Liverpool v Everton. 27th Sep at 12.45.

[Blue 1]

Is it McAllister-esque, tide turning material?

I wouldn't call it McAllister-esque. Jags didn't cheat.

 

[Eggs]

The one where the shot hits his hands? You having a laugh?

How on earth can he block it in any other way than he jumped?He was a yard away from him. Jones for UTD at home to us last year is a definite peno; that yesterday is certainly not.

...glad the ref had the same opinion as you, especially in front of the Kop. It was a pen for me, arms above his head with sufficient distance between him and the striker. We got away with it but plenty more credit to be had on that score.

 

[Eggs]

.......some are saying its the greatest ever goal scored in the kop. They don't like that, they don't like that at all so I think we should officially declare it. EVERTON'S PHIL JAGIELKA SCORED THE GREATEST GOAL EVER SEEN IN THE KOP END - official. Tell all your buddies in work, university, the pub and on the internet.

....think I've started something with this one early this morning. Keep the momentum going, spread the word and make them sick.

 

[Prevenger17]

The Barry incident was a penalty every day of the week, but I'll shamelessly accept Atkinson's view of it. We were due a bit of luck.

 

[Chang Elephant]

...glad the ref had the same opinion as you, especially in front of the Kop. It was a pen for me, arms above his head with sufficient distance between him and the striker.

When you're trying to block a shot wouldn't the arms be outstretched to the side, what's the point in deliberately blocking something that's flying over the bar ?

 

[matty1878]

Lukaku should of had a pen

 

[Eggs]

When you're trying to block a shot wouldn't the arms be outstretched to the side, what's the point in deliberately blocking something that's flying over the bar ?

...I always think the term 'deliberate' is a misnomer. Very few handballs are 'deliberate' I would say. Not sure if the rule still says deliberate. It was probably a instinctive reaction from Barry, but if the arm is significantly outside the body and the ball catches it then you can gain an advantage. Definite penalty for me, lets agree to disagree.

 

[Tubey]

It was a definite pen, but so was the one on Lukaku, which conveniently the RS have obliterated from their cultist minds.

 

[meagher94]

Hendo primed to take slippy's armband. Snarling at Rom to get up when he'd been pulled down in the box, harrassing the ref. Barging into the back of players and that somehow being a fair challenge. Next home derby we best be how I like my women, fast aggressive and nasty. Rom should learn a bit of grit from big Dunc.

Was gonna say, if he was telling Rom to get up he should've got up, squared up to him and told him where to go.

Poor hardman-Hendo would have soiled his shorts.

 

[Ring master]

Both Incidents for pens should have been given and if anyone says different they are been silly,but to be fair to Barry who really should be sent off for 2nd yellow, i think he was just saving the shot from ending up in the crowd as it looked to be way off target lol

 

[Woolly Blue]

It was a definite pen, but so was the one on Lukaku, which conveniently the RS have obliterated from their cultist minds.

Correct.

If Barry hadn't been in a Blue shirt we'd all have said it's a penalty. Under those circumstances, arms raised away from body, shot at goal, you'd get a penalty more often than not. We should have had one, they should have had one so the ref had a bit of a nightmare which ended up evening itself out.

 

[riddick]

If Chelsea dont get the hand ball against Barcelona than thats no a penalty for me either.






ok, not really, it was a deffo penalty every day of the week. At least have SOME semblance of your hands near your side. He was flailing about like a [Poor language removed] child.

 

[TGW89]

I said on here last week we would get something out of it if we steadied at the back and controlled our passing more. For all their pre match "another 4-0" and also the hiding to nothing that was feared in some quarters didn't materialise. After the first twenty minutes, I thought we were much improved in passing and technique...one particular midfield move involving 3/4 players was pure class. It was a coming of age for the likes of young John Stones who can only go on now to be a rock for us at the back especially as Jags was on song defensively and seems to have got his confidence back, his fantastic goal apart, and theyre sorted as a unit I reckon. My big fear was regarding Tony Hibbert but that proved unfounded as Stirling was hardly in it with McCarthy backing up on the right so their drooling over how he'd rip him apart was the usual kopite static noise. Weve got Coleman, Barkley to come back and Browning in the squad, with Garbutt and young Chris Long on the edge of it. The futures bright. Unlike our noisy neighbours, we don't have delusions of grandeur regarding our status and don't have £120m to spend (or whatever they p'd up against the wall) trying to achieve it. Tell you what though, yesterday shone the spotlight on some things regarding them too. The final script wasn't as theyd read, with Jags's choker absolutely stunning them, manager, captain and the cult members.

 

[N.S.N.O.]

I reckon Barry could have saved Jagielka's goal....

 

[L4Everton]

Was laughing my ass of yesterday, am laughing my ass off today. Cheers kopites.