To be fair mate you cant say that about Silva unless we are going to go down the dont blame big Sam for any of our problems. Silva is a poor manager but at the time we went for him he might of been acceptable to replace Koeman just to get shut of the Dutchman
No, that doesn't make sense as a comparison.
I'm not saying that you can't blame Silva for anything, simply that it's too simplistic to suggest he's not capable of organising a defence when the defence was poor both before and after him aswell. Had he taken over a solid unit and made it porous, or had defensive issues which were immediately solved by his successor then it would be a reasonable shout, but as neither of those things are correct, it's not.
For the record, I
don't blame Allardyce for the vast majority of our issues. I have plenty of issues with him but I can't really blame him for the fact we have no creativity in midfield for example, because that isn't a problem of his making.