Current Affairs EU In or Out

In or Out

  • In

    Votes: 688 67.9%
  • Out

    Votes: 325 32.1%

  • Total voters
    1,013
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it really the case though?

View attachment 243229

I have no idea "where" those exports are going to, but they've doubled since 2016. Again, it scarcely seems any more credible than the nutjobs on the other side shouting about net zero. Neither seems to have a great deal of actual data to back themselves up.
No idea, it would take a detailed look at inventory and trading to know mate. I just put them up as an alternative narrative, one from someone with some inside information.
 
Is it really the case though?

View attachment 243229

I have no idea "where" those exports are going to, but they've doubled since 2016. Again, it scarcely seems any more credible than the nutjobs on the other side shouting about net zero. Neither seems to have a great deal of actual data to back themselves up.
Is that stuff we manufacture from scratch here or process in some way and export? Just curious, sometimes the definitions are key. Point of origin etc.
 
Is that stuff we manufacture from scratch here or process in some way and export? Just curious, sometimes the definitions are key. Point of origin etc.
I don't know really. It just felt like the Welsh chap was shouting "Brexit" without really any of his working to back it up, just as Farage was shouting "Net Zero" with similarly scant evidence. For the Byline Times guy to laud it as the equivalent of Woodward and Bernstein seemed a bit much. He was just preaching to a different choir.

Incidentally, one of the comments on the YouTube video did mention a new EU environmental directive that (they said) prevented the Welsh plant from exporting to the EU because the plant isn't to the right standard (compared to the NL plant). They argued that the Dutch government gave them a lot of financial help, whereas the UK government didn't, but I'm not sure that's all that reliable either.


1706039654994.webp
 
I don't know really. It just felt like the Welsh chap was shouting "Brexit" without really any of his working to back it up, just as Farage was shouting "Net Zero" with similarly scant evidence. For the Byline Times guy to laud it as the equivalent of Woodward and Bernstein seemed a bit much. He was just preaching to a different choir.

Incidentally, one of the comments on the YouTube video did mention a new EU environmental directive that (they said) prevented the Welsh plant from exporting to the EU because the plant isn't to the right standard (compared to the NL plant). They argued that the Dutch government gave them a lot of financial help, whereas the UK government didn't, but I'm not sure that's all that reliable either.


View attachment 243239
I suspect the reality is a mix of all of it. Being outside the EU probably doesn't help. But our Govt has invested in Port Talbot, its just in the electric arc furnace which mothballs the blast furnaces- which is arguably linked to the net zero argument (see below).

My mate (knows the plant well and still has friends working there) reckons from a business perspective it's much cheaper to import ingots from over seas plants and roll them here. Guess it's the same for the arc furnaces which melt scrap for new metal. I suspect the net zero element is only part of the story for Tata. They'll have filthy plants elsewhere I suspect.

Anyway, on part my curiosity about what constitutes exports. As Port Talbot won't make from new, but will process stuff.
 
Of course we should never have left but it will take a very brave party to put in their manifesto that they will take the UK back into the EU .

This excludes the SNP who couldn't. I think even the Lads dropped it which is shameful
Could probably offer a new referendum.

However I think even if passed it would take some years for the Cion and other.MSs to agree to a readmission .

I was still working in 2016 and was in Brussels at the time. A lot of anger I am afraid.
 
Could probably offer a new referendum.

However I think even if passed it would take some years for the Cion and other.MSs to agree to a readmission .

I was still working in 2016 and was in Brussels at the time. A lot of anger I am afraid.

Anger at what, that we wanted to be an independent nation again ?….

The U.K. allowed the whole of its Empire to go its own way, one by one, because that’s what they wanted. Should we have been angry ?…..the EU empire needs to get a grip tbh……
 
Anger at what, that we wanted to be an independent nation again ?….

The U.K. allowed the whole of its Empire to go its own way, one by one, because that’s what they wanted. Should we have been angry ?…..the EU empire needs to get a grip tbh……
great britain dear, and are you drawing parallels of modern democracy to slave trade era 'shoot at will' policies? in your own time, no rush at all, you get your soldiers all lined up...
 
Anger at what, that we wanted to be an independent nation again ?….

The U.K. allowed the whole of its Empire to go its own way, one by one, because that’s what they wanted. Should we have been angry ?…..the EU empire needs to get a grip tbh……
I seem to have read somewhere about some spots of bother in Ireland India America Kenya etc before they were allowed to go their own way...

Carry on. Every day a school day in here
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.

🛒 Visit Shop

Support Grand Old Team by checking out our latest Everton gear!
Back
Top