Maybe im a tad harsh mate didnt mean to cause offence, to phrase it better i dont think he contributes to the standard we need or grown into. But please dont play hes an Everton player he is beyond critisism card - your better then that - i support Everton not any one individual in the team - cetainly not one who costing the team. He had a good period from Feb to May - the year we got to the cup final and for me he has been a sliding scale liability since. When you say he had a good game against Swansea, he didnt make any mistakes - im sorry that doesnt constitute a good game, he had a game i expect as a baseline performence from an Everton keeper, he made one or two bread and butter saves i expect an everton goal keeper to make - he was simply doing what he should do for once - but its interesting that so many thought it was performence worthy of mention - really shows what we have come to expect from him.
I know we will never agree on him mate. But he is becomng problamatic - nuts and bolts.
Since I write off Anichebe occassionally of course I can't say that. I don't mean he's beyond criticism. But the level to which people criticize Tim - knowing his stats - which put him in the top suite of GKers bugs me. Everyone has a personal opinion on here, but imo people ignore the bold numbers (and unlike Anichebe, THo actually has years of them).
The Swansea game he wasn't just "doing his job" - he made two excellent saves in that match. Pulling saves out of your ass is not normal course of business.
Saying he doesn't contribute at all rankled me. Supporting the team also means supporting the players. Not blindly, but they make up your team. That should count for something.
We are always going to disagree on this, but I will post when I feel like posts go off the deep end. Glad you clarified.
