Fellaini Misses Derbies

Was referee Martin Atkinson correct to book Marouane Fellaini?

  • Yes - Should have been booked

    Votes: 22 45.8%
  • No - Never a booking

    Votes: 26 54.2%

  • Total voters
    48
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well i just spent some of my winnings on a chippy tea for me and the family!!! But they got the order wrong, so i ended up with a tiny plate of curry and chips, i am fuming beyond believe here.
 

Well i just spent some of my winnings on a chippy tea for me and the family!!! But they got the order wrong, so i ended up with a tiny plate of curry and chips, i am fuming beyond believe here.


Ha ha i won 80 quid on a horse a couple of weeks back mate, i came out of the bookies and the car had been clamped guess how much it was to get it unclamped.
 
Last edited:
Well i just spent some of my winnings on a chippy tea for me and the family!!! But they got the order wrong, so i ended up with a tiny plate of curry and chips, i am fuming beyond believe here.

Those morons! I'd be fuming if I was you, Mik. WTF is going on?
 

Who in there right mind has voted Yes to it being right that he should be booked?:@:@:unsure:. It was barely a foul, he quite clearly won the ball and only if were being really petty about it would you give a foul. To then go and give a Yellow is ludricous in the extreme. 1 of the worst decisions i have ever seen
 
he was lucky to still be on the pitch at half time. We had a corner late on in the 1st half and he was being held, which was out of order, but to try and get some space instead of shrugging the defender off he threw about 3 or 4 elbows into the face of the defender.

If the defender had gone down or appealed he was a gonner.

We could look on the brightside in that we know he is definitely available for the Arse and United games. I know its the Derby and I'm not trying to say its not important, but the Arsenal game is a 6 pointer and In all fairness, the games against the [Poor language removed] are going to be a tall order regardless of what side we put out. Against the Arse, the way theyre playing, having Fellaini available gives us a great chance to beat them, at home, under the floodlights, and close the gap on them.
 
Who in there right mind has voted Yes to it being right that he should be booked?:@:@:unsure:. It was barely a foul, he quite clearly won the ball and only if were being really petty about it would you give a foul. To then go and give a Yellow is ludricous in the extreme. 1 of the worst decisions i have ever seen

He was getting little digs in throughout the game, and the challenge was booked because of a combination of these and that. I think it was a fair decision.
 
He was getting little digs in throughout the game, and the challenge was booked because of a combination of these and that. I think it was a fair decision.

Not 1 foul was worthy of a yellow and all combined werent worthy of a yellow. The 'foul' he was booked for he won the ball and wasnt a foul. An all round woeful decision
 

Not 1 foul was worthy of a yellow and all combined werent worthy of a yellow. The 'foul' he was booked for he won the ball and wasnt a foul. An all round woeful decision

Fair enough, mate. I just feel that because Fellaini had been warned after 14 minutes, and that it was clear that he wouldn't be given the benefit of the doubt anymore, he should have been removed for his own protection when it was clear that we were in the driving seat.

I still think that the booking was fair, though. But I saw the game via stream so it might be the case that I'm wrong. You saw it live, which is clearly the better position to be in.
 
Fair enough, mate. I just feel that because Fellaini had been warned after 14 minutes, and that it was clear that he wouldn't be given the benefit of the doubt anymore, he should have been removed for his own protection when it was clear that we were in the driving seat.

I still think that the booking was fair, though. But I saw the game via stream so it might be the case that I'm wrong. You saw it live, which is clearly the better position to be in.

Are you saying he should have been booked for that incident alone?
 
I cant believe 18 have voted it was a booking. I missed the game today but have seen replays of the incident and if you look closely, screech got his toe to the ball. His foot also was only three foot off the ground. Never a booking but because of his intimidating size, screech is becoming a victim of officials much in the same way Big Dunc did!
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top