0
Garbutt - 0
Oviedo - 0
Barry - 0
McCarthy - 0
Besic - 0
Mirallas - 0
Naismith - 0
Barkley - 0
McGeady - 0
Lennon - 0
Lukaku - 0
Kone - 0​

NEGGED for giving Besic a 0.

 

[Goat]

Howard - 4
Robles - 7
Coleman - 7
Hibbert - 7
Jagielka - 8
Stones - 8
Distin - 4
Alcaraz - 4
Baines - 7
Garbutt - 6
Oviedo - 6
Barry - 6
McCarthy - 8
Besic - 5
Mirallas - 6
Naismith - 5
Barkley - 4
McGeady - 4
Lennon - 7
Lukaku - 7
Kone - 4

5?????

Honestly lad.