We absolutely need to be doing this too and this is what Everton have done well. Allardyce is lucky because if he’d gone into any other club outside the top 6 with 6 first team players missing he’d be in trouble. Here he’s had Holgate Kenny Davies and Calvert Lewin to come straight into the first team and Lookman an Vlasic to support.
It doesn’t get away from the fact though that we are having to turn to the kids because what should be our big gun players at their peak are either injured (Bolasie Coleman Barkley Funes Mori) or are not in form (Keane Klaasen Schneiderlin). In my opinion only when we have that balanced squad will we be able to compete like we have before across multiple comps. Players at their peak have the correct blend of power pace hunger and experience.
Where your strategy falls down is that whilst we wait for these kids to hit their peak the big clubs just wait for us to finish their development and take them. Holgate will be on the radar of every top club if he keeps up this form: young English centreback good on the ball fast and versatile across the back line? Gold dust.
Then we have to start all over again.
As a team we should have the captain of ROI as our RB, England international Keane partnering Argentinian international Mori, LB is a problem area.
Senegalese international Gueye with French international Schneiderlin and Dutch international Klaassen. Iceland international Siggurdson, Rooney and Belgian international Mirallas upfront.
On paper that is what our first team of players should be. Highly experienced internationals in their primes.
Instead it’s nowhere near that due to injuries and poor form.
In my eyes that’s the challenge facing Allardyce, either rehabilitate the above players or move them out and get better ones in. Teams of old lags and young players (no matter how good they might be) don’t often win many trophies without some big gun players to build around.
if we're just going off 'international caps' then yes that makes sense but for a club of our current premier league standing...whats the point?
We would end up finishing 7th each season (with the possibility of higher if a superior squad of players fell short).
In my mind even if we had 'excellent' young players they would still not see as much game time as we could offer them while still finishing 7th.
The way forward (in my view) is to build the very best squad of players with Keane (25 at season end) and Pickford (24 at season end) being the seniors.
Of course we should still aspire to sign one player each season who is in or approaching their peak years e.g Sigurdsson to ensure we finish 6 or better each season.
What we would then have (in principle) in 3 seasons time would be a core group of players aged 22-28 and experienced players 31+
Logically due to our 'continued' investment in young players we would in fact have 3 brackets;
21 and under
22-28
31+
That's the way forward, in my view.