2025/26 Jarrad Branthwaite

Not how teams work in my expierence mate.

Might be short order because he’s quality, but bad management of him and p,Ayers who covered fir him.
If Tarkowski had been outstanding this season I might agree, but he's been patchy. I think it would be fair enough to just get on with playing Branthwaite and O'Brien and see if they can start to develop a partnership, considering they will be the pairing long term.

As I said though priority needs to be keeping Branthwaite fit ultimately. We've fortunately got the depth in that position to manage his fitness as much as we need to.
 
If Tarkowski had been outstanding this season I might agree, but he's been patchy. I think it would be fair enough to just get on with playing Branthwaite and O'Brien and see if they can start to develop a partnership, considering they will be the pairing long term.

As I said though priority needs to be keeping Branthwaite fit ultimately. We've fortunately got the depth in that position to manage his fitness as much as we need to.
I'd be amazed if Tarkowski gets dropped. I'd guess it will be one of Branthwaite, Keane or O'Brien alongside him.
 
If Tarkowski had been outstanding this season I might agree, but he's been patchy. I think it would be fair enough to just get on with playing Branthwaite and O'Brien and see if they can start to develop a partnership, considering they will be the pairing long term.

As I said though priority needs to be keeping Branthwaite fit ultimately. We've fortunately got the depth in that position to manage his fitness as much as we need to.

It’s a fair point mate JT hasn’t been great this year, actually think he’s come into a bit of form the last two - as I say it’s fair point - but realistically will happen - not in a million years,Mir will be him and another ….id think we’d all be surprised if it’s not.

Agreed he’s our highest quality defender….but also shouldn’t walk back into the team, no one should…they all need to get a shirt from the lad holding it…if he just walks straight back in…why give max effort if he knows he’s a shoe.

While Keane and JOB - why bother trying if Branthwaite just sails back in. You have to keep them motivated and all competitive with each other. We may need them again as we have needed them the last 24 games.
 
It’s a fair point mate JT hasn’t been great this year, actually think he’s come into a bit of form the last two - as I say it’s fair point - but realistically will happen - not in a million years,Mir will be him and another ….id think we’d all be surprised if it’s not.

Agreed he’s our highest quality defender….but also shouldn’t walk back into the team, no one should…they all need to get a shirt from the lad holding it…if he just walks straight back in…why give max effort if he knows he’s a shoe.

While Keane and JOB - why bother trying if Branthwaite just sails back in. You have to keep them motivated and all competitive with each other. We may need them again as we have needed them the last 24 games.
I do agree that the squad needs to be kept competitive, just personally think a few players (Branthwaite, KDH, Ndiaye, Garner) are a cut above the rest of the squad and realistically should always be starting if they're fit. Iroegbunam, Alcaraz, Keane, Gana all should be fighting to earn their place back in the team.

Also agree that Moyes won't bench Tarks, though I think he arguably should. Very harsh on O'Brien if he loses his place once Branthwaite is back.
 
I do agree that the squad needs to be kept competitive, just personally think a few players (Branthwaite, KDH, Ndiaye, Garner) are a cut above the rest of the squad and realistically should always be starting if they're fit. Iroegbunam, Alcaraz, Keane, Gana all should be fighting to earn their place back in the team.

Also agree that Moyes won't bench Tarks, though I think he arguably should. Very harsh on O'Brien if he loses his place once Branthwaite is back.

I think it’s fair enough if he missed a couple of games and the Keane and JOB had howlers, but they e both made huge contributions, I don’t think he will or should bring him straight back in - I think he will be in shortly because he’s that good though amd when he get the chance it will be obvious.

Thinking back to Rooney, even he had to earn his spot in the beginning. Dibling will have to do the same.

Think actually Idrissa has to earn his place in the team now also, I’ll be annoyed if he just slots straight back in. Garner has shone without him.
 
It’s a fair point mate JT hasn’t been great this year, actually think he’s come into a bit of form the last two - as I say it’s fair point - but realistically will happen - not in a million years,Mir will be him and another ….id think we’d all be surprised if it’s not.

Agreed he’s our highest quality defender….but also shouldn’t walk back into the team, no one should…they all need to get a shirt from the lad holding it…if he just walks straight back in…why give max effort if he knows he’s a shoe.

While Keane and JOB - why bother trying if Branthwaite just sails back in. You have to keep them motivated and all competitive with each other. We may need them again as we have needed them the last 24 games.
They get paid handsomely to be motivated and Branthwaite is our only left footed centre back. His distribution long and short will be a massive plus for us even not taking into account his all round excellence.
 
I don't even know if this happens any more but if he's approaching full fitness in training surely he should play either in a behind closed doors friendly or one of the u23 games to get a bit of match sharpness back, before he gets on the field for us.

As long as O'Brien isn't shifted to right back, we're thankfully not absolutely desperate for JB to be immediately put back in the side.

Maybe he'll come on for us to see out the game if we're lucky to get two up against Leeds on Monday.
 
I don't even know if this happens any more but if he's approaching full fitness in training surely he should play either in a behind closed doors friendly or one of the u23 games to get a bit of match sharpness back, before he gets on the field for us.

As long as O'Brien isn't shifted to right back, we're thankfully not absolutely desperate for JB to be immediately put back in the side.

Maybe he'll come on for us to see out the game if we're lucky to get two up against Leeds on Monday.

Yes I think that would send me over the edge if he reverted Obrien to right back as Patterson has done very well there the last couple of games and the whole team has benefited as we look so much more balanced as a team. Think myself Branthwaite should be introduced carefully last 15 minutes then 25 then try him for a full game.
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top