Moyes - should he stay or should he go?

Should Moyes..

  • Stay?

    Votes: 351 61.5%

  • Go?

    Votes: 220 38.5%
  • Total voters
    571

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

→ Log in 🔑 Register
Status
Not open for further replies.
jazzy said:
The McGinn one is interesting.

There was derision on here about the possibility of us signing him because he was too old and not good enough.

He has been superb for Villa and makes them tick.

Imagine if he was coming in off the right flank instead of Dibling.

Sometimes football hipsters know sweet FA.
Click to expand...

It’s a really tricky one mate - I think we still are trying to find an identity - what is Everton and what is our philosophy and what is our approach to things, no one really knows.

McGinn is interesting* un the sense in that does he make us better this season - 100% yes.

Could we be stuck with him on a four year contract o. over 100k a week after 18 months - also yes.

It’s that soul searching between immediate improvement and long term strategy and planning that I think will lead to confrontation by the manager and administration.
 
matty1878 said:
people think we will sack moyes and the new manager will have us raiding up and down the wingers with overlaps

and scoring 6 goals every week
Click to expand...
No we don’t, but maybe there will be a plan and maybe he won’t stick a 6ft 6 CB at RB and play Dwight McNeil RW and play Harrison Armstrong left wing one game, number 10 the game before. Maybe his tactics won’t be booting long and hope for the best
 
I'm in the Moyes should go at the end of the season camp.

The poor recruitment has been used as a stick to beat him with.

The problem is that we don't actually know exactly what the balance of power is with regard to signings.

Most people say Moyes has the final say. They may be right but we don't know

Some say a player can't be signed without Moyes approval, sounds the same but it's not.

Looking at the signings there appear to be 2 different strategies. Players for now ( KDH and Grealish ) and players for the future ( Rohl ,Aznou, Barry and Dibling)

Given that we spent £30m on ready made players and £100 m on prospects I find it hard to reconcile Moyes involvement.

Either he wanted the players and intended to play them - poor judgment by him - or he expected to spend more on ready made players and the recruitment team failed to get them over the line or there was less in the war chest than Moyes thought.

Either way it's a monumental cock up.

Question is who is to blame?
 
blueboy72 said:
No we don’t, but maybe there will be a plan and maybe he won’t stick a 6ft 6 CB at RB and play Dwight McNeil RW and play Harrison Armstrong left wing one game, number 10 the game before. Maybe his tactics won’t be booting long and hope for the best
Click to expand...

i just said get full backs or play a RB that
you already have

he’s used mcneil/ harrison as we’ve had to
 
matty1878 said:
we can’t get europe IE personnel wise

we would have an even bigger build then we do have.

we can all agree disagree etc

i think when we have all fit we are a good side mate

and IF we had the better strikers/ full backs it would improve us no end

most the games we’ve lost as to we can’t score

goals win games mate
Click to expand...
Yes but you need to attack to score goals mate. We have had 3 home games in a week against bang average opposition and we’ve stunk the gaff out. When we have our best players available it’s he the ball to Grealish and Ndiaye and hope they do something. And they’re plenty of full backs out there, but are manager insists on prem experience
 
blueboy72 said:
Yes but you need to attack to score goals mate. We have had 3 home games in a week against bang average opposition and we’ve stunk the gaff out. When we have our best players available it’s he the ball to Grealish and Ndiaye and hope they do something. And they’re plenty of full backs out there, but are manager insists on prem experience
Click to expand...

well it’s moyes being a nob prior to brentford changing a winning side

yr it is the ball to grealish and ndyie

but that then opens for KDH etc

that can’t mark all our attackers

and again a striker mate who we
know can score
 
He's not going anywhere lads so you might as well just get used to it. TFG knew exactly what they where getting with Moyes. He's a steady-eddy here for stability and nowt else. We're currently 12 points better off than we where this time last season and have never once looked like being in a relegation battle. That might not be enough for any of us but if you look at it dispassionately its objectively an improvement on the previous four season while protecting the owners involvement. If they had ambition then they'd never have brought Moyes in at all, let alone kept him in the summer. No I'm afraid that he's here until his contract expires or we get worse and end up in a relegation dogfight and lets he honest, some of you might hate Moyes but you must know that isn't going to happen.
 
Find it interesting that we should accept this poor run of form and the cup exit should be accepted as inevitable as we all knew that AFCON and injuries from the busy schedule would arise.

Fair enough. So why didn't Moyes?

Why didn't he bring in cover in the Summer?

He's done what he was supposed to, stabilise us post Dyche. Time to say Thanks and so long. Let's stop wasting time and get things moving forward again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar Threads

Back
Top