Jags Captain fantastic or Captain Calamity ?

[Kurt.]

Personally I think he’s been ace... a captain doesn’t have to go around shouting and screaming for 90 mins just so the fans in the stand know he’s on the pitch ala horrenderson .... if he’s respected by the players and manager alike then he’s doing his job... there’s a lot more to bring the club captain than what goes on on a Saturday afternoon

 

[davek]

1 in 5 people think the captain is worthy of the armband so far.

Please sign another CB, Silva, and get this fake leader out the reckoning for it.

 

[Mikey_Fitzgerald]

He's neither

 

[gonetomorrow]

Captain Courageous. It's time to sail on by.

 

[wainy]

Seamus should be in possession of the armband, been obvious for 3 seasons. Jags is a shrinking violet when the going gets tough.

 

[GwladysBlue]

Retire, leech.

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

How is he a bad captain? Because he does not scream at teammates and referees? The people in the best position to judge are his teammates and managers.

 

[fandjango]

1 in 5 people think the captain is worthy of the armband so far.

Please sign another CB, Silva, and get this fake leader out the reckoning for it.

Using your own false mathematics 52% think he is doing a good job

 

[Loadsofchemistry]

3 years of Moshiri & people forget 30 years of austerity Everton. John Spencer, Marc Hottiger & at least 60 others I’d rather forget have worn the Everton shirt...

Jagielka came in from Sheffield Utd for not much. He quickly became one of Moyes best pieces of business. He made Lescott look better than he was (defensively). He captained us to an FAC semi win & stood up to score the winning penalty. Did a great job on Drogba in the final. OK, we lost against abramovic’s millions, but still a fantastic effort. In terms of value for money, there’s not that many have given us more.

It’s not his fault the club hasn’t recruited better in the last 5 years, as he’s passed his peak!

He missed the final through injury mate. Pretty much agree with the restaurant though.

 

[Nyhus]

Solid defender, okey captain.

 

[d34noj]

I think after that England game, when Gerrard was captain and we got tonked (Don't recall who we played) and 'Captain fantastic' pussied out and hid in the changing rooms whilst Jagielka manned up and faced the music alone sums up what kind of man he is.

You don't need to scream and shout to be a leader of men - Gerrard and Henderson with all their false bravado are half the Captain Jagielka is.

 

[Rudolf Hucker]

He missed the final through injury mate. Pretty much agree with the restaurant though.

You’re right! My memory is sh1te. I remember a game though, when Jags & Drogba had a right battle & Drogba was all over him in recognition. Could have sworn it was at Wembley??

 

[Stan Lee Park]

1 in 5 people think the captain is worthy of the armband so far.

Please sign another CB, Silva, and get this fake leader out the reckoning for it.

Because the fans on this forum are the best judges of his ability.
Please sign another davek so we can have a proper discussion and not the usual diatribe.

 

[Dublin blue 75]

Football's grim reaper has been breathing down Philip's neck for a number of seasons at this point. Marco, put Philip and the rest of us out of our misery. Squad backup until January when we sign a second CB.. hopefully. And sixty grand for captain please also.

 

[Stan Lee Park]

Football's grim reaper has been breathing down Philip's neck for a number of seasons at this point. Marco, put Philip and the rest of us out of our misery. Squad backup until January when we sign a second CB.. hopefully. And sixty grand for captain please also.

Who would he be backing up in the current squad? Keane? Holgate? Besic? He's miles ahead of all these.