LEE PROBERT

Status
Not open for further replies.
All our bookings were correct?

Are you injecting actual smack?

As far as i can remember they were.

Fellainis was late and he jumped in, might have bruished the ball but still a yellow. Pienaars first was similar and his second was lucky not to be a straight red. Osmans was for delaying the start of play. Jelavic was for taking his shirt off.

Thats just the law mate, even if you disagree they should be bookings the law say they should.
 

Lee Probert and the wanking rat - separated at birth? We should be told.

Lee
10z2qon.gif


Rat
2225376595.jpg
 
Maybe he didnt give them a pen on purpose? He gave them one for nothing in the reverse fixture and will have seen the mistake his linesman made at halftime.

Probably not but these things surely play on the refs' mind.
 
As far as i can remember they were.

Fellainis was late and he jumped in, might have bruished the ball but still a yellow. Pienaars first was similar and his second was lucky not to be a straight red. Osmans was for delaying the start of play. Jelavic was for taking his shirt off.

Thats just the law mate, even if you disagree they should be bookings the law say they should.

Think it was more because he booked our players yet the likes of Milner somehow never got booked for his numerous fouls. Barry tackle on Distin when he was in the air was bad and don't think he even got booked for that.

He was just awful and if he gives that handball on Fellaini, don't see how he can't give a pen. Really poor ref in general.
 

Wonder if his performance was inspired by todays 4th official none other than Martin Atkinson!!! A word or two in quasimodo's ear maybe dirty conniving maggots
 
The quality of english refs seems to have plummeted the last 5 years.

Does anyone have an opinion of the refs in the bundesliga?
 
Think it was more because he booked our players yet the likes of Milner somehow never got booked for his numerous fouls. Barry tackle on Distin when he was in the air was bad and don't think he even got booked for that.

He was just awful and if he gives that handball on Fellaini, don't see how he can't give a pen. Really poor ref in general.

Refs shouldn't give out bookings because fans think that cause he booked a player on their team he should book one on the other team.

As i said, our bookings were all correct, he was wrong to not book Milner. I think the Barry one was 50/50 and i'm not sure why he booked Dzeko when he did. Mind you thinking back he might have booked Kolarov due to pressure from the crowd.

The penalty he didn't give was an awful decision.

After every game i can pretty much gaurantee fans from opposing teams will have different views on the refs performance, i just try and look at it completly unbiased.
 
As the poster above says, all our bookings were pretty much spot on. Referees don't have a lot of leeway with certain offences. Taking your shirt off is a yellow whether in the first minute or last. I thought he could've shown Pienaar a straight red for that 2nd yellow. I did think Fellaini's booking was a tad harsh, but in the context of the game, not much.

He seemed to book a couple of the Man City players as almost totting up for team fouls, when in actual fact he should've shown yellow's earlier. The Mirallas offside was a linesman call, and to be fair it was marginal and at speed, still bloody annoying tho. The "penalty" for Fellaini's handball was actually given for hands against Osman, who was outside the box. The ref was clearly explaining it to him. Good job, because Fellaini was a nailed on penalty, and an over-officious referee could've shown a yellow, therefore 2nd red.

Probert is an absolute lemon though, and overall gave a pristine example of how referees favour the monied teams. There's too much of it been going on for years to be pure coincidence. Not suggesting corruption, but there's definite bias.
 
I'm not looking for a conspiracy but I really think that the refs and officials have someone talking in their ear this season. I don't know if its the forth official or someone watching TV replays but there has been two massive decisions that have gone our way this season at goodison.

1) Fellainis handball today
2) Suarezs last minute disallowed goal

In both games we had been the victim of awful decisions ( off side goal today and rat faces horrific raking his foot down the back of Disitns achillies) Is this a coincidence? Are the refs aware they have made an awful mistake so they try to make amends? Also, whilst you cant complain about Pienaars second yellow in normal time it seemed nothing, its only when you saw the reply you realised it was a poor challenge. Probert took his time to show the yellow, did someone have a word in his ear?
 

I'm not looking for a conspiracy but I really think that the refs and officials have someone talking in their ear this season. I don't know if its the forth official or someone watching TV replays but there has been two massive decisions that have gone our way this season at goodison.

1) Fellainis handball today
2) Suarezs last minute disallowed goal

In both games we had been the victim of awful decisions ( off side goal today and rat faces horrific raking his foot down the back of Disitns achillies) Is this a coincidence? Are the refs aware they have made an awful mistake so they try to make amends? Also, whilst you cant complain about Pienaars second yellow in normal time it seemed nothing, its only when you saw the reply you realised it was a poor challenge. Probert took his time to show the yellow, did someone have a word in his ear?

Don't see why they'd do that tbh. In the aftermath, all the focus would be on the decision that went for us, rather than against us so they'd still end up looking bad in the long run.
 
Refs want to be applauded and will get more applauds if they favour the super rich teams than if they favour the poor.

People, especially the TV-people, like to pretend its not so but everyone know it is.

Take Utd as an example. Refs in this country have been scared of Ferguson for years and Utd get more off them than any other club in the league, followed by Liverpool.

Ask utd fans they´ll admit they usually have a very good time off referees. And we all know about the multitude of matches were the ref have done teams at Anfield over the years. All those Stevie G dives when Liverpool are chasing an equaliser comes to mind.
 
I think you need to accept that as far as we were concerned his decisions to book Fellaini was spot on, Pienaar too (after giving a really poor free kick when two players bumped into each other - a nothing situation - Pienaar went in two footed). The 2nd Pienaar yellow looked, from where I was watching, like a clumsy foot up for a devious bounce. It seemed the City player made an awful lot out of nothing (if there was no connection or intent). I thought Osman was booked because the returning ball (to the City player for the free kick) accidentally bobbled in the wrong direction - looked a poor decision.

That apart he made a number of poor calls where City players should have been booked - the Mirallas goal was his assistants fault - the pen he didn't give us was poor, the pen he didn't give City is apparently the correct decision.

He relied on the assistant to give Fellaini his yellow card. Yes he was poor but the red for Pienaar only galvanised us - I wasn't bothered as I thought we would win and get a 2nd goal. Simply put City were 2nd best and after the card they didn't up their game (barring a short spell) - we had a few chances before the killer goal. So we can enjoy the result and moan about Probert if need be.
 
I can't blame him for Mirallas's goal and we are lucky that Fellani didn't get sent off for the handball. My only real complaint was that if you are going to throw out Pinnear then you got to do the same against Milner who committed about 18 fouls on the day.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top