Name the best Everton lineup you’ve seen in your lifetime

[Debunkology]

To be fair, you put Gueye in your best 11. You also had Southall and Kanchelskis, so you must've been watching since at latest 97.

That's some claim that.

1992, I was too young to remember 80s

We haven't had a better DM than Gueye since then IMO

 

[Joey66]

I would have loved to have seen Bobby Collins he was dumped sold in 1962 before we won the league like Bally he never wanted to leave ... I just missed him - evidently scored 18 goals in one season from midfield for us - sold to Leeds for peanuts they were bottom of the league in the old division 3 - Don Revie knew what he was getting they rose like cream - in 1965 Leeds lost the old 1st division on goal difference in 1965 - got to the FA Cup final to be beat by the other lot - Bobby Collins that year was Footballer of the year,
My question is would he if he had stayed got into your favourite Blues team?if you had the privilege to have seen him play that is?
He came to us when we were relegation fodder hauled us up the table into the top six captained the side - sold as he was deemed to old... Everton that.... as Leeds became our nemesis in the late 1960s.....

 

[Kever10]

1992, I was too young to remember 80s

We haven't had a better DM than Gueye since then IMO

Dya reckon? I mean, other than work rate, do people genuinely think he is a top player? We've had some bad teams over the years, but even in those bad teams, including teams Gueye was in, we've had top players, and there's no shortage of midfielders in that mix. At the very least, I would say Dacourt was better than Gueye in almost every area, barring probably distance covered (i don't there will be any data to confirm or deny this as the stats driven data of today outweighs anything had even 20 years ago) and maybe discipline.

Just amazes me how many people go on about Gueye like he was some difference maker.

Each to their own i guess.

 

[Bkk Andy]

I'm stunned how many people who've named 80's players think that Lukaku is better than Lineker.

 

[Bkk Andy]

Southall
Stevens, Watson, Ratcliffe, Baines
Kanchelskis, Reid, Bracewell, Sheedy
Rooney, Lineker

 

[blueboy1945]

West
Wright Wilson
Gabriel Labone Kay
Scott Stevens Young Vernon Ring

 

[blueboy1945]

I would have loved to have seen Bobby Collins he was dumped sold in 1962 before we won the league like Bally he never wanted to leave ... I just missed him - evidently scored 18 goals in one season from midfield for us - sold to Leeds for peanuts they were bottom of the league in the old division 3 - Don Revie knew what he was getting they rose like cream - in 1965 Leeds lost the old 1st division on goal difference in 1965 - got to the FA Cup final to be beat by the other lot - Bobby Collins that year was Footballer of the year,
My question is would he if he had stayed got into your favourite Blues team?if you had the privilege to have seen him play that is?
He came to us when we were relegation fodder hauled us up the table into the top six captained the side - sold as he was deemed to old... Everton that.... as Leeds became our nemesis in the late 1960s.....

Yes Joey, I couldn't understand why he left at the time, I think the management thought he was past it! Very skilful, very hot tempered, but a great player. I only picked Dennis Stevens ahead of him in my team because he fitted in to the team ethic a little better, although his skill level and ability to excite were not on Bobby Collins level.

 

[Joe123451978]

Parkinson, Dacourt, Carsley, Fellaini, Barry, Mccarthy. I'd say Allan but it's early days.

I'd have Fernandes before Gueye, but it stings knowing what could've been.

No chance half of them are as good as Gueye, Parkinson maybe. The rest no chance

 

[Goat]

If people put Gana in the side they can only have been watching us for 5years.

 

[Furey1878]

Martyn

Coleman----Jagielka---Lescott----Baines

Arteta---------Barry
James--------------------------------Richarlison

Rooney---------
----------Lukaku​

 

[Goat]

Southall
Stevens - Ratcliffe - Jagielka - LB3
Hamez - Reid - Arteta - Sheedy
Lineker - Lukaku​

 

[Joey66]

Yes Joey, I couldn't understand why he left at the time, I think the management thought he was past it! Very skilful, very hot tempered, but a great player. I only picked Dennis Stevens ahead of him in my team because he fitted in to the team ethic a little better, although his skill level and ability to excite were not on Bobby Collins level.

I know Dennis Stevens had it rough replacing Bobby Collins, but with missing seeing him what was he like as a player- he had been injured - The Catt looked at his age, &,
It was good bye .....
A disastrous transfer very much like Bally......neither of them wanted to leave ..

 

[Debunkology]

Dya reckon? I mean, other than work rate, do people genuinely think he is a top player? We've had some bad teams over the years, but even in those bad teams, including teams Gueye was in, we've had top players, and there's no shortage of midfielders in that mix. At the very least, I would say Dacourt was better than Gueye in almost every area, barring probably distance covered (i don't there will be any data to confirm or deny this as the stats driven data of today outweighs anything had even 20 years ago) and maybe discipline.

Just amazes me how many people go on about Gueye like he was some difference maker.

Each to their own i guess.

If I didn't choose Gueye. I would have chosen Barry.

Dacourt was quality, and I was gutted when he left. But we didnt miss him half as much as when Gana left.

 

[Furey1878]

Martyn

Coleman----Jagielka---Lescott----Baines

Arteta---------Barry
James--------------------------------Richarlison

Rooney---------
----------Lukaku​

Bench:
Pickford
Distin
Digne
Carsley
Cahill
Pienaar
DCL

 

[consho]

West, Stevens, Labone, Watson, Wilson, Steven, Kendall, Ball, Sheedy, Hickson, Lineker.