• 🔵Introducing our Everton Newswire – all the latest credible Everton news in one place, updated every 15 mins. Find it in the 'Whats New' section.

January Transfer Window 2026

Obviously just my opinion but way too much recency bias on Wilson and McNeil I think.

This is Wilson's first ever season in the prem with Fulham where he's started more than half the games he's played in. That's a squad player for a midtable side.

He's nearly 29 and is over performing his xG and xA this year by pretty much double. That's not a player who will maintain this level of form, he's on an insane finishing streak and also the players he's passed to have finished off difficult chances rather than him putting it on a plate. He's having the absolute season of his life very late in his career, that's all, he's not suddenly a different player. And he doesn't do anything else useful in build up or out of possession

I wouldn't hate it on a free in the summer if the wages are okay! You need experienced squad players knocking around. But that's all he is imo

Ok, now review McNeil’s career.
 
He is client journalist for TFG.

He has had all the scoops before anyone else.
Nonsense mate
Mentioning we will have 70mil in the summer we spent over 100 last summer and he mentioned strikers,
But forget to mention the only striker this January we have actually enquired about. Tammy Abraham
 
Obviously just my opinion but way too much recency bias on Wilson and McNeil I think.

This is Wilson's first ever season in the prem with Fulham where he's started more than half the games he's played in. That's a squad player for a midtable side.

He's nearly 29 and is over performing his xG and xA this year by pretty much double. That's not a player who will maintain this level of form, he's on an insane finishing streak and also the players he's passed to have finished off difficult chances rather than him putting it on a plate. He's having the absolute season of his life very late in his career, that's all, he's not suddenly a different player. And he doesn't do anything else useful in build up or out of possession

I wouldn't hate it on a free in the summer if the wages are okay! You need experienced squad players knocking around. But that's all he is imo
He payed 29 first season, 35, 2nd season and 25 last season. Not sure how many starts or how many missed through injury. But that suggests he’s started more than he hasn’t
 
Ok, now review McNeil’s career.
Starter for a relegation candidate team or squad player for a mid table team. Like he has been for 8 seasons

He also had more goals & assists per 90 mins for us last season than Wilson has had for Fulham this season, if you want to judge a player entirely on one short period of output.
 
He payed 29 first season, 35, 2nd season and 25 last season. Not sure how many starts or how many missed through injury. But that suggests he’s started more than he hasn’t
93030.webp

First column of numbers is appearances is matched played, second is starts. Never started more than half the ones he's played in before this season. Doesn't take into account games he was on the bench and never came on either

Squad player!
 
Nonsense mate
Mentioning we will have 70mil in the summer we spent over 100 last summer and he mentioned strikers,
But forget to mention the only striker this January we have actually enquired about. Tammy Abraham

Mark Douglas had all the scoops about the takeover before anyone else last year and quite a few different stories before the likes of Joyce.

He is getting his input from the TFG side.
 
Starter for a relegation candidate team or squad player for a mid table team. Like he has been for 8 seasons

He also had more goals & assists per 90 mins for us last season than Wilson has had for Fulham this season, if you want to judge a player entirely on one short period of output.
He’s got 12 goals and assists in 21 games this season. I doubt McNeil has ever had 12 goal involvements in a full season.
 
He’s got 12 goals and assists in 21 games this season. I doubt McNeil has ever had 12 goal involvements in a full season.
I'm going to stop replying because I'm just telling you things you can literally look up.

He has 0.63 goals and assists per 90 mins this season, McNeil last season for us had 0.66

It's really really good! But the likelihood of him doing it again is incredibly slim
 
Mark Douglas had all the scoops about the takeover before anyone else last year and quite a few different stories before the likes of Joyce.

He is getting his input from the TFG side.
According to the internet, not sure how true, but apparently he reports on Newcastle’s thats his
Main club. So im not sure why he’d be the client journalist for Everton and TFG
 
Starter for a relegation candidate team or squad player for a mid table team. Like he has been for 8 seasons

He also had more goals & assists per 90 mins for us last season than Wilson has had for Fulham this season, if you want to judge a player entirely on one short period of output.

McNeil is a squad player for a relegation haunted team. He won’t be joining a mid table club when he leaves us.
 

Similar Threads

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top