Goats squad analysis thread 2019/20

MarcelsGoat

Player Valuation: £90m
And like the Everton season ticket renewals, this thread seems to get earlier and earlier.

With my thoughts mostly drifting to next season and what the future brings, its time to take a look at the squad we hopefully wont be taking into next season. As always its not a speculation thread, its just a chance to look at the squad, track the signings, the sales, the loans and areas we can look to improve. As always its an ever-changing list, yoots have a chance to break in, break out and of course, its all based on my viewpoint, with hopefully dashings of everybody elses! Enjoy.

Manager: Marco Silva

GK
Jordan Pickford
João Virginia
Maarten Stekelenburg

RB
Séamus Coleman
Jonjoe Kenny

LB
Lucas Digne
Leighton Baines
Antonee Robinson
Brendan Galloway
Luke Garbutt
Cuco Martina

CB
Yerry Mina
Michael Keane
Mason Holgate
Phil Jagielka
Matthew Pennington
Ashley Williams

DM/CM/AM
Idrissa Gueye
Gylfi Sigurðsson
Tom Davies
James McCarthy
Morgan Schneiderlin
Muhamed Bešić
Kieran Dowell
Joe Williams
Beni Baningime
Callum Connolly
Nikola Vlašić
Kieran Dowell

Widers
Richarlison
Bernard
Theo Walcott
Ademola Lookman
Henry Onyekuru
Yannick Bolasie
Kevin Mirallas

ST
Dominic Calvert-Lewin
Cenk Tosun
Oumar Niasse
Sandro Ramírez
Shani Tarashaj

Total players: 41
Players culled so far: 0

Players purchased so far: 0


Analysis to follow........
 

MarcelsGoat

Player Valuation: £90m
GK
Tricky area for me, we of course have Pickford, who I personally consider a very good GK, prone to the odd howler, but I think hes more than good enough for what we wish to do. An ever-present in goal, so thankfully we havent had to rely on Stekkers at all, which is always good. As for next season, what do we do, do we retain Stekkers and hope that young Virginia can put some pressure on Pickford, prevent complacency from Pickford and hope and pray we never have to rely on Stekkers or do we use some of our very limited funds to get in a proper number 2? I would be going with option A myself, but it depends what sort of GK Brands can pick us up. Other than that im reasonably happy with this area of the pitch and as far as first team is concerned we are pretty much ok.

RB
60 grand I say. I honestly thought he was done, but the last few weeks the old Seamus has returned, but, he will be 31 in October, a nothing age for your modern football, but as above with Pickford, might we benefit from getting in somebody to keep him on his toes? Which brings me to JJK, hasnt really shown the talent he did when ive watched him for England and Everton yoot, not saying hes been really bad, but he looked very good going forward, something we have yet to see from him for us. I would be getting in somebody else and giving JJK a loan somewhere. He really needs games at his age and I consider it the best thing for at this stage in his career, hopefully he can really kick on and return a much-improved player.

LB
Imagine watching 1 of the better LBs in the league for 5 or 6 years, then when father time caught up to him you then find yourself with another 1. Lucas Digne, footballer. I also would be offering Baines a 12 month on reduced wages, cant think of many players able to slot him as back up. This of course depends on the likes of Robinson, who from what I gather has had a tough time out on loan and hasnt really kicked on as much as we would have liked. The other names here arent really worth considering.

CB
Unlike Baines, I personally wouldnt be offering Jags another contract. I love him, but hes 37 in August. Mina, sadly we have yet to see what he has to offer, hes been very up and down and sadly very injured, early days yet tho. Keane has been much improved this season, still turns like the QE2, but as I say has really improved and we could certainly do a lot worse. Talk of retaining Zooms pleases me, I just like him for some reason, even tho I really shouldnt, due to his ability to sometimes walk around the pitch like somebody whos wondering if they left the iron on. Holgate has played at RB out on loan and was very impressive at times. I see his future more as a CB myself and with Keane, Mina, Zooms and Holgate I would be fairly happy.

Engine room
Lots of players here, lets start with those I would be looking at moving on. McCarthy, Snides, Besic, Dowell, Williams, Connolly, Gana. Gana you say? Has the weapon lost it? Well no, I wouldnt be looking at moving him on, I just think he will look to move on, im sure im wrong, I often am. I almost put Beni in this list, but instead another loan is best for him at his age. The likes of Dowell and Williams I think will really struggle to break into the team any time soon and at some point, you either move them on or play them.

Andre Gomes is football sex, provided we retain him that leaves us with Iceland, TomTom, Gomes and Vlasic, which means we would need at least 1 other CM. Ideally we would need 2 if we did manage to ship out all the others, which is unlikely, so in that case we retain the best of them. I mean I cant say I know for sure what Williams, Connolly, Dowell or Beni even are.

Widers
The 2 boys from Brazil are just superb, they really are. Walcott started the season off reasonably well, but sadly looks spent, along with Lookman who must be robbing Marcos milk from the fridge or something, I can see both moving on. Hopefully we get a work permit for Henry, which means we would probably need another Right Winger/Forward. Im just gonna pretend Mirallas and Bolasie arent a thing.

ST
Harry Calvert Kane, a massive improvement from the boy this season, leading the line well, but we probably need a little extra here. Tosun doesnt really look the answer and Niasse isnt even a footballer. Sandro and Tarashjai are a thing.

So the tl:dr version.

In an ideal world we would buy the following players.

GK to put pressure on Pickford
RB to put pressure on Coleman
CB if Holgate isnt the answer
CM x 2, depending on Gana/Gomes
RW
ST x 2

I cant imagine we will sign 8 players and the above is a complete ideal world, a world in which we sell/loan everybody we dont need. Some areas, as I say above we could "make do". Something to consider is I havent named any of the yoots. We need a pathway for some of them to break through, we wont know if they are good enough if they never get a chance. Anyway, im sure Brands has all this sorted.
 

Jimmy Grimble

Player Valuation: £8m
Keepers : Virgin came highly rated from the goonereahs and by all accounts has had a very good season. I would like him to be clear number 2 to pickers next season and given the jersey for carabao cola milk cup games.
Looking at @MarcelsGoat squad list, the only position that screams major concern is striker. Keep dcl. Hit the eject button on all others and get 1 absolute quality striker in.
I’m happy enough to retain the services of zooms, but much over 25mill and I’d leave it. Gomes has shown enough to be worth a flutter at anything up to 40m. The one who could make or break next season is Gana. I fully understand him wanting cl at this stage of his career, but if he could be persuaded to stay I think we could have a great season next year.
 

banno

Player Valuation: £50m
How’s that pedantic? They literally won’t be in the 2019/20 squad unless we offer them a contract. May as well stick Messi in there too in case we offer him one as well.
They have time to be offered a contract so it is right at this time to leave them in there until it is confirmed either way. He did mention the offering of contracts to Jags and Baines. So no he didn't balls it up he actually took it into consideration.
 

Nymzee

Player Valuation: £70m
They have time to be offered a contract so it is right at this time to leave them in there until it is confirmed either way. He did mention the offering of contracts to Jags and Baines. So no he didn't balls it up he actually took it into consideration.
So why is Williams on the list but not discussed?
 

banno

Player Valuation: £50m
So why is Williams on the list but not discussed?
As the OP said 'With my thoughts mostly drifting to next season and what the future brings, its time to take a look at the squad we hopefully wont be taking into next season' which to me means current squad.
 

Nymzee

Player Valuation: £70m
As the OP said 'With my thoughts mostly drifting to next season and what the future brings, its time to take a look at the squad we hopefully wont be taking into next season' which to me means current squad.
We have a thread for the current squad. You can keep trying but I’m not going to acknowledge your stance here. @MarcelsGoat knows he made a light night blunder.
 

Eggs

Player Valuation: £70m
....I think whatever happens in the summer will be about prioritisation, and there will still need to be a strategy of offloading players in the interests of good housekeeping. The squad is simply to too big.

A few thoughts on MGs analysis;

I very much doubt Baines would accept a wages drop. He’ll have 2 or 3 year contract offers from elsewhere as well as certainty of getting game time. The squad is too big, Baines is very good but it makes sense if he and Jagielka move on. Lewis Gibson is a CB who can play LB and is the obvious one to step up to the squad and provide cover.

Holgate is definitely a RB who can cover at CB. The fact he’s on loan means he’s surplus to requirements and will be sold if an offer comes in. My opinion only, of course. The same applies to all loanees with the possible exception of Joe Williams. I can’t see Vlasic ever being an Everton player again.

If Zouma can’t be signed, we will need somebody of his type to compliment Keane and Mina.

We need a striker with quality, power, pace and athleticism. DCL will be a valuable asset but Tosun isn’t the answer.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Top