Transfer Rumour Memphis Depay

[Ashtonian]

View attachment 33497

Never learns does he.

I don't believe for one minute esk is making any of his stuff up.

I also believe where he is getting the info from is completely wrong and we shouldn't believe his word as gospel.

but for making things up? I don't think he would even be arsed to do that.

 

[ijjysmith]

oh i see, we have to be 'fair' now do we?

GOT -its like living in nazi germany, or maybe current north korea..or somewhere else horrible like luton

I'm very rarely fair when ITK's come to town Neil.

He mentioned that Deulofeu leaving as being another sign of Memphis joining, but said many times it was going to be completed.

Hopefully he's right with VVD at least lol

I highly doubt it Decs.

 

[Deco]

I'm very rarely fair when ITK's come to town Neil.



I highly doubt it Decs.

Me too mate, me too.

We need some players mate big time. I'd take a Mertens..

 

[Ashtonian]

To be fair he did say, if Deulofeu goes to Milan we will go for Depay. Or words to that effect. Well Deulofeu hasn't gone to Milan.

Eventualities are easy to wriggle out of, if this happens etc

I just don't think what esk finds out is very trustworthy. After the summer, in all fairness whatever the real story behind the players, he got them all wrong from his source.

So as i said above, i don't think he is making things up, but where he finds the stuff out is no better than indikiller on twitter.

 

[ijjysmith]

Eventualities are easy to wriggle out of, if this happens etc

I just don't think what esk finds out is very trustworthy. After the summer, in all fairness whatever the real story behind the players, he got them all wrong from his source.

So as i said above, i don't think he is making things up, but where he finds the stuff out is no better than indikiller on twitter.

You now I hate agreeing with you Ash but I do here.

Esk doesn't strike me as they type to just make stuff up. What would be the point? But he's getting info that isn't complete or not giving him the whole story. Yes it's nice of him to pass stuff over on here or Twitter but i'd rather not read it myself as it doesn't seem too accurate. Things change I know. Maybe his use of language could be better as it builds people's hopes up.

If he doesn't mind the flak he gets when things inevitably go tits up then fair enough, but can't be nice being on the backlash of everything that hasn't happened.

 

[gaino92]

Eventualities are easy to wriggle out of, if this happens etc

I just don't think what esk finds out is very trustworthy. After the summer, in all fairness whatever the real story behind the players, he got them all wrong from his source.

So as i said above, i don't think he is making things up, but where he finds the stuff out is no better than indikiller on twitter.

No one is as bad as that absolute scrote

 

[bluestevon]

To be fair he did say, if Deulofeu goes to Milan we will go for Depay. Or words to that effect. Well Deulofeu hasn't gone to Milan.

Meanwhilst unless i am mistaken WRD never made any mention of Depay did he? and instead mentioned Mertens?

 

[Foot Long Hot Dog]

£14.7m not that expensive. Let's trust Koeman and Walsh' judgement. We will land someone just a matter of time.

Word is that the player fancied a move away from the PL, and we knew so backed off.

 

[Mikeonlythebestwilldo]

You now I hate agreeing with you Ash but I do here.

Esk doesn't strike me as they type to just make stuff up. What would be the point? But he's getting info that isn't complete or not giving him the whole story. Yes it's nice of him to pass stuff over on here or Twitter but i'd rather not read it myself as it doesn't seem too accurate. Things change I know. Maybe his use of language could be better as it builds people's hopes up.

If he doesn't mind the flak he gets when things inevitably go tits up then fair enough, but can't be nice being on the backlash of everything that hasn't happened.

Could be things getting changed last minute like ??? Like last summer he got the targets right but they didn't want to come or the club wouldn't sell like and then plan b had to come in theirs been proof spoke of moshiri himself about it

 

[Ashtonian]

No one is as bad as that absolute scrote

haha what i mean is the news is as reliable as anything like that.

I'm sure most of us if we read something that seemed genuine then we would mention it here, hell the other forum had blurred pics in starbucks yesterday! Point is, just because it turns out to be wrong it doesn't make the person passing it on bad as well. Because i genuinely believe (never met him either) that he was just passing things on and 100% believing the news himself

And as always, why would he want to make things up? He had no gain and probably not arsed if people believed the news or not.

 

[ijjysmith]

Meanwhilst unless i am mistaken WRD never made any mention of Depay did he? and instead mentioned Mertens?

Not sure mate

 

[ijjysmith]

Could be things getting changed last minute like ??? Like last summer he got the targets right but they didn't want to come or the club wouldn't sell like and then plan b had to come in theirs been proof spoke of moshiri himself about it

It could be of course mate. That's the thing though, nobody knows, so if you're giving info out then it needs to be with a caveat that it could go tits up.

 

[Mikeonlythebestwilldo]

It could be of course mate. That's the thing though, nobody knows, so if you're giving info out then it needs to be with a caveat that it could go tits up.

The only thing he got wrong was the usamnov link which wrd got right to a degree but he wasn't spot on everyone is different everyone's got a different opinion and different info comes out like gossip now you start it another tells another by the end of the street the story has changed I respect everyone on this forum good bunch of blues

 

[tommye]

The only thing he got wrong was the usamnov link which wrd got right to a degree but he wasn't spot on everyone is different everyone's got a different opinion and different info comes out like gossip now you start it another tells another by the end of the street the story has changed I respect everyone on this forum good bunch of blues

 

[bluestevon]

It could be of course mate. That's the thing though, nobody knows, so if you're giving info out then it needs to be with a caveat that it could go tits up.

My take on all things ITK, if someone drops in, drops out with a very occasional bit of info and don't generally hang around for the adulation etc, then yeah can accept that, had a few in the past such as DAVIDMOYES who did so

The main issue with last sumer etc, was a poster - a long time and respected one, was making a lot of predictions - supported by inside tip offs from someone inside the club, and by and large far too many of them weren't being given as opinions or as this may happen etc, but where either said to be effectively done deals, or intimated as such with a nod and a wink and a twitter picture or pronouncement to show the confidence.

You go playing the ITK game, then if it goes belly up and 99% of what you predict doesnt happen then expect to be torn apart on a forum tbh, sure as hell that if you get things spot on your gonna take all the likes and fawning over your every posts that would come with that as well. So honestly very little sympathy over the entire business (and thats as someone who has spoken to him a fair bit and likes the guy as well)