I really don't think you've been paying attention to the academy if you think Tom Cannon was the same player before the Preston loan as after. It increased his value tenfold which helped keep the club afloat. The same way Harrison Armstrong has now got a great championship loan.
And if you can't see the improvement in recruitment from this scholar year to the last then that's just ignorance on your part.

the sale of Tom Cannon was the only difference between us and another 10 point deduction. Again I find it hard to comprehend that Vaughan had that much impact on him. Same with Armstrong, he’s a player that’s been on Championship/League One radars since October, it seems like it would be harder to mess up a loan move for him. Not disputing that Vaughan might have had some impact, but one was a player on the edge of the first team squad when he first came in and the others a lad that had played senior football for us before his loan. He’s hardly been the deciding factor in these players careers.
Same with the academy recruitment. He’s been in post 12 months. It’s hard to say exactly how much impact he’s had as the majority will have been done earlier -
Braiden Graham had been scouted and signed before that point.
Like don’t get me wrong, wouldn’t say he’s done a bad job, but I don’t get the histrionics like we’re letting some unreal player whisperer walk away.