But it's not just a one off cup tie. You are comparing two cup ties. City v Wigan and Arsenal v Everton. The likelihood of both going to the underdog is low.
Everton are a good side but arsenal are better. They will beat Everton more than they will lose to them.
Same with City and Wigan, it just so happened they beat them yesterday and we lost to Arsenal on Saturday.
Except we weren't an "underdog" in the sense Wigan were.
We have emerged with draws the last two times we have played at the Emirates in the league.
And we drew with then at Goodison last season.
So the last three three league meetings with Arsenal have been draws.
You guys need to lose the inferiority complex.
Yes, Arsenal were favourites on Saturday....but not overwhelming favourites.
And as many of us have stated here since the game....a bit more awareness from both Mirallas and Lukaku and a bit more composure from Barkley could have seen us build up a two or three goal lead before the penno.