James McCarthy

[chicoazul]

Very! Was the 10 minutes it took to do the above time well spent?

Oh the quotes? Sorry mate no I was just reading through the thread examing what was said rather than who said it. So I thought I'd pick out some of the worse posts in the hope that as a forum we improve and learn not to make knee jerk ridiculous statements. Apologies as I can see maybe it looks like I've singled you out but you weren't alone.

 

[Tubey]

Oh the quotes? Sorry mate no I was just reading through the thread examing what was said rather than who said it. So I thought I'd pick out some of the worse posts in the hope that as a forum we improve and learn not to make knee jerk ridiculous statements. Apologies as I can see maybe it looks like I've singled you out but you weren't alone.

 

[phil j]

Very! Was the 10 minutes it took to do the above time well spent?

More to the point, how long did it take YOU to do the drivel he quoted?

 

[chicoazul]

I thought he was only a six out of ten today like.

 

[chicoazul]

More to the point, how long did it take YOU to do the drivel he quoted?

 

[Furey1878]

More to the point, how long did it take YOU to do the drivel he quoted?

hahahahahaha

 

[lmurkder]

Blood everywhere. What's going on?

 

[bluemangroup]

I didn't say I knew him inside out. I'm making the point that he's hardly been invisible to any football fan who follows the Premier League has he? I've certainly seen enough to "justify a proper opinion on him", let's put it that way.

I have an opinion on Chris Brunt, James McClean and hundreds of other footballers too. If you don't watch football and take an interest in other players other than those who wear the blue of Everton, that's your business, but you shouldn't be writing off legit opinions on a player on this forum based on your own limited knowledge of football.

My actual view is he's a decent, 6/10, consistent player for what it's worth.

This bit made me laugh.

 

[Brennan]

More to the point, how long did it take YOU to do the drivel he quoted?

'He's hit that on the full, straight over the bowler's head for six'

 

[Allezfan]

6 out of 10 is about right, i think.

I was thinking about how he doesn't dominate opposition the way Fellaini on his game did, but he just does his job every game and works really hard. We've swapped a guy who could do 10 out of 10s and also 1 out of 10s with a 6 every week. He just gives us such a consistent reliable base for our creative players to build from. Exactly what we've needed.

I was saying to Mikey last week, he's really the new Carsley. That sort of player and one we've really missed ever since we sold Lee. Worth every penny for us, I think. Was our glaring weakness.

 

[fozzy]

He's coming along fine. Fits in very well, still early days so its not fair to be vaulting posts from those who thought he was rubbish.

very few thought he was rubbish.

a few (me) thought he wasnt worth the price tag.

big difference

 

[chicoazul]

This bit made me laugh.

Hahaha its ace.

 

[chicoazul]

very few thought he was rubbish.

a few (me) thought he wasnt worth the price tag.

big difference

Aye it is. But its ok Foz I'm sure the good folk of GOT forgive you. Its not as if you've studied him and then wrote him off before he's kicked a ball for us. Merely offered a passing opinion, that's cool.

 

[bluemangroup]

Hahaha its ace.

Tubes work after the 20 minute cameo in the Chelsea game by Jimmy Mac shouldn't be forgotten either. I think that bottom comment is from then.

 

[lmurkder]

Aye it is. But its ok Foz I'm sure the good folk of GOT forgive you. Its not as if you've studied him and then wrote him off before he's kicked a ball for us. Merely offered a passing opinion, that's cool.

'Turbo Gash'