Ok. So I take it you accepted the 8th, 10th and 12th before that, two of them provided by an alleged world class manager?
That’s the problem with fans, the eternal tightrope between optimism and expectation.
We had about 15-20% of our lot wanting him gone last season for how dull it was, another large group saying give him til Christmas next season when got Jiménez back, and the rest along the lines of ‘what are you talking about, this is still the best for nearly half a century’.
Then there were the few old farts that remember winning titles in the 50s that didn’t think 7th was anything to be happy about, it’s a disgrace that we haven’t won a cup yet.
You’ve got to actually put your expectation level into context. Should you be doing better than you are? Yes. Should Everton be finishing that low with their spend in the Moshiri era? No.
Would getting back to being the ‘best of the rest‘ actually be an achievement considering recent finishes: yes.
If a manager leaves a club better than they found it, especially relative to budget, then they’ve succeeded. By that metric, Nuno was a success. Every manager at Everton since Moshiri’s millions has failed.
Just to put some context to this mate.
8th was under Allardyce and Silva. Allardyce got 48 points (and came in after we had played all of the big 6 in our first ten games so had a plumb set of fixtures). He was also obnoxious and was sacked.
Silva got 8th and most fans accepted this was a decent season, very few wanted him gone at that point. However we didn't build on this at all. We had 14 points from 15 games the next season. Ancelotti came in and got 30 from 20, so it was a good turnaround. We had sacked a manager for his part in causing 12th.
The following season we had finished 10th, but with 59 points (which is the same amount as your best season). There was some frustration from some quarters but overall the point tally was good for a 1st season.
I suspect Nuno will be given a seasons grace whereby a top half finish will be ok. But if he doesn't kick on, I'm not sure how long he will be here. In fairness, no manager has kicked on in their 2nd year here under Moshiri, so difficult to say what he will do. He will likely be given funds to help with his team.
In fairness, it's a similar issue to what you have too. There's a glass ceiling you hit, which is around 60 points. Leicester have got past it, but even though have only got to 67 points in what is a great season. Getting to 55-60 is relatively easy, but to get beyond that is a lot harder. You've gone a very different direction too and taken a bit more of a gamble. It's hard though mate, you can do a lot right to have to get to 60 points, and you get a couple of things wrong and you go tumbling back down quite quickly.